(Part 2) Reddit mentions: The best breast pumps
We found 171 Reddit comments discussing the best breast pumps. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 65 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the products ranked 21-40. You can also go back to the previous section.
21. Spectra Baby USA S1 Hospital Grade Double/Single Breast Pump W Rechargeable Battery with Tote
- ABSOLUTELY THE MOST ADVANCED HOSPITAL GRADE PUMP AVAILABLE WITH RECHARGEABLE BATTERY!
- Closed system – hygienic for you and baby.
- Night light & timer,Super quiet, Letdown mode and fully adjustable program to best suit your body
- Everything you need for double pumping ON THE GO including S1 Pump motor, double collection kit with backflow hygienic protectors, ac adapter, inbuilt rechargeable battery(can be used plugged in or runs with the battery for about 1 hour on a full charge!), Designer tote bag.
- Powerful, adjustable suction yet so comfortable you won't realize how powerful it is!
Features:
Specs:
Color | Clear White,blue |
Size | 3 Piece Set |
Weight | 7.8 Pounds |
22. Nenesupply Pump Parts Compatible w Spectra S2 Spectra S1 Pumps Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories Spectra S1 Accessories Not Original Spectra Pump Parts Flange 24mm Duckbill Valves
- CONTENTS: 2 Medium 24mm FLANGES, 2 DUCKBILL VALVES, 2 BACKFLOW PROTECTORS, 2 BOTTLES (with One-Piece Travel Cap), and 2 TUBES. Use with Spectra S2, Spectra S1 and Spectra 9 Plus breastpumps.
- ALL PARTS MADE BY NENESUPPLY. NIPPLES NOT INCLUDED. Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories. Not original Spectra Pump Parts. Not original Spectra S1 accessories. Replace Spectra Flanges, Spectra Duckbill Valves, Spectra Backflow Protectors, Spectra Tubings, Spectra Bottles.
- COMPATIBLE and INTERCHANGEABLE WITH SPECTRA PUMP PARTS. Same suction power as OEM parts.
- DIFFERENT FLANGE SIZES AVAILABLE: 19mm, 21mm, 24mm, 27mm, 30mm. ONE-PIECE CAP enclosed for the bottles
- MATERIAL DO NOT CONTAIN ANY BPA. Can be sanitized with water steam, boiling water or microwave-steam bags. Comply with FDA regulations for plastic materials that contact food. Tested by independent labs for safety.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Clear White |
Height | 5.51 Inches |
Length | 5.91 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 10 Count (Pack of 1) |
Weight | 0.4375 Pounds |
Width | 4.72 Inches |
23. Bellababy 2 Pieces Manual Breast Pump Kit Includes a Rotatable Pump and a Silicone Pump Soft and Powerful Suction BPA Free
🎄 Come with 2 pcs of breast pump,a rotatable pump and a silicone pump🎄 The Rotatable pump can be 270° rotated,very convenient and easy to operate🎄 Food Grade PP and Silicone,BPA free🎄 Powerful Suction,help empty the breast fast and efficiently🎄 Separate air and breast milk,anti-back ...
24. Philips Avent Manual Comfort Breast Pump
More comfortable pumping position due to unique designSoft, textured massage cushion helps stimulate milk flowCompact, lightweight design of the pump body makes it easy to hold and position on your breastCompatible with other Philips Avent feeding products, such as Natural and Classic bottles and br...
Specs:
Color | Manual |
Height | 8.86 Inches |
Length | 3.54 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Weight | 0.78 Pounds |
Width | 7.72 Inches |
25. 21 mm Small Flagne w/Valve and Membrane for Spectra Breast Pumps S1, S2, M1, Spectra 9; Narrow (Standard) Bottle Neck; Made by Maymom
- 2x One-Piece Breastshield (21 mm internal diameter, specially designed for Sepctra Pumps) , 2 Valves, 4 Membranes; Compatible with Spectra pumps S1, S2, M1, Spectra 9 having the back-flow protector and narrow mouth bottle connector. If you must use a widemouth bottle, purchase a bottle converter (amazon keyword: maymom bottle conerter).
- Please measure your nipple diameter before making the purhcase. This flange's Nipple tunnel diameter is 21 mm, suitable for mothers with nipple diameter 17-19 mm; Connects to Standard-sized bottles (All Medela, Ameda Bottles and small version of Spectra, Playtex, Gerber, Dr Brown bottles etc; But NOT wide-mouth bottles like Wide version of Spectra). Please purchase/Use a Standard-Wide bottle converter for Wide mouth bottles.
- US FDA registered medical device (No. D192499); Complies with US FDA and EUstandards for containers that contact food and class II medical device; Test reports are online for your reference;
- Retail poly-bag packed; sealed by the manufacturer.
- Made of Bisphenol-A (BPA)/DEHP-free material and all components are steam safe for sterilization.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Yellow |
Height | 6.299212592 Inches |
Length | 3.149606296 Inches |
Size | Breastshield 21 mm |
Weight | 0.1 Pounds |
Width | 3.543307083 Inches |
26. NatureBond Silicone Breastfeeding Manual Breast Pump Milk Saver Suction. New 2019 Basic Pack with Cover Lid in Hardcover Gift Box. BPA Free
★ Most Value for Money Basic Pack with Dust Cover Lid - Silicone Manual Breast Pump collects "let-down" / breast milk leaks and relieves engorgement using pure natural suction pressure. Every ounce of breast milk is precious. Save it for your baby.★ Extremely Soft, Comfortable and Safe - High Qu...
Specs:
Color | Basic Kit |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 7 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 1 Count (Pack of 1) |
Width | 3 Inches |
27. Whisper Wear Hands Free Double Breast Pump Set
Hands-free double breast pumpWearable under clothesTwo pumps, two stems, and four valvesStylish, lightweight carrying bagCooler pack holds six bags and cools up to eight hours
28. Haakaa 4oz/100ml Silicone Breast Pump with Suction Base 100% Food Grade Silicone BPA PVC and Phthalate Free
Award winning, best-selling, nursing mom and lactation consultant recommended. Patented design. Pat. No. USD808,006SMaterial: 100% food grade silicone. Soft and comfortable. BPA PVC and Phthalate FreeEasy to use and easy to clean. Dishwasher safe.Simply suction to your breast and let the pump do the...
Specs:
Color | Clear White |
Height | 8.78346455797 Inches |
Length | 4.76771653057 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 1 Count (Pack of 1) |
Weight | 0.1763698096 Pounds |
Width | 2.81889763492 Inches |
29. Medela Symphony Breast Pump Kit, Double Pumping System Includes Everything Needed to Start Pumping with Symphony, Made Without BPA
EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO BEGIN SINGLE OR DOUBLE PUMPING TODAY: The Symphony Breast Pump Kit includes everything needed to start pumping with Medela’s hospital-grade Symphony pump, which functions as a single or double breast pump based on your preferenceSYMPHONY BREAST PUMP KIT ALSO INCLUDES ACCESSO...
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 8.3 Inches |
Length | 5.2 Inches |
Release date | February 2015 |
Size | 19 Piece Set |
Weight | 0.6 Pounds |
Width | 6.9 Inches |
30. Philips AVENT Single Electric Comfort Breast Pump SCF332/33
More comfortable pumping position due to unique designChoose from 3 expression settings (low, medium, high) after starting in the gentle stimulation modeSoft, warm stimulation massage cushion now has a soft, warm texture intended to help stimulate breast milk flowCompact, lightweight design for ease...
Specs:
Color | White,violet |
Height | 10 Inches |
Length | 12 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | February 2015 |
Size | 1 Count (Pack of 1) |
Weight | 1.68 Pounds |
Width | 4 Inches |
31. Abergele Women's Hands Free Band Strapless Breast Pump Bra, Black, XX-Large
- Abergele Hands Free Pumping Band Strapless Breast Pump Bra
- Item styling: Push-Up
- Underwire type: Wire Free
- Strap type: Adjustable
Features:
Specs:
Color | Black |
Height | 0.7 Inches |
Length | 7.8 Inches |
Size | XX-Large |
Weight | 11 ounces |
Width | 7.4 Inches |
32. Nenesupply Compatible Tubing for Spectra S2 Spectra S1 Spectra 9 Plus Avent Ameda Purely Yours Replace Spectra Tubing Ameda Tubing Not Original Spectra Pump Parts Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories
- 2 REPLACEMENT TUBES for SPECTRA S2, SPECTRA S1, 9 Plus Breastpumps, Avent Electric, and Ameda Purely Yours breastpumps. MADE BY NENESUPPLY. NOT ORIGINAL SPECTRA PUMP PARTS. Not original Spectra S2 Tubing
- LONGER THAN OEM TUBING: 42" in length. 9" longer than OEM tube. Easy to use while pumping. Replace Spectra tubing, Avent tubing, and Ameda Tubing.
- NO MORE TEARING ENDS: Made from sturdy materials that can sustain multiple pulls and stretches every day. BPA FREE and DEHP FREE. Can be sanitized with Micro-steam bag, water steam or boiling water.
- NO MORE FALLING TUBES and EASY TO PLUG ONTO THE PUMP: Fit the pump tightly. Save your precious time.
- FDA REGISTERED MEDICAL DEVICE. Manufactured by faclities in compliance with FDA quality control system. Comply with EU Commission Regulation plastic materials that contact food.
Features:
Specs:
Height | 5.905511805 Inches |
Length | 6.692913379 Inches |
Size | 1 pack |
Weight | 0.1 Pounds |
Width | 0.787401574 Inches |
33. BelleMa S5 Single / Double Hospital Grade Electric Breast Pumps, With IDC technology, Touch Screen Cordless
IDC : control left or right pumps independently, no suction reduction while dual pumping3D SYSTEM : easy to assessble and clean, innovative 3D pump system: Imitate a baby's feeding behaEFFICIENT : hospital grade closed system anti-backflow, highly efficient power up to 250 mmHgTOUCH SCREEN : easy to...
34. Maymom 4 Count Duckbill Valves for Spectra. Designed for Spectra S1 Spectra S2 Spectra Pump not Original Spectra Pump Parts Replace Spectra Valve (Semitransparent)
Duckbills for spectra s1 s2 pumps. Go around the hole type. Contains 4 duckbill valves for Spectra. Work with Spectra S2, Spectra S1, Spectra 9 Plus, Spectra Dew 350.Made by maymom. NOT original Spectra pump parts. Work with Spectra S2 accessories.Semi transparent. You can see how milk go through th...
Specs:
Color | Semitransparent |
Size | Potty-Training285 |
35. Maymom Backflow Protector Compatible with Spectra S2 Spectra S1 and 9 Plus Breastpump Not Original Spectra Pump Parts Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories Replace Spectra Backflow Protector
Contains 2 Backflow Protectors, including 2 Large Caps, 2 Small Caps, and 2 Silicone Diaphragms. Replacement for Spectra Backflow Protectors, both new and old versions.Designed to work with the flanges of Spectra S1, Spectra S2, and 9 Plus Breastpumps. Complete compatibility. No milk will enter the ...
Specs:
Color | White |
Height | 1.968503935 Inches |
Length | 5.905511805 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 2 Count (Pack of 1) |
Weight | 0.125 Pounds |
Width | 2.755905509 Inches |
36. Manual Breast Pump, Silicone Hand Pump for Breastfeeding, Quiet Portable Milk Pump Kit by LotFancy, 2-Speed Pump Design, BPA Free with 2-Pack 5oz Breastmilk Bottles and Nipple
37. PumpMom Replacement Silicone Membrane, for Spectra S2 Spectra S1 and 9 Plus Breastpump Backflow Protector and Maymom Backflow Protectors; Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories or Spectra Pump Parts
- COMPATIBLE MODELS - 4 Replacement Silicone Membranes for Spectra Backflow Protectors and Nenesupply Backflow Protectors.
- SAFE MATERIAL - Made with Food Grade Silicone, BPA free.
- THIS IS AFTERMARKET PART MADE BY PumpMom. Not Original Spectra S2 Accessories.
- All items packaged in retail pack, sealed by manufacturer for best protection and hygiene.
- 100% MONEY BACK GUARANTEE - If you experience any issues we offer a complete No Questions Asked Money Back Guarantee.
Features:
Specs:
Color | 4pc |
Height | 4.724409444 Inches |
Length | 0.2362204722 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 4 Count (Pack of 1) |
Width | 4.724409444 Inches |
38. Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump Stopper 1 pk (Blue)
- Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump Stopper 1 pk (Blue)
- Made from 100% silicone. BPA, PVC and Phthalate free
- Sits tight in the neck of your Haakaa breast pump and will stop any spills or accidents.
- This product can be sterilized with any steam sterilizing system or boiling water.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 0.99999999898 Inches |
Length | 2.79921259557 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 1 Count (Pack of 1) |
Width | 1.40157480172 Inches |
39. 2L Portable Electric Milking Machine Milker Cow Sheep Goat Milking Machine Manual Pump One Quart One Teat Milker Claw Milking Teat Cups Goat Sheep Milking Machine (Sheep Milking Machine)
Specs:
Height | 6.299212592 Inches |
Length | 10.629921249 Inches |
Weight | 0.0220462262 Pounds |
Width | 7.086614166 Inches |
40. Maymom Flange Kit for Philips Avent Comfort Breastpump, One-Side; Flange, Valve, Tube, Massage Pad, Suction Membrane, Cap
- CONTENTS: 1x duckbill valve, 1x tubing, 1x massage pad, 1x suction membrane, 1x top cap 1x flange. Flange with the massage pad is 25 mm; 30 mm without the massage pad.
- This kit is only for one side; Buy two units if you pump on both breasts at the same time. This kit does not include any bottles.
- COMPATIBLE with Philips Avent Single/Double Comfort Electric Breast Pump but not the old ISIS pumps. This kit is not the original Philips Avent kit or original Philips Avent accessories. Maymom is not affiliated with Philips nor does Philips endorse the product.
- Made by Maymom: All items are packaged, sealed and made by manufacturer Maymom, NOT Philips Avent.
- BPA/DEHP FREE. IN RETAIL PACK.; Comply with EU and USA FDA regulations for materials that contact food. Tested by independent labs for quality and safety. All items are packaged in retail pack.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Transparent |
Height | 4.724409444 Inches |
Length | 5.905511805 Inches |
Size | 25 mm |
Weight | 0.25 Pounds |
Width | 3.149606296 Inches |
🎓 Reddit experts on breast pumps
The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where breast pumps are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
The Spectra S1 is an amazing pump. I've been using mine now multiple times a day (I exclusively pump) for 10 months and I love it. It's portable (you can use it with or without the charger), fairly quiet and it's comfortable! And you can hack it easily to fit Medela parts.
http://www.amazon.com/Spectra-Baby-USA-Hospital-Rechargeable/dp/B00FYVQREI/ref=sr_1_3_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1463413291&sr=8-3&keywords=spectra+s1
Another vote for the Spectra! I use it with the Maymom version of Avent comfort flanges, and it's so comfortable, effective, and quiet. I love the two settings: quick and gentle to encourage letdown, then slow and strong for the rest of the session. Note that the Spectra doesn't come with a bag, so if you ever pump away from home you'll need a bag for it.
I have a Spectra pump that I’ve been using since our girl was born in July. When I need to transfer milk to bags, I use the Target Up & Up brand. We’ve had zero issues freezing/thawing milk in these.
In terms of every day use, I originally got these Nene supply bottles from Amazon because they screw directly into the Spectra and fit the Phillips Avent bottle tops (Avent bottles were recommended by a friend). However, our girl does better with the Dr. Brown bottles so I got adapter pieces so I could pump directly into them (whatever I pump at work, she drinks the next day).
Happy to answer any questions! Thinking about pumping as a FTM is so daunting!
Just FYI: If anyone is looking to get a manual breast pump as well, here's a set that includes a built-in bottle with nipple (and cover) along with a bonus Haakaa-style suction pump:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JCH3BB9/
Obviously it's not the brand-name version, but you can't beat the $12.99 price, plus the reviews are good and a friend of mine says it worked for her!
I love my Avent manual and have heard from others that they love theirs too. This is the one I have: http://www.amazon.com/Philips-Avent-Manual-Comfort-Breast/dp/B009YSYCZS/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1396482088&sr=8-1&keywords=avent+manual+pump
I actually use it over my Ameda double electric - it's faster and has better suction!
I have one, but as a FTM without my kid here yet, I pretty much know jack shit. However, after searching for the S2 on Amazon, I found that customers also bought this and other various things to make life easier or that can work with Medela bottles/parts/etc like these flange adapters. The top customer review had some info about how they used medela bottles with pumpin pal flanges and didn't have to "hack" anything or cut tubing. Have a look around. I am getting a better grasp on everything by doing this.
Throw a haakaa in the side she isn't nursing on as she feeds from the favorite boob. You'll collect some milk and it will relieve the pressure! They are like $20 on Amazon.
I have this knockoff brand and it worked great:
https://smile.amazon.com/NatureBond-Silicone-Breastfeeding-Air-Tight-Hardcover/dp/B07GP1Y3VM
There was a similar setup a few years back, but they weren't so estheticly designed. They did, however, use typical storage bags, so that expense was much less. Powered by AAs, ah, I actually have a pair! Whisper Wear! Whisper Wear Hands Free Double Breast Pump Set https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000H7F7H2/ref=cm_sw_r_taa_QKsCyb2593PWB
~L~
I love the [haakaa pump] (https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01N7GHVI9/ref=mp_s_a_1_4_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1518860758&sr=8-4&keywords=haakaa&dpPl=1&dpID=51D60qh%2BrEL&ref=plSrch). It's quiet, easy to clean, cheap, small, and I can fill up 200ml in one session, sometimes in 10 minutes or an hour depending on the boob at the time. I usually don't use the measurements on the pump and just pour the milk into a container when the pump is about half full so it doesn't detach and spill when it's full/heavy. It's not exactly a pump, rather it just suctions onto the boob.
Buy the symphony tubing at least. The part that connects to the symphony is different from the pump in style's. The rest is the same. The symphony is much better than the pump in style, I also have a workplace with the symphony and the power is much better than my pump in style at home. I purchased this kithttp://www.amazon.com/Medela-Symphony-Double-Pumping-System/dp/B000C13SXI The extra pump parts and bottles are a plus, too. For extra bottles beyond that, the Gerber first essentials bottles are compatible with Medela pump parts and super cheap. The kit I linked to is only $30, by the way.
I have the Phillips Avent Single Electric Pump:
https://www.amazon.ca/Philips-Avent-Electric-SCF332-11/dp/B00PF83R6G/ref=sr_1_sc_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1510601671&sr=8-1-spell&keywords=phillips+event+breast+pump
I definitely don't have any expectations (except that it will be hard!)- but like I said to someone else, I'm a planner so it's hard to kind of just let go and realize that a lot depends on the baby. And I'm definitely not married to the idea that I HAVE to breastfeed, either- like, I want to and hope to and I'm willing to put in the effort to try but if for some reason it's not working out, I'm not going to stress myself out over it or be miserable forever because I hate it. I think happy mom/formula feeding is better overall for baby than a stressed out, resentful mother/breastfeeding.
Abergele Hands Free Pumping Band Strapless Breast Pump Bra Nursing and Expression Bustier 100% Cotton with Three Position Hook and Eye Closure Black X https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DVSSM2L/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apap_qqrBI2rV67z5v
For $20 this one has worked well for me so far- can't use it as a substitute for a regular bra but works fine with a nursing bra. I got an XL and XXL so you would probably need like a small or medium I would think. I have no idea what actual bra size I am now- was 34 DD pre pregnancy so Def bigger than that lol. I'm no expert tho- only 7 days pp with a little guy in the NICU so I'm exclusively pumping for now but this bra works well for me!
I use a Spectra with Medela parts. I like the Medela flanges better, the spectra ones didn’t fit right. For this setup I bought:
Also, random tip I wish I knew earlier: if you’re having any pain while pumping, I recommend using coconut oil on the inside edge of the flanges and on your areola
I either get dom from Thai pharmacy online or eBay. For my pump Im gonna post the link for you, this thing is the best money ive ever spent!!!
https://www.amazon.com/S5-Hospital-Electric-technology-Cordless/dp/B078J7ZZHK/ref=sr_1_sc_1_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1539209650&sr=8-1-spell&keywords=bellma+breast+pumps
We just replaced the duckbill valves and back flow protectors... I think we just got them off amazon! Links below but keep in mind they are in Canadian prices :)
https://www.amazon.ca/Maymom-Protector-Breastpumps-Diaphragm-Replacement/dp/B01BREQFME/ref=mp_s_a_1_2?keywords=spectra+parts&qid=1563807649&s=gateway&sprefix=spectra&sr=8-2
https://www.amazon.ca/Maymom-Duckbill-Spectra-Designed-Original/dp/B07HY365KD/ref=mp_s_a_1_3?keywords=spectra+parts&qid=1563807672&s=gateway&sprefix=spectra&sr=8-3
Price History
CamelCamelCamel - [Info] │ Keepa - [Info]
_
Don't En Passant these deals.
^(Info) ^| ^(Developer) ^| ^(Inquiries) ^| ^(Support Me!) ^| **[^(Report Bug)](/message/compose?to=The_White_Light&subject=Bug+Report&message=%2Fr%2Famazondealsus%2Fcomments%2Fdp0qtn%2Fmanual_breast_pump_expires_1110_coupon40rqydcp%2Ff5rw6ne%2F%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0APlease+explain+here+what+you+expected+to+happen%2Fwhat+went+wrong.)**
Is this what you are looking for? backflip membranes
I used these when pumping and they were great.
I’ve been here! Too many times. Amazon saved the day after my most recent one - cat jumped up on my night stand to lose two good ounces all over the wall and floor! Buy a stopper Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump Stopper 1 pk (Blue) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01MG8FUSC/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_kRZWDb1GS7AWT
A goat milker would be a better model to base you project on. Cow milkers have too much suction even with the regulator. Also. A goat milker is pretty inexpensive.
Something like this:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07FHZ21Y1/ref=sspa_dk_detail_2?psc=1&pd_rd_i=B07FHZ21Y1&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_p=21517efd-b385-405b-a405-9a37af61b5b4&pd_rd_wg=L4GWO&pf_rd_r=D3N0PJDZQK60JGE4K604&pf_rd_s=desktop-dp-sims&pf_rd_t=40701&pd_rd_w=CITvb&pf_rd_i=desktop-dp-sims&pd_rd_r=3032e2c7-e8d1-11e8-bf17-01182ac8a987.
I'm all for DIY but the mechanics and possible injuries sustained would point me to a bought one. Just my 2 cents.