Reddit mentions: The best cat repellent mats
We found 69 Reddit comments discussing the best cat repellent mats. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 10 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.
1. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats , Large, 48 X 20 inch - Pet Proof Your Home - Battery-Operated Electronic Repellent Mat
- TRAINING TOOL: Use ScatMat training mats to teach dogs and cats of all sizes to not play on the furniture, jump on countertops and which areas of the house are off limits
- EASY TO USE: Place the training mat indoors on the area you want your pet to avoid; When your pet steps on the mat, they will receive a safe yet startling static correction
- CUSTOMIZABLE CORRECTION: 3 correction levels allow you to choose either a low, medium or high setting based on the temperament of your cat or dog
- 5 SIZES: Available in a variety of sizes to cover different areas in your home
- U.S.-BASED CUSTOMER CARE: Our pet product experts are here to help you and your pet and are available by phone, email or chat if you have any questions
Features:
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 48 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | March 2006 |
Size | Large 48" x 20" |
Weight | 1.6 Pounds |
Width | 20 Inches |
2. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats - Sofa Size 12 X 60 inch - Pet Proof Your Home - Battery-Operated Electronic Repellent Mat
FURNITURE PROTECTION: Use the mat to train your dog or cat to stay off furniture, countertops and other areas of the home that you want to protectINDOOR USE: Use this battery-operated training mat anywhere inside your home. It is recommended not to place heavy objects on the mat as there is potentia...
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 2.5 Inches |
Length | 21 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Sofa 60" x 12" |
Weight | 2 Pounds |
Width | 3.75 Inches |
3. 13ft Garden Cat Scat Spike Mat, Anti-Cats Network Digging Stopper Prickle Strip Home Spike Deterrent Mat (6.5ft2PCS)
- 【Garden Protector】Keep cats , dogs and other animals away from your garden, flower beds and vegetable patches with our cat scat mat .
- 【Wide Use】This security spikes can be used indoors & outdoors, such as lawn grass, gardens, tables, sofas, chairs or any other valuable assets.
- 【Easy to Install】This cat deterrent mat can be easily paved and installed anywhere,like fences, gates, sheds, railings, ledges, boundary walls. The curved hook can be cut and fixed in the soil.
- 【High-quality】Made from durable and long-lasting PP, our pet deterrent mat is unbreakable and harmless deterrent solution.
- 【Large & Adjustable Size】Pack of 2, Size:78.7*11.8in(200*30cm), our cat scat mat can be cut shorter and networked wider or longer as pet your need with the sided snap-fit buckle.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Black |
Size | 13ft |
4. PetSafe ScatMat, Large, 48-Inch by 20-Inch
- Quickly discourages pets from developing bad habits
- Safe, low-voltage battery -operated system can be used anywhere
- 9-volt battery lasts for up to 6 months or 1, activations
- Activity indiactor shows when pets are no longer testing scatmat
Features:
Specs:
Height | 3.5 Inches |
Length | 10 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Large |
Weight | 1.6 Pounds |
Width | 6.75 Inches |
5. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats, Curved Size 50 x 12 inch - Pet Proof Your Home - Battery-Operated Electronic Repellent Mat
FURNITURE PROTECTION: Use the mat to train your dog or cat to stay off furniture, countertops and other areas of the home that you want to protectINDOOR USE: Use this battery-operated training mat anywhere inside your homeEASY TO STORE: This clear, flexible vinyl mat easily rolls up for easy storage...
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 2.75 Inches |
Length | 3.5 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Curved 50" x 12" |
Weight | 1.08 Pounds |
Width | 12.75 Inches |
6. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats, Strip Size 46 x 3 inch - Pet Proof Your Home - Battery-Operated Electronic Repellent Mat
- TRAINING TOOL: Use ScatMat training mats to teach dogs and cats of all sizes to not play on the furniture, jump on countertops and which areas of the house are off limits
- EASY TO USE: Place the training mat indoors on the area you want your pet to avoid; When your pet steps on the mat, they will receive a safe yet startling static correction
- CUSTOMIZABLE CORRECTION: 3 correction levels allow you to choose either a low, medium or high setting based on the temperament of your cat or dog
- EASY TO STORE: Simply roll up this clear, flexible vinyl mat when you need to store it away
- 5 SIZES: Available in a variety of sizes to cover different areas in your home
- BATTERY OPERATED: ScatMat training mat is battery operated and requires a 9-Volt battery (not included); You can also purchase an optional ScatMat Power Adaptor if desired (not included)
- QUALITY GUARANTEED: PetSafe brand has been a trusted global leader in pet behavior, containment and lifestyle innovations for nearly 30 years; We help pets and their people live happily together
- U.S.-BASED CUSTOMER CARE: Let our pet product experts help
Features:
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 6.75 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Strip 46" x 3" |
Weight | 0.6 pounds |
Width | 3 Inches |
7. Pet Shock Mat - 60”x12” Pet Training Mat for Cats & Dogs, 3 Training Modes Pet Shock Pad, Indoor Use Dogs & Cats Training Mat for Sofa w/LED Indicator, Intelligent Safety Protect, Long Battery Life
3 Optional Training Modes - DOGCARE pet training mat provides 3 optional training modes (Static Mode, Beep Mode, Static + Beep Mode). We would recommend the owner to use static + beep mode first. Once the pet is familiar with the beep sound, then the owner can switch the training pad to Beep mode. L...
Specs:
Color | white |
Height | 3.35 Inches |
Length | 12.6 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 60"x12" |
Weight | 1 Pounds |
Width | 2.17 Inches |
8. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat Extension 48 x 20 inches, Large, Extension only
POWER PACK AND BATTERY NOT INCLUDEDConnects to your existing ScatMat for expanded coverageExtension Mat must be connected to ScatMat with Power Pack - SOLD SEPARATELYFor any size cat or dogFor indoor use onlyCall, chat or email with our expert PetSafe US-based customer care specialists six days a we...
Specs:
Color | Clear |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 48 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | March 2006 |
Size | Large 48" x 20" |
Weight | 1.5 Pounds |
Width | 20 Inches |
9. High Tech Pet Sofa Scram Sonic Pad Pet Deterrent
Uses audible sound to keep your pet at bayWorks quickly and effectively without applying shock or pain to your petWorks on cats and dogsUse on sofas, chairs, countertops, beds, in front of doorways and on trash cansMeasures 2-inch high by 12-inch deep by 59-inch long
Specs:
Color | BLACK |
Height | 4 Inches |
Length | 16 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 58" long by 11 1/4" wide |
Weight | 2.5 Pounds |
Width | 14 Inches |
10. PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats, Sofa Size 30 x 16 inch, Pet Proofing Mat
- TRAINING TOOL: Use ScatMat training mats to teach dogs and cats of all sizes to not play on the furniture, jump on countertops and which areas of the house are off limits
- EASY TO USE: Place the training mat indoors on the area you want your pet to avoid; When your pet steps on the mat, they will receive a safe yet startling static correction
- CUSTOMIZABLE CORRECTION: 3 correction levels allow you to choose either a low, medium or high setting based on the temperament of your cat or dog
- EASY TO STORE: Simply roll up this clear, flexible vinyl mat when you need to store it away
- 5 SIZES AVAILABLE: Available in a variety of sizes to cover different areas in your home
- BATTERY OPERATED: ScatMat training mat is battery operated and requires a 9-Volt battery (not included); You can also purchase an optional ScatMat Power Adaptor if desired (not included)
- PROTECT LARGER AREAS: If you need to protect a larger area in your home, purchase Scatmat Extension Mats (sold separately)
- QUALITY GUARANTEED: PetSafe brand has been a trusted global leader in pet behavior, containment and lifestyle innovations for nearly 30 years; we help pets and their people live happily together
Features:
Specs:
Color | clear |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 30 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | March 2006 |
Size | Medium 30" x 16" |
Weight | 0.5 Pounds |
Width | 16 Inches |
🎓 Reddit experts on cat repellent mats
The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where cat repellent mats are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
I have a cat shopping list for myself, here are some links to a few of the things I plan to purchase and thought could help you.
I would consider getting as many of these covers as necessary, and a few scratching posts to put nearby.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00XV586VQ/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_kWzyDb2V14202
You could also try placing these in front of or on top of the couch.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0721735K9/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_iZzyDbHT6AA8Q
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0017XBDPA/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_KZzyDbXTT8JGG
They also make claw covers that come in multiple colors. Regardless of what you do, please don't discard your cat, and do your best to trim his nails. I use this one, it's pretty good.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00JENKK8Q/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_P3zyDbQCRECV3
Remember that encouraging good behavior with treats and appropriate outlets for scratching is vital to the health of your pet and the sanity of your household. Do your best not to punish, simply redirect them to a better option. (Basically put the cat scratching posts near the couch or any problem areas while covering the furniture with hard plastic to redirect his energy.)
I'm dealing with the exact same issue, our boy has start pawing at the bedroom door and the rattling is becoming too much to handle. Glad to have your insight on the motion sensor air spray as that was the option my fiance was considering. We haven't tried this personally yet, but I was looking into a ScatMat. It seems like it would extend far enough in front of the bedroom door so our cat can't just try to lean his way against it to paw. Good luck and I would love to hear about any results!
Few tips:
I would suggest a ssscat spray can or ssscat mat. Worked like a charm for us! The mat is more of an investment up front, but you'll never need to purchase replacement cannisters:
https://www.amazon.ca/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Large-inches/dp/B0017XBDPA/ref=sr_1_5?keywords=ssscat&qid=1574462631&sr=8-5&th=1
Put the can or mat just outside your bedroom door and they'll either have the shit scared out of them by the spray can, or they'll get a mild shock from stepping on the mat (which is enough for them to learn not to go there).
For my one cat we bought her a stool that wad about counter height so she could watch what was going on and out worked. To train her, when we caught her on the counter we would place get on the stool and praise her. Other times i would place her on the stool and give her a treat. She quickly learned the stool was hers and she was happy.
My other cat was not so easily trained. For him we had to get SSScat spray. It's motion activated and sprays an air blast. A couple of these and your cat won't be back. http://amzn.com/B000RIA95G
If all else fails they do sell scat mats which give a mild shock when a cat walks on it. It sounds mean but the highest level is like a static shock. It did work. I had to use this for my smartest cat when everything else failed. http://amzn.com/B0007NWNM8
I find these things work better because they work whether you are there or not. All you cat has currently learned is he can't be on the counter when someone is in tha room. You didn't say anything about being on the counter when you are not in the room :)
ScatMat
This will be much better and safer. It also has the benefit of not being able to reset when you aren't there. With ideas like yours, cats often learn to set off traps so they can go do what they want anyway. The scatmat won't stop working after the cat jumps up the first time
Definitely understand the counter concerns. I’d recommend the scat mats then. Should be able to get a decent size for about $40 and up.
For example:
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats , Large, 48 X 20 inch, Pet Proof Your Home, Electronic Training Mat https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0007NTBJ6/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_qVZSDbJAAC9XY
They also have these motion sensor activated compressed air cans as well.
As for the tunnels, there are a few cheap four way tunnels with crinkle material. Would highly recommend a window perch; they have ones that can fold up while still hanging on the window, so you can close the blinds or shutters.
https://www.amazon.com/d/Cat-Repellent-Mats/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Strip-inches/B0001AB42W
you can get plastic garden spike mats used to keep cats from destroying plants. They aren't tough or sharp enough to be harmful, and they're a lot easier to put on counter tops and move when you want to cook etc, and look better than tinfoil. They've worked well in keeping the cat off our counter
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07RY78GH3/ref=cm_sw_r_tw_dp_U_x_zjSwDbCM3R29D
(you can probably find them at the dollar store for a significantly lower price)
I tried foil and plastic carpet runners with the feet right side up and kitten did not care, she would lay on top of them! So far I have had good luck with these training mats, you put them on the surface you want to train your cat to stay off of and they give a little shock when the cat touches it.
​
https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/dp/B0007NWNM8/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1537189864&sr=8-3&keywords=cat+shock+mat
We use a sofa-sized Scat Mat across the front seats to keep cats off them. I suppose you could get two of them and put one on the top as well. They run off batteries, and roll-up easily, so they are very simple to use every day and put away when you need to drive the Jeep.
Yeah, that would be pretty annoying. We catsit my mom's two blind kitties sometimes, and one of them likes to explore the bedside table, resulting in knocking water cups off and once turning off my wife's APAP machine (for sleep apnea.) That was rather annoying. There is a very easy solution though. There's a product called a ScatMat that you can put on any area you want kitties to not get on, that gives a small shock if they step on it. It's not dangerous, just startling. For both of my mom's cats, and another cat we catsit, it took exactly once for them to never get on the areas again. Then we returned it to PetZoo or whichever one we got it from because they have 90 day return policy.
If you'd like them to not be on your desk or other surfaces, may I recommend: https://smile.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/
No, officer. It's a scatmat to keep my pets indoors when I leave the door open for fresh air...
I made it myself to save money.
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats, Curved Size 50 x 12 inch, Pet Proofing Mat https://www.amazon.com/dp/B005G6LFLG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_n1f1Db37S8S05
For $50 my tree hasn’t been touched once since installing :)
There's something out there called the Scat Mat which is a plastic mat with wires running through that sends a shock (feels like a static shock like when you rub your feet on carpet and touch something metal).
I used it to keep my cat off my kitchen island. It worked for about a week and then my cat got wise and realized that she could step between the wires. So beware if you have a smart/determined cat.
The Scat Mat is an electric pad you put on the couch, counter, anyplace. I haven't used it, but I know it exists. I don't think he's getting enough exercise. He may need more rough, run, and higher energy outlets than just a simple walk.
something like this
Couldn't you also just electrify the floor?
Think like a scatmat that runs around your insulated doors and windows.
Get a Scatmat. They work brilliantly and you can just move them around to spots you don't want them on till they get trained...which usually only takes a shock or two.
Solution
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0007NTBJ6/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?qid=1395105041&sr=8-1&pi=SY200_QL40
Over here. They are remarkably efficient. Just one zap was all it took. Now she won't even go near the mats. I'm pretty sure the batteries went dead a long time ago, but she won't approach them for anything.
It's harsh treatment, obviously, but we really had no alternative. We just could not keep her off the sofa, and we had to replace two furniture pieces before we found the mats. My wife was ready to take her for one final trip to the vet. The mat probably saved her life.
I never found something satisfying, so never bought a Maggie, although I adore them. At one time I considered this
Metal screen is radical but I'm afraid it will have a detrimental effect to the sound.
http://www.amazon.com/Battery-Operated-Scat-Mat-48x20/dp/B0007NTBJ6
And make sure they have a few towers next to the forbidden zones so that you can easily redirect them to an allowed climbing place.
May I recommend the Scat Mat? Place it on your table or whatever. She will stop jumping up. Here is one in action.
They have something called a scat mat, which despite its slightly off-putting name, works wonders. It's just a plastic mat with a wire going back and forth connected to a battery pack. If the animal touches two points of the wire it closes the circuit and delivers a mild shock. Worked great on my mom's cats when she got a new suede sofa.
They cost $40, but they fuckin work.
Does your vanity have the space for a ScatMat? We had issues with one of our cats counter surfing in our kitchen so we gave that a try. After a few shocks, he’s not up on the counter nearly as much anymore. Not a 100% fix for us but it was worth the $40! It may work wonders for you!
Gotta use a scat mat if you want to get proper entrainment.
There are these plastic spike thingies you can put in your flower pots to discourage the cat from getting in there. Cheapest are the ones at Daiso. Dunno if you have that store..so here is a link to them on Amazon.
Cat Scat Mat With Garden Spikes, Anti-cat Prickle Strip w/12 Staples, 12 Strips, Tape, Deter Dog Digging Yard, Fence, Pots, Repel Critters Climbing Birdfeeder, Safe no Hurt,11.8inx6.5ft Roll https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PDNH18L/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_pXsmDb1D1GH9F
If you don't want the cat to jump on something, like your counters, then try these:
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats , Sofa Size, 12 X 60 inch, Pet Proof Your Home, Electronic Training Mat https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0017XBDPA/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_UYsmDb6SZ2MJE
Or these Ssscat Spray Ssscat Kit https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000RIA95G/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_sZsmDbWXRRJSB
What do you mean by 'drops things'?
how about these?
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0007NTBJ6?pc_redir=1408202906&robot_redir=1
Maybe a scatmat? https://www.amazon.com/d/Cat-Repellent-Mats/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/B0007NTBJ6
​
3 Cats. After a couple mornings of door claw symphonies, my GF bought this Bad Boy
http://www.amazon.com/Battery-Operated-Scat-Mat-48x20/dp/B0007NTBJ6
Throw one of these on it
https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/dp/B0007NTBJ6
Is that pad electrified?
https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Sofa-inches/dp/B0017XBDPA
Scat mat in front of the door?
https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Large-inches/dp/B0007NTBJ6
Check out Scatmat and Ssscat.
This or a https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/dp/B0007NTBJ6
You could also give this a try. https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/dp/B0007NTBJ6
Scat mat: https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Indoor-Training-Electronic/dp/B0007NTBJ6/ref=br_lf_m_obag9nqtcktf8rm_ttl?_encoding=UTF8&s=pet-supplies
Motion detector spray: https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-PDT00-13914-SSSCAT-Spray-Deterrent/dp/B000RIA95G/ref=br_lf_m_obag9nqtcktf8rm_ttl?_encoding=UTF8&s=pet-supplies
My cats drove me crazy scratching at my door at night, until I got a Scat Mat: http://www.amazon.com/Battery-Operated-Scat-Mat-48x20/dp/B0007NTBJ6
I had tried the Ssssscat Sprays other posters have recommended, but my cats quickly learned that by moving very, very slowly they could avoid setting off the motion detector. The mat works because it shocks them every time they step on it. It works so well, I don't even bother turning it on anymore. Just roll it out when I go to bed, and the cats don't go anywhere near.
I would expect that it would work well on your counters as a training aid.
On medium, it's about the strength of a small static shock. More startling than anything.
I’ve found that if you don’t want a cat on a surface they DGAF and will still sit there when you’re not around to shoo them away, but if they don’t want to sit there they won’t. Unpleasant things like foil, tape, and bubble wrap sometimes work, sometimes they don’t. A ScatMat can help with the more stubborn cases. It gives off a static buzz that deters pets from sitting on it.
Scat-mat. 9-volt battery and a little static-electricity type shock and the cat will avoid it. After a few times, turn it off and then you don't have to worry about walking on it later ;)
So don't let them do that.
Cat scratches door - open door immediately and quickly and spash it with water from the sink. Alternatively, get a scat mat.
Dog barks/scratches - Tell them "No bark" or whatever you use to get them to not bark.
How big is the windowsill? Maybe put something uncomfortable on it?
The sell these plastic pads you can put on your couch to keep cats off, they just have little plastic spikes on them, they are like the underside of the plastic office chair pads for carpet. Not like something that will harm them, just something that is totally uncomfortable to sit or stand on.
I had a rottweiler foster that would push the blinds with his head and break them to see out the window. A few firms "No's" fixed that for me, but it always depends on the dog. It had to be when he didn't know I was busting him, so he got the idea that I would always be around to bust him.
Does she have enough toys to keep her occupied so she doesn't care about the window?
Maybe something that would make noise would also work. Another thing you can do with cats is something like tin foil, that is noisy and feels unstable.
There is also stuff like this https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Strip-inches/dp/B0001AB42W
I know that probably sounds like mostly negative stuff, but it is hard to give positive reinforcement when you aren't around...
My GSD is also not allowed on furniture and tries to be sneaky sneaky about it. We just put stuff on the couch/loveseat when we're asleep or not home. I bought a flagpole online and the long box is a perfectly sized deterrent.
Otherwise, there is something you can buy but, again, it involves placing it on the furniture when you're not on it. It's a nylon pad with sensors that emit an alarm when your pup tries to get on it.
I had the same problem but found a solution. An electric door mat. The damn thing works. My cats used to jump on my doorknob while my wife and I slept. Now they won't go anywhere near my bedroom.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0007NWNM8/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?qid=1407861365&sr=8-1&pi=SY200_QL40
Large pet shock pad(s) under the sheet.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0007NTBJ6
I know someone who used something like this on their counters (non weimaraner).
I guess it worked well, but I've heard varying things (some bad) about using shocks on dogs. I guess you have to be really careful or you can permanently mess up the dog psychologically, but I don't know anything about it/them.
https://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Training-Large-inches/dp/B0007NTBJ6
Shock the fucker. Doesn't hurt it, but it'll think twice about sitting on your furniture.
I'm a terrible sleeper - wake up to the slightest sound or touch - so having the cat in the bedroom just isn't possible for me. One of the first things I bought when I adopted my cat was this shock mat. I laid it down outside my door. He stepped on it once and now avoids the door area. I set a nice bed a little ways away from the door, so he has a place to call his own for the night. Never had any problems after the first week or so.
I also had that issue with my cats when I first adopted them. I ended purchasing a little zap mat that gives a very mild shock and corrects the behavior pretty quickly. I always set it on the lowest setting. Test on yourself so you know what the cat will be experiencing. It’s very light on the lowest setting.
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat for Dogs and Cats, Medium Size, 30 X 16 inch, Pet Proof Your Home, Electronic Training Mat https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0007NWNM8/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_cqGVCbR2RZNKQ
however after much research I think I may hve found something that just might work! http://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-ScatMat-Electronic-Training-16-Inch/dp/B0007NWNM8/ref=pd_ybh_3 This was recommended somewhere else and I may try it! Its a mat I can put in front of the door that delivers a noise or an electrostatic shock not to harm but to scare.
As an aside, be sure they both have collars with ID tags on at all times - I see they already have collars, which is great! Get them both microchipped if they aren't chipped already.
I have two friends (one in Arizona and one in California) who both refused to chip, collar, or tag their "indoor only" cats since "their cats would NEVER get out", and of course both had their cats get out. One hadn't even spayed her cat, so thorough was she in her belief the cat would never get out - and of course the cat got pregnant before my friend found her. >_< Sooo, I am a firm believer that every cat should be chipped, collared, and tagged, even if they "never" get out.
As for your original problem - I am facing the exact same thing with my new 8-month-old. I currently use two SSSCats to keep her out of the kitchen and away from the front door, but I follow this Amazon review's advice in regards to the spray canister:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R1YGZSYXLPRVJ0/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8&amp;ASIN=B000RIA95G
I also use the "sofa" size of this product:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0017XBDPA/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o08_s00?ie=UTF8&amp;psc=1
It's not like a shock collar - I've put my own hand on it and it's more like a static shock like when you rub your feet on carpet and then touch a metal object. It's more of a surprise than anything painful. You don't have to keep it or the SSSCats there forever - they'll learn quickly.
I've also used the "scare" tactic with great success with my older cat - when your little guys try to get out the door (or even approach it), slam your hands HARD onto whatever is nearby - floor, wall, countertop, the door itself - and yell "NO" in a deep, loud voice. Basically you're trying to make as much noise as you can at once to scare the crap out of them. Cats hate being startled. Do this every time it happens, the instant it happens. You can vary up the method of making sound, but make sure it is LOUD, sudden, and startling. You can also add a very light physical punishment to the fear-punishment - tap them on the top of the head with a finger along with a loud "NO". You're not hitting, just tapping firmly - imagine that you're trying to get someone's attention with a tap on their arm. Again, most people will condemn physically punishing a pet, but animals "understand" physical gestures, not words. (I know I said use a word, "NO", when yelling - you can use any other word/sound, "NO" is just conveniently easy to bellow.) Make it super unpleasant for them to even approach the door. If you open it a crack when you get home and they stick their heads/faces out, you can slap the door itself at that point and stomp to scare them.
It's worked wonders on my older cat (18 years old, used it to train her to stay out of the kitchen and to train her out of her random aggression that developed after my dog died) and your little guys won't be emotionally traumatized or hate you forever, don't worry!
Daww, I would say poor kitty but this is sufficient punishment for being a BAD GIRL. Also, I have found hanging a scat mat (an electrified shock blanket after a fashion) has stopped my kitty from manipulating the screen door. I imagine it would work if you hung it/placed it where you didn't want kitty to go.
This is, of course, you have already used tape and other sticky things to gross out the cat so they don't want to touch it...