Reddit mentions: The best deodorants

I believe the term you are seeking is "Zero Waste" living, or something close to.

Researching a bit of "zero waste" living products may help you get started with some ideas! I find a lot of material on youtube about zero waste living and am dabbling into the reality of the lifestyle myself. I am not sure if you are a man or woman, or what kinds of products you do use in your bathroom (toiletries, cosmetics, cleaning supplies, etc.) But I figured I would offer a few of my favorite alternatives to common items that you may look into.

Safety razors. Disposable razors/plastic handles with replaceable heads are convenient, yet highly wasteful and overall expensive to maintain. There are lots of stainless steel safety razors on the market with the feature of removable blades (of which you replace and recycle once your current blade has fulfilled it's purpose). Safety razors range from about $25- $50 and can last up to a lifetime. The replaceable razor blades can be found for very cheap (their lifetime lasts according to your usage). Here are amazon links to exemplary items:

Safety Razor: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000NL0T1G/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_boeIybWZE9JXX

Safety Razor Blade Replacements: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001QY8QXM/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_WoeIybSASAFBK

Homemade deodorant and/or natural sustainable deodorants: These can be tricky to get started with. Most commercial deodorants use aluminum to block your sweaty glands and completely block the process of perspiration. So, I urge you to take on natural deodorants with patience and give different methods a chance to work for themselves.

You can make your own, in a glass jar with ingredients that are less harmful to your body and this may be the best method to find something that aligns with your own body chemistry. A typical recipe for homemade deodorant would be 1 part coconut oil to 1 part bicarbonate soda (baking soda). BICARBONATE SODA MAY IRRITATE YOUR UNDERARMS. For the first couple weeks of usage, you may experience irritation of your glands purging the aluminum blockage and other toxins built up over time. Baking soda may also cause irritation to those who shave quite frequently, however I have found that applying this mixture at least 30 minutes after I shaved armpits in the shower, that I am less likely to get slight itchiness, if any at all. LISTEN TO YOUR BODY IF THIS METHOD IS NOT TOLERABLE FOR YOU.

If you are not keen on the idea of slathering on some good old homemade, Hippie salve, then Piperwai AND Schmidt's are popular brands with minimal packaging that seem to work for majority of people. These two products still contain bicarbonate soda, but will save you the convenience of not making your own. There are plenty of zero waste options that do not contain bicarbonate soda, but I have found luck with this formula and haven't looked beyond to seek anything else. Again, youtube is a good resource for finding such.

Piperwai Deodorant: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B011SM7IGM/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_FweIyb6Z2E2RM

Schmidt's Deodorant: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018K3HD62/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_fxeIybH035978

As for soaps, there are many wonderful body, face, and hair soaps available on the market today. Investing in simple bars with paper packaging or reusable storage may be the best option for avoiding excess packaging. There are lots of options available either on Etsy, at your city Whole Foods, or there are usually natural soap options that can be found quite locally at farmers markets and such hopefully in your hometown. Personal preference will go into certain decision making with soaps but bars are usually the best way to avoid said packaging.

Hopefully this offered a small bit of help and information to help you get started in your journey towards minimalism and green-thumb consciousness! Good luck!

This can be dealt with.

Here are a few options to consider. First, Zinc will help with the stink. You can take a Zinc supplement AND use a topical ointment on your feet. If you decide to take a Zinc supplement, don't take it everyday and be mindful of your copper levels. OptiZinc has copper included although you want to supplement even a little more. The ideal zinc-to-copper ratio is 10:1.

• Boudreaux's Butt Paste Maximum Strength Diaper Cream
  
  This works very well because it contains 40% Zinc. One of the highest you can find. I've used this on my feet with success and I've even used it on my face before to help with complexion issues and it never dried me out. I think using daily on your feet would be fine although I wouldn't recommend putting it on your face every day. You can find this in Walmart in the baby isle (where the Pedialyte is located). Start with a small amount and rub it in. A little goes a long way with this stuff, you don't want your feet feeling greasy all day.
  
  
• Crystal Body Deodorant Stick Deodorant
  
  I bought this because I was looking for safer deodorant options. I was amazed at how well it worked on my armpits (much better than traditional deodorants containing aluminum) and the upside for you is, it even specifically mentions being used on feet to treat foot odor. I haven't done that but I imagine it would working swimmingly.
  
  
• Nature's Way Chlorofresh
  
  
  This product is along the same lines as BodyMint, but much cheaper. It is typically used to deal with bad breath that originates from odor created in the gut, but it has also been used to treat general body odor as well. I recommend starting with the top 2 recommendations first but considering this can be tried for only ~$7, it may be worth just adding it to your odor fighting stack.
  
  
• 10-Seconds Deodorant & Disinfectant
  
  I was told this is the product that bowling alleys use to disinfect the bowling shoes. I bought a can sometime ago when I was running and wanted to keep my running shoes from getting rank. I can't find it right now but I seem to recall a warning about harmful/caustic chemicals coming into contact with skin so use this one carefully if you decide to try it. You should be disinfecting your shoes anyway since it sounds like your issue could be bacterial or fungal, seeing as it spreads so rapidly to new shoes.
  
  
• Drymax Run Hyper Thin No Show Socks
  
  I got these for running and I love them. They are super light and are made from a breathable mesh. The thicker your socks are, the more likely your feet are to get hot and begin sweating. These are a bit expensive but you can think of them as an investment that pays dividends.
  
  
• Mini Moso Natural Air Purifying Bag, Charcoal
  
  These are designed to naturally remove odor. I keep them in my shoes when they're just sitting in my closet. I assume they are working because my shoes don't stink. They are cheap and got good reviews on Amazon. Check 'em out.
  
  
  In conclusion
  
  I believe if you are washing your feet thoroughly, making sure your socks are clean and your feet have some Zinc ointment rubbed into them (or the crystal deodorant applied) and your shoes are properly disinfected and dry, I think you will see an appreciable reduction in foot funk if not a complete eradication.
  
  Good luck.
  
  

The deodorant is DEFINITELY the culprit. Aluminum causes most of the yellowing. More importantly, it is probably not good for you to wear such a strong anti-antiperspirant.

First, because it is not good to clog your pores, regardless of what you are clogging them with. Sweating is a natural body process.

Second, aluminium CAN be absorbed into the body transdermally via your armpits (source). That much is clear. Whether or not it can cause harm is still up for debate. But, IMHO, if you can avoid using it, you probably should.

So, here are steps you can take to transfer away from aluminium.

1. Look for an all natural, aluminium free deodorant. It is important to note that this will not anything like you are used to. It will NOT stop sweating. It will just help you smell better. Tom's of Maine makes some (I don't really like those, but some people swear by them). Arm and Hammer makes a nice one. Or, you can go really natural, and use something like Weleda. That is what I use, and it is just alcohol and natural oils.
   
   
2. Trim your pit hair. Don't shave it like a woman, but trim it down like your beard. This will help to decrease sweating and bacteria growth.
   
   
3. Wash really well in the shower. I mean scrub the shit out of those pits.
   
   
4. Don't wear under armour or other quick-dry type shirts. Those tend to pick up odor really quickly. Wool is the best for resisting odor, and cotton is ok, but not great. Both are better than the synthetic shit.
   
   Try all of that and see where it leaves you. You will still sweat, but you probably won't develop an offensive odor, and your shirts won't turn yellow.
   
   As for the shirts that are already stained, I don't know what to tell you.

I am a sweaty person. I have tried all the name brand antiperspirants/deodorants. After years of crusted yellow/white stained shirts, I realized that my body seemed to compensate with more sweat, plugged up under the arms, it surfaced on my back and head. Clinical/prescription strength antiperspirants only added to the problem, and my white tees took the damage. Later I found out people, myself included, actually use too much, you only need a super thin amount applied to your underarms, don't go about it like frosting a cake.

Also thinking about the potential harm of aluminum based antiperspirants (you absorb everything through your skin), I moved on to some natural deodorants (brands like Toms) but they just didn't seem to work so well, but i did notice when I applied less deodorant, or didn't altogether, my sweat began to lessen in severity. Anytime I actually smelled (like after yardwork or a any long day in the sun), it was time for a shower anyways. After I was properly applying a thin coat, I settled on Arm & Hammers Essential Deodorant that began to alleviate my problems, notably with my clothing. No more yellow crusty shirts!

But how about some deodorant that will last you several years? Try a Thai Deodorant Stone, I've had this baby for a year now and I can attest that it works great. Nowadays I apply this to my underarms from time to time and lightly powder my feet and groin with a mix of cornstarch and talc. Life is much better now.

TLDR: Use less antiperspirant and try a deodorant stick without aluminum, like Arm & Hammer Natural Essentials, or try a Thai Deodorant Stone cause it rules. Also try applying talc/cornstarch to areas you get moist

And while we're on the topic of saving money on everyday hygienic activities, consider a safety razor (refill blades are $10 for 100 compared to $20 for 8) some nice sandalwood shave soap (I've had this bowl for a year and it doesn't really look like any is gone) and a nice aftershave (I get lots of compliments on the particular scent of this one from those who get close enough to smell it) I always use an after shave lotion with little or no alcohol, because alcohol dries your face out and makes you look older. Then moisturizer, then an anti-aging...

Before I started shaving like this, I had a bit of an acne problem and some parts of my face where I would get spots of dry skin, it's gone now. My skin is mostly clear. You're gonna get a much better shave that doesn't irritate your skin and save a ton of money when you think about the cost of Gillete Quadruple edged razors, plus how much more badass is it to shave like this? This is how your grandpa shaved. The upfront investment is a badger brush, which I called an investment because a good one will last you a lifetime.

That's my hygiene ramble.

Where is the odor coming from? Remember because she is female she could have a yeast infection or vaginitis. I'm someone who has to wear particular deodorant or I smell. The Crystal works best for me. ( https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU/ref=sr_1_4_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1502582706&sr=1-4&keywords=crystal+deodorant ). Keeping things shaved also helps but that may not be an option. Also remember you are her dad. Not some pedophile so don't be afraid to help if needed. Is there a female she trust that could have a heart to heart with her? Or maybe make it fun and present like a makeover/spa day. Could be a way to teach her some tricks without making her feel targeted. I also work with a lot of Young adults with autism and one thing we do is make checklist. That way steps are at forgotten and there is a routine and pattern which could be helpful for people with autism.

Finally, if the odor is coming from her clothes you can spray the hotspots like under the arms with Listerine. I do this to my gym clothes before washing them. The alcohol kills bacteria.

I'm not claiming it is the best when really letting out the sweat, but when I'm at a bar or a show for 2-6 hours it holds up just enough. I still sweat through it, but it keeps me from having thst definitive BO smell and more of an earthy, natural aroma.

The best and weirdest response so far was post uh... engagement in bed, I like to spoon and bask for a while while muscles are still twitching and feel nice, and my female partner, instead of spooning up to my side and lying with her head against my chest where I beckoned her, she put her face directly against my armpit and deeply inhaled. She did this little wiggle and settled against me in this super satisfying, sexy way that made me feel so accepted and fulfilled. It was easily one of the best aftersex baskings I've ever had. It made me feel so sexy and special.

Edit: syntax mistake

It does not prevent sweating. Antiperspirants are designed for that and often contain aluminum chlorohydrate. This is how I differentiate if I am confused by the labeling.

As for the smell, deodorant definitely helps but if it is a long day and you sweat a lot it can mix with your BO scent and make something unpleasant for some like skylla's example of the freshener + shit nasal DP . Try stuff out and see what works best but if you sweat a lot you may want to keep in mind the mix of scents it creates.

If you wear any cologne, you will want to look for a very mild or even completely fragrance-free deodorant. I use the crystal stick and I am pretty satisfied. The stick itself lasts a super long time as long as you don't drop it, does not leave any stains on clothing, as natural as you can get in the deo aisle and doesn't conflict with any cologne. The only drawback for me is that I have to apply a LOT to make it as effective as some other more potent deodorants but that just means rolling the rock for longer as wetting it.

I get mine from the drugstore in my area but here is their site: http://www.thecrystal.com/

Reviews: http://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Stick-Body-Deodorant-sticks/dp/B000L978FU

1. Aveda Botanical Kinetics™ Hydrating Lotion - Face lotion, applied to face and mustache after shower.

2. Musgo Real Glycerine Lime Soap, MR GLO - Face soap, used before each shave.

3. Proraso Shaving Soap with Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol - Shave soap, whipped up then applied to face for shaving.

4. Proraso Pre and Post Shave Cream - Pre/Post shave cream, massaged into face after washing face with MR GLO. Massaged into face again after shave.

5. Proraso Aftershave Lotion - Aftershave, applied to face either after shave or after shower. My wife likes the smell of this.

6. TABAC ORIGINAL For Men By MAURER & WIRTZ Deodorant Stick - Deodorant, masculine scent of lavender, citrus, and warm florals.

7. Colonel Conk Evernice Model 775 Chrome Safety Razor Stand - Stand, holds DE razor and brush.

8. Merkur Model 180 Long Handled Safety Razor - DE Razor, great weight and balance used to shave face.

9. Tweezerman Men's Shaving Brush - So, so brush used for applying shave soap. Would like a better brush someday.

10. Feather Hi-Stainless Platinum Double Edge Razor Blades - Razors for DE, my favorite so far.

11. Tweezerman His Moustache Scissors with Comb - Scissors and comb, after movember I decided to keep the mustache so these items help maintain its appearance.

12. Comb - Comb, used for combing hair before and after shower.

13. Aveda Men Pure-Formance™ Grooming Clay - Hair product, used after shower with hair wet or dry. Hair looks natural but styled. I'll use pomade if I want the appearance of having a more polished look.

14. Large Stainless Steel Shaving Soap Bowl from Super Safety Razors - Mug, I'd rather have a porcelain mug for class but this does the trick. I use it to soak my brush and razor before each shave. I also use it for creams when not using Proraso.

Deodorant: Thai Crystal or something similar. It's not an antiperspirant but works great if you apply it right after showering and rub it on vigorously.

Soap: I love Aleppo soap, made with olive oil. I use it in the shower and for washing my hands.

Shampoo: Dr. Bronners baby mild. I dilute it with water 1:1 and have it in a foaming dispenser as it's rather runny.

Other options are Pure Nuff Stuff: they sell most of their products in an unscented version or Nanny's Silly Soap Company, she makes great unscented soap.

Do NOT try Organic 101, which is popular on Amazon and reviewed positively elsewhere. Part of the Merino advantage imho is getting a few wears in before washing. This deodorant accumulated beeswax and retained BO in the pit crevices. Was a real pain getting the residue out. And in the meantime a slight odor remained in the shirts. FWIW Puracy stain remover worked after several applications.

I made the mistake of going all-in on some new Outlier before a summer trip last year. Was mostly successful.

After trying that one, a few from natural foods groceries and Whole Foods and Arm & Hammer natural, I've settled on Underarmed, which is available on Amazon. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B06XPDFSZW/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1

No affiliation with this company.

Downside is this stuff is relatively expensive vs other products. But it's been best of any I've tried. No smell for at least 8 hrs or longer, no residue. Works great with Outlier merino (as well as Pistol Lake Eudae).

Happy to give back to this sub.

http://www.amazon.com/Hammer-Essentials-Solid-Deodorant-Unscented/dp/B00E3B47ZQ

I have to vouch for this stuff. Wal-Mart sells the scented kind in my area, and they are both fantastic. Free of most of the chemically stuff you're trying to avoid, but still extremely effective (for me at least) and also pretty cheap.

To give you an idea, I can wear any other deodorant (even the "prescription strength" stuff) and still be funky at the end of the day, from just sitting in a classroom or an office all day. This stuff, I'm fresh all day and it lasts even through workouts, Summer activities, etc. At least that's been my experience.

It'll probably take you a while before you find "the one" that works best for you and your body's chemistry. I've been using natural deodorant for 15-ish years, and I remember it taking a while before I found what worked best for me. I still change things up sometimes because I'm a sucker for new things.

I'm currently using Native, but I'll be changing brands after I finish with what I have left. It works alright, but it gets kinda iffy at the end of the day for me. Also, I'm trying to get away from purchasing as much stuff from mega corporations as I currently do. The coconut scent is amazing though and it is good for sensitive skin.

Before Native, I was using Green Tidings and loved it. I only stopped wearing it because lavender can be a migraine trigger for some of the people I work with and I do not want to be the cause of that. It's a light scent, but I was still worried about that.

Toms was ok years ago but then they changed the formula or something and it wasn't as good..That was well over 5 years ago since I last used them though, so that may have changed again.

I didn't have any major complaints with the Jason's or Schmidt's deodorants that I tried.

Again, I like Bathhouse's so far. I used to use Eau de Minimes, which smells heavenly and works well, but stopped after seeing it had a medium-high rating on the EWG database (but then I read that the EWG may not be the most trustworthy, so I might try it again). Soapwalla's and Lush's Aromaco also work great, but irritated my armpits because of the baking soda over time (my bf still uses Aromaco without problem, though). Also have read amazing things about Lavilin but haven't tried it.

I really like Arm and Hammer Natural Essentials deodorant. It has either fresh scent (which I love, like stand-there-and-smell-the-stick love) or unscented. Its aluminum and paraben free

omg, I love Arm and Hammer Essentials. The unscented is okay, but the fresh one is AH-mazing. Really helps with my B.O.
Also there's this one from Amazon. http://www.amazon.com/Green-Tidings-Deodorant-Strength-Protection/dp/B00EOB0042?ie=UTF8&psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s01
I like to alternate between these 2 because otherwise, I feel like my body gets used to just the one and it isn't as effective. :)

Stick deodorant: consider Tom's long-lasting men's deodorant. I am pretty sure this is an antiperspirant as well. I love the brand and use one of their deodorants as well.

Toothpaste: perhaps Dr. Bronner's. they are all natural and a really reputable vegan brand.

​

Also, just because we get in little cat fights now and then doesn’t mean we aren’t a united front. Fuck Brenda and be healthy my mans!

Got you with a link to the aluminum free deodorant I use. Don’t get turned off by the organic bit. It actually works and you’re not filling your pores with metal.

Natural Aluminum Free Deodorant Stick (That Works) Stay Fresh All Day - Underarmed for Women & Men - Organic, Healthy, Safe, Non Toxic - Phthalate, Paraben, Gluten & Cruelty Free (Lavender Scent) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06XPDFSZW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_kaZyDb6J4SX6X

Arm and Hammer somehow made me smell worse halfway through the day than if I hadn't applied deodorant at all so I recently started using this. It's kind of goofy and you need to apply it on clean, damp underarms but it's working pretty well. I also like that it's totally fragrance free. On my recent return to the U.S. from a trip abroad, after rifling through my shit the customs agent told me that a lot of her coworkers it too so idk it must be good??

Have you tried these? (link is to Amazon, but they sell them in Donki and drugstores. I sweat a lot too, and while this (and its menthol blue cousin) doesn't do much to reduce the amount (even though it says it's an antiperspirant), it helps a lot with the smell. It's definitely the best thing I found in Japan - not too expensive, so you can give it a try and see if it works for you.

I don't suffer from excessive sweating but I use this and it works so so well. I want people who have a sweat or odor issue to try this. It can be found at Amazon but some drug stores and Wal-Mart stores have it. It's inexpensive and lasts forever.
http://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Body-Deodorant-Stick-4-25/dp/B000L978FU
I would recommend using it before bedtime and also right after showering. For best results, your skin needs to be dampened or just put a little water on the top of it. You can put deodorant over it too. It will take a week or two to get full results.

My friend got one as well, it came and went until one day it became infected and I had to drain it. You might be allergic to a chemical in the deodorant you use. Try switching to a different brand. If it persists, this deodorant worked well for my friend. You do have to put it on at least twice a day, but it’s all natural.

Edit to add: friend hasn’t had this problem come up in the past 2 years he’s been using this product. If it still persists, I recommend going to a dermatologist.

This is gonna sound like some hippy shit but Kdot is part of black hippy so hang on a sec: most deodorant+antiperspirant contains metals which are bad for clothes and more importantly may or may not play a factor in various cancers, though the jury is very much still out on this.

Regardless, for 2 years I have used a combination of salt-based antiperspirant (link) and using cologne as my deodorant. I am consistently complimented on my scent, I feel clean and great, and none of my shirts have even remote staining. I don't like to wear undershirts under button-downs so it is very important to me that I not be staining them. Oh, and the antiperspirant I linked lasts 1.5 years easy, mine is going on 2 years now for like $4.

Fuck Old Spice and their marketing, you don't need that shit and it smells horrible. I don't have proof but knowing large mutinational corporations, you can make a decently educated guess that they purposefully developed a product that sorta works but only for a short time, because then how would they sell more of it? It's like planned obsolescence but more so planned rapid depletion.

+1 to Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser.

I love Sharps Happy Me All Over bar soap. I am on a rampage against body wash. Bring back the bar.

Worst name I've ever seen, best deodorant I've used. Herban Cowboy Dusk scent.

Aveda Brilliant Universal Styling Cream for keeping my mess of hair in order.

OP, I know I'm late to the party but no one has brought this up yet.

When you talk about ruining your shirts from sweat, I had a similar experience. When I was in high school, I wore the same 5 undershirts under my uniform for like a year and I sweated so much that the material in the armpits became kind of tough and discolored, thus ruining the shirts. It happened regularly to all tees I wore for the next five years and I thought it was just unavoidable.

I've read that this grossness is actually caused by chemicals in the antipirspirant. Since having switched to crystal deodorant (which is not an antiperspirant), this doesn't happen to my shirts. I recommend the crystal stuff in that it keeps me odor free and keeps my shirts in good condition.

Some people in this thread have reported that quitting antiperspirants has led to a decrease in sweating. This hasn't happened for me, so your mileage may vary. I still sweat a lot on the crystal deodorant. But there are no chemicals (it's pretty much made of salt, I think) and my shirts last longer.

What I have started doing is wearing a moisture wicking shirt (like Under Armor) as an undershirt. While this decreases the severity of large sweat spots under my arms, they are still there. Just instead of looking soaked, they look a little damp, which is a big improvement.

What's the best natural deodorant you've tried? Mine is Urban Cowboy . Just curious what you guys have tried and liked.

Schmidt's charcoal+magnesium natural deodorant. No aluminum, smells great, not greasy or wet feeling. Pretty inexpensive and easy to find at Target and most other places now

• handkerchief
  
• iPhone 5s
  
• [Saddleback Leather ID wallet, dark coffee brown] (http://www.saddlebackleather.com/pocketidwallet)
  
• Fisher Space Pen, matte black
  
• Streamlight Nano
  
• Leatherman Brewzer
  
• Kershaw Ken Onion Chive
  
  In My Bag:
  
  Survival Tins --
  
  
• Plastic Baggie from REI (unavailable online, sadly)
  
  --Medical--
  
  
• Gauze pads, antiseptic wipes, bandages from $2 CVS first aid kit
  
• off-brand superglue
  
• whistle - Fox 40 Rescue Howler Whistle
  
  --Fire--
  
  
• Mini Bic Lighter
  
• Firestarter - Light My Fire 2
  
• Generic Kindling from REI
  
• strike-anywhere matches
  
• stormproof matches and striking surface from REI (unavailable online)
  
• gauze pad (for kindling and to keep items from rattling)
  
• Bicycle Poker Size Rider Back playing cards
  
  Other --
  
  
• Old Spice Classic
  
• "Rubicks" Cube, ShengShou Aurora 3x3 black
  
• Klean Kanteen Vacuum Insulated Stainless Steel Tumbler, 16oz -- I take this thing with me everywhere
  
• Klean Kanteen Pint Lid -- I keep this in my bag, only use it once in a while, but it's nice to have on hand.
  

alum is a nice post shave/pre-aftershave step as it closes most small nicks without the need for styptic and it has antimicrobial properties as well so it can help prevent acne and whatnot. it also makes your skin tighter resulting in your skin feeling smoother. if you want to get some alum on the cheap, this is what I use. if you don't get that, be sure to get potassium alum, not any other kind of alum like ammonium, it'll sting more.

You're going to want an alum block to rub over your wet face right after the shave. It tightens your pores, disinfects, and controls any bleeding if you have cut yourself or scraped your skin. If you want one purpose-made for shaving, you can get the one by RazoRock, but you should save a few bucks and instead use a Crystal Body Deodorant; it's chemically identical and comes in a plastic applicator that is easier to hold.

After rinsing off the alum, I would use a toner splash, like Thayers witch hazel and lavender or Ogalalla bay rum, followed by a balm, like Nivea Aftershave for Sensitive Skin.

I've been using this stuff for over a year now, but I would also like to know the best because I have to apply this about twice a day.

Sure thing! :) I didn’t find any information about it being an antiperspirant, unfortunately, but reading through the amazon reviews, it seems quite a few people find it more effective than their old regular deodorant (Dove, Secret, etc.), which is cool, especially considering that the Crystal deodorant in the stick form is primarily made of mineral salts.

I used to have the same issue and was unable to resolve it -- I trashed a bunch of very nice (non-Outlier) merino shirts. Afterwards, I decided to test a bunch of deodorants online (10, to be precise) over the course of a few months until I found one that 1) did not stain, 2) did not cause any itching, and 3) eliminated all musk. Behold, the result: Bale Secrets Natural Deodorant [LINK]. While this isn't a solution, I hope it helps!

I can't use "normal" deodorants as they always irritate the shit out of my pits and have messed up some shirts like you mentioned. I use this stuff right now and it is really good. It keeps me smelling good until I get home from work. Another option could be essential oils as they do a really good job of keeping you smelling good (a few friends do this, i've never tried it tho.) I also used to use some Lush deodorant that worked really well but i don't remember which one.

I have tried them all and the only one that works for me consistently has been Bali Secrets Bali Secrets Natural Deodorant - Organic & Vegan - For Women & Men - All Day Fresh - Strong & Reliable Protection - 2.5 fl.oz/75ml [Scent: Original Essence] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B012E9DMNQ/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_-YQjDbT654S58

I don't know what sorts of deodorants you've tried but I use the roll-on Crystal deodorant and LOVE IT.
Tbh I don't generally sweat a ton but in the summer in the South it does a great job of countering disgusting boob sweat, which is a major accomplishment.
It doesn't have a scent and even when I do end up sweating a decent amount, it doesn't smell like anything.

Alternative LPT: Switch to one of those salt stone deodorants.


I threw out all of my old white undershirts (I keep around 30 on hand. I'm pretty serious about white t's), and made the switch from antiperspirant at the same time. No more pit stains! Haven't looked back. It's amazing!

Green Tidings Organic All Natural Deodorant is what you want. You can get it unscented or lavender. But it'll do what you are looking for. It leaves no stains. But as with most natural deodorants, it doesn't stop the sweating like an antiperspirant. Furthermore, you may need to reapply after 6-8 hrs. YMMV. (I went through one, lavender, and liked it so much I bought it again, the bigger container the second time).

Potassium alum (baber's alum) like that stick you linked to is intended for use on your face. Deodorant alum is almost always ammonium alum, which often stings when applied to your face but works better as a deodorant.

And not to get into too much detail.. but why would you ever want to rub something on your face that you have already rubbed into your armpits? Sure you may have showered first or whatever.. but even then I don't think I would want to use the same product on both areas.

Hey! This might not work for you, but I also had a BO problem where my regular deodorant wasn't doing anything, so based on internet recs I started using this Thai crystal stick right after I got out of the shower, and it completely eliminated my problem. Apparently it creates an unfriendly chemical environment for bacteria.

It's important to completely clean your underarms in the shower before applying the stick, because although it prevents bacteria, it is not a smell masker and can't help you if you're already smelly. I have an anti-bacterial body-wash which I scrub under my arms in the shower, but maybe the sulfate-free soap suggested elsewhere in this thread would be good? I'm interested in trying it.... Anyway, after I get out of the shower I wet the stick briefly under the tap and then apply to my pits, which dry quickly. I also put my reg deodorant on top of it.

Thai crystal I've only found online, but I have seen other crystal deodorants (roll-on type) in drugstores, which I've tried and do the job too (I prefer the solid form though). this one

Edit: I feel a moral responsibility to mention the aluminum controversy. It's a whole box of worms which may or may not be an unfounded scare.... I am thinking of maybe trying this Milk of Magnesia as an alternative, but I'm not in any rush.

So, I've tried a ton of "natural" deodorants in my quest for a safer alternative to conventional antiperspirants, here's what I've got.


My absolute and utter favorite is the Crystal Essence roll on. It comes in a few scents and has a , it does not leave a residue and is the absolute closest thing you can find to a natural antiperspirant. As long as you apply it to clean skin, it does the job well. Basically, it's my holy grail of deodorants.


Other common natural deodorant sticks, like Tom's, Alba, Nature's Gate, etc.. the deo will go on "wet" feeling and tend to stay that way until it dries. Which can be uncomfortable/annoying for most people. I've found most of these will leave a residue behind.


Natural spray deodorants are so-so, from what I've found. The Weleda rose spray deo works pretty well but can smell alittle weird after awhile. No residue though!

I loved this! For the deodorant, the only aluminum free one that worked for me was Lavilin deodorant (http://www.amazon.com/Lavilin-Underarm-Deodorant-Cream-12-5/dp/B0013OXEFU). It's a cream so it's kind of a hassle to put on.

For the sunscreen do you mind a whitecast?

Crystal deodorant should help with the smell. Get him to put some on his feet after hopping out of the shower. It seems weird, but it works pretty well.

This stuff rocks. I get it at Whole Foods. Vegan, if you care about that, works, and smells great.

http://www.amazon.com/Herban-Cowboy-Deodorant-2-8oz-sticks/dp/B000OP3R74

Get a good deoderant like this and a bottle of good cologne.

After a shower, with the body still slightly wet apply deoderant and spray 1 or 2 mists of cologne in the air and walk into it. This is all you will need.

I use Schmidt's Cedarwood and Juniper about 90% of the time and Baxter of California the rest. Baxter is more subtle than the Schmidt's, scent-wise, and it's also a bit gentler, I guess? I use it whenever my pit skin needs a break.

I tried Every Man Jack Cedarwood but it absolutely does not mix well with my natural scent for some reason. Every other cedarwood scented product I've tried does. :\

My favorite scented thing, even though it's not a deodorant, is Baxter of California's Exfoliating Body Bar. It's cedar wood and oak moss scented. (My mother calls it my 'man soap', which is awkward because I'm not out.) It's expensive but it's a big bar, so I cut it in smaller pieces and only use it where I have rough skin. I sniff myself for hours after a shower.

Check your local drug stores plenty of them should have it like HAC drug, fit care depot etc. Amazon also has it of course.

For the smells, I use Thai Deodorant Stone. I always sweat a lot and this is the very best thing I have found for odor control. Everyone that I have convinced to try it also love it. It doesn't stop you from sweating, but you won't stink anymore.

Herban cowboy has one called "dusk" it's all I use. I found most deodorants gave me issues. This one is good, mild, and smells great.

Edit: link https://www.amazon.com/Herban-Cowboy-Deodorant-2-8oz-sticks/dp/B000OP3R74

From Texas, so even this time of year I have some problems with heat causing sweatiness. I use Mitchum Smart Solid Clinical Performance antiperspirant. It works better than any other over the counter product I have tried. Get unscented so you don't clash scents with your cologne, it is designed so it doesn't leave the white stains on clothing (although I have noticed that it does leave little white spots very occasionally), and only apply one layer over your whole pit. It doesn't need to be just coated on like some people do. I keep an old towel in my bathroom so that if I put too much on I can just dab it off a bit. Only one warning, because it has so much going on it is a bit powerful and can cause an itchy rash if you over apply. Happened to me once or twice because I over applied it, itchiness went away in 20 or so minuets.

If you don't feel like going to a doctor to seek a cure, then try this because it really is a magic deodorant. Put it on at night before bed and right after your morning shower and it will work better too, I buy mine at CVS. Good stuff.

I've used a bunch, but found Arm and Hammer the best.

I use the unscented crystal deodorant stick (amazon). If I do sweat under my arms while using this, there's no smell. I use the dry stick version so it is kind off a hassle to use, my underarm as well as the stick have to be wet in order for it to get on my skin, then it has to dry completely. But it always works. I have tried certain dri but it gave me a rash and it made my armpits sweat even more, and I feel like any deodorant/antiperspirant with a scent smells way too strong.

Wow, not even the [crystal deodorant ] (https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU)?

All my sympathy!

I love salt deodorant. I got this at CVS for $6, it lasts forever, works really well for me in stopping odor, doesn't feel gross, doesn't develop a smell.

Anything w/o aluminum or paraben, I use Tom's but arm and hammer has a good option as well.

http://www.amazon.com/Arm-Hammer-Essentials-Deodorant-Fresh/dp/B001CI6RQK

This stuff from Arm and Hammer is my go-to; I've been using it for about 5 years! Amazon link for example, I often find it at CVS for cheaper. I bike everywhere and am a pretty sweaty lady, and it still works well for me.

https://www.amazon.com/Speick-Natural-Stick-Deodorant-Ounces/dp/B0012LU4LQ/ref=sr_1_sc_1_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1525980880&sr=8-1-spell&keywords=speiak+deoderant

or

https://www.amazon.com/Tabac-Original-Maurer-Wirtz-Deodorant/dp/B000XE2VGE/ref=pd_sim_194_10?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B000XE2VGE&pd_rd_r=SB54GFFCGGGRCCH5T8XB&pd_rd_w=wcVER&pd_rd_wg=4vIGi&psc=1&refRID=SB54GFFCGGGRCCH5T8XB

Only ones I have had luck with since switching from antiperspirants

pro tip: trim, dont shave your arm pit for better results.

Another vote for the crystal deodorant...the key is to apply a lot fresh out of the shower. It works by inhibiting the smelly bacteria from starting to grow...once it's there the deodorant can't do anything. But as long as you do that it works great! I like the chamomile one but the unscented is fine too.

I have dark armpits too. I have actually found that the schmits brand charcoal deodorant has actually lightened them substantially. If you can get your hands on it, I'd reccomend it.

Its available at most large retailers, but I'll link it from Amazon too. Hope it works for you too!

https://www.amazon.com/Schmidts-Deodorant-Charcoal-Magnesium-grams/dp/B071YYMZ19/ref=mp_s_a_1_5?crid=3AMUPF45QC3JC&keywords=schmidts+charcoal+magnesium+deodorant&qid=1556753303&s=gateway&sprefix=schmits+ch&sr=8-5

Me too, I'm nosey about the change even if I can't afford it.

If I may make another suggestion, assuming you don't already: particularly if you're going to put proper money into aftershave then consider changing anything else scented so it doesn't interfere.

1. Pure witch hazel or an alum block are unscented and are for literal after shaving, not in the "part of your outfit" sense. I prefer the former since it's liquid and I like to keep the splash-on feeling. WH can come with or without alcohol, it's down to preference.
   
   
2. Use a mineral salt instead of deoderant. YMMV I'm sure, but I've found it better in every way, sucks that they tend to aim it at the chemical-fear market. I wouldn't even have looked at it if I hadn't given up on the rest and found such positive reviews. Here's an example.

I've been able to extend the wear out of my clothes by wearing a cotton tank underneath my tops (I love the $2 ones from F21, they're 100% cotton and wash & breathe really well), switching to Himalayan crystal salt deodorant (this one is my favorite), hanging up my clothes immediately upon arriving home, and switching to natural fabrics. The tank will absorb most of the sweat and keep your clothes clean, and the salt deodorant will kill any odor-causing bacteria while also relieving you of gross smelling old deodorant mixed with sweat smells in your shirts. Hanging your clothes up when you get home lets them air out sufficiently to where you should be able to get 2-3 wears out of them. Synthetic fibers don't allow your clothes to breathe so they will trap in the smell. My linen/cotton/silk shirts can go WAY longer without being washed than my polyester ones. The only way I can get more than one wear out of a synthetic top is if it's sleeveless.

Arm and Hammer Essentials Natural deodorant Arm & Hammer Essentials Natural Deodorant, Fresh - 2.5 oz - 2 pk https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MUE56R6/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_elCxzbYRKRE1H

I then either put on a little bit of gold Bond body powder or generic talcum powder. Works perfectly.

I used aluminum based antiperspirant for years until I had a severe, allergic reaction. This combo took a while to find but works well for me.

I have been using Crystal for about a year now and will probably stick with it. It is a big salt rock. It isn't an antiperspirant but it is excellent at preventing odor.

https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU?th=1

What did you think of the crystal? I have one that is just the rock without the plastic dispenser. They sell them for example like this here:

https://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Basket/dp/B000FVA6XU/ref=pd_bxgy_2/135-8639298-9943902

Another friend of mine uses half a lemon.

This is an example. It uses mineral salts. You have to get it wet to use but I just put it on after my shower (when my armpits are already moist) and it works just fine like that. They also make a roll on version but it doesn't last nearly as long, in my experience.

My holy grail is Crystal Deodorant. It’s about $5 and lasts me over a year with daily use. It works better for me than any regular, “clinical strength,” or natural deodorants I’ve tried. And it doesn’t stain my dark clothes with white streaks, nor does it make the pits yellow on my white shirts.

Use a crystal rock like this when your armpits are wet and clean

Then a second "real" deodorant like this with essential oils

I like this basket one
(Thai Deodorant stone by DSA if Amazon doesn't work for you)
I've had issues with plastic applicators as the stone wore down/got older, and the basket makes it less of an eye sore, and the stone doesn't sit in water making funky crystals. It also cuts down on plastic/trash which is another plus! They only major drawback is the basket format probably isn't the best for travel, since the rock is just a big rock and I am still figuring out the best way to but it in a bag so it doesn't bump around.

These also last for-ev-ver. It feels like you've adopted a pet rock.

This works great if you put it on right after you shower.
https://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI?th=1

Have you tried Old Spice deodorant? They do have certain scents that are made without the antiperspirant/aluminum. I'm a woman, and I use the Wolfthorne scent. It smells like oranges and isn't uber manly.

I've also used the thai crystal . It's a crystal that you wet and rub onto your pits. I know it sounds hokey and like bullshit, but it helps me with the smell. Doesn't do anything for sweat, though.

I prefer au Naturel, but this is my favorite for when there has to be something else.

It's a tub, not a tube. I was trying to post a picture but my image search doesn't give me a link on my phone, so:

https://www.amazon.com/Lavilin-Underarm-Deodorant-Cream-12-5/dp/B0013OXEFU

It isn't nearly enough product to cause issues at airport security, and even if it was its closer to a solid than a liquid.

I use Arm & Hammer - Arm & Hammer Essentials Natural Deodorant, Fresh - 2.5 oz - 2 pk https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MUE56R6/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_lXRSAbCPWZXMD

Just switched to Thai Crystal, stuff is amazing & compact - https://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI?th=1

YMMV but, I used to have horrible pit stains. We're talking BROWN here, not just slightly yellow. I read an article that said the culprit was aluminum (the active ingredient in most deodorants and all anti-perspirants) mixed with sweat. So I switched. To an aluminum free deodorant (pretty much the opposite advice of those who are advocating CertainDri) and now, even white T-Shirts will last me for years (literally) without any pit stains.

Also, I too have the curse of sensitive pits so, the most common aluminum free deodorants (Speed Stick, even the "all natural" Tom's) gave me bad pit rash.THIS
is my perfect, non staining, non irritating deodorant. As a bonus, it's also pretty much the cheapest deodorant you can buy. So there's no harm in trying...

Thai Natural Crystal Deodorant.

It's not Thai and it's not "natural", but they do work. The crystal is alum, which is a different kind of aluminum salt than the aluminum chlorhydrate found in most antiperspirants. You apply the the deodorant, by wetting the crystal and rubbing it on your skin. It has no smell.

The benefits of it are that it does not stain clothes - no yellow stains in the armpits like regular antiperspirants. I find it to be effective at stopping odors.

From the name, it seems like a ridiculous product. I started using it a few years ago. At first, was switching from antiperspirant to a regular deodorant to stop my shirt armpits from staining yellow. But several brands of regular deodorant (arm and hammer, old spice) irritated my skin. This stuff works well and I have no irritation. I'm very happy with it.

Costs about $7/stick, but a stick will last a year, maybe more.

Mitchum Smart Solid, Unscented.

Do you specifically need an antiperspirant?

If not, try a natural stone deodorant. I've been happy with it for 18 years now.

CRYSTAL BODY DEODORANT Stick - Unscented (4.25 fl oz) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000L978FU/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_JX0pyb0GDGMFV

I use Underarmed here and LOVE it. I tried so many others (toms, native, primal pit paste, etc) before find this one. It took ~2 weeks for me to adjust. It’s on the pricier side but one stick has lasted me almost 5 months (?!)

Here’s 7 day natural deodorant. On the condition that you bathe daily, though. It stops the bacteria that causes an oder from being able to grow. Expand your horizons.

I swear by Mitchum Smart Solid "Clinical Performance"

Not sure what a Paleo deodorant would be, but you could try mineral salts like this.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000L978FU/

http://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Stick-Body-Deodorant-sticks/dp/B000L978FU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1396539315&sr=8-1&keywords=crystal+deodorant

Try that, I love it even more so since it has no scent.

This is the link I purchased from. I'm guessing we triggered some sort of pricing algorithm with our sudden interest, because the price has gone up.

http://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Body-Deodorant-Stick-4-25-oz/dp/B000L978FU

I have really been liking the Schmidt's deodorant line.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B018K3HD62/ref=twister_B01NCNVM7P?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

I've used this stuff for years: https://www.amazon.com/Century-Herbal-Clear-Deodorant-2-65-Ounce/dp/B000GCLDOO

It has a very mild, non-fake-flowery-perfume scent on the applicator, and I don't really smell it once I apply it.

But I don't think I am a heavy sweater at all. This brand does make a "sports" version, though, so that might be a better choice.

Herban Cowboy is a good non-aluminum stick that smells nice and won't leave stains, but I find I have to reapply midday.

Buy this stuff: http://www.amazon.com/Arm-Hammer-Essentials-Deodorant-Fresh/dp/B001CI6RQK/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1321286424&sr=8-1

I used to use mitchum anti antiperspirant and it actually made me sweat more, but this arm and hammer stuff is natural and doesn't stain your clothes. I also never sweat and don't smell either.

For deodorant you should keep the alum crystal one, like this: https://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Body-Deodorant-Stick-4-25/dp/B000L978FU/

The thing last forever and will not melt even if you put it in the trunk of your car during hot summer.

Mitchum Clinical Performance contains 20% Aluminum Zirconium Tetrachlorohydrex Gly (the most common compound used as an anti-perspirant) which is the highest you can get without a prescription. It looks like Certain-Dri is only 12%.

Well, if you feel like changing brands, there is one that I've recommended to people who get the dreaded armpit rash. My dad, boyfriend, and I all use it with great results and no body odor.
Thai Crystal Deodorant Stick
You just moisten it and rub it on your pits. It can be used on stinky feet too :)

Old Spice Classic Deodorant Stick, Original 3.25 oz (Pack of 6) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0017WNFXE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_bVTvDb44V8N6Q

I switched to Dove Men Care, but found today that it also gives me a burn/rash. Crystal is the only deodorant not to do that to me so far (https://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Body-Deodorant-Stick-4-25/dp/B000L978FU/ref=sr_1_1_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1470007067&sr=8-1&keywords=crystal+deodorant). I found it at CVS for around $3. It's just potassium alum, which is the same alum you might use shaving.

I know you have probably tried a million things, and i hope my suggestion isn't upsetting, but have you tried Lavilin? I have/had a similar issue with odor for a long time (I am not sure if it is related to my traumas) and it is the only thing that really worked.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0013OXEFU/ref=sr_ph_1_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1511680733&sr=sr-1&keywords=lavilin

Lavilin


We apply once every 3-5 days and it's been a pleasant experience. Doesn't stop sweat, just stops the smell; but I'm not a heavy sweater anyway.

I don't care about anti-perspirant, and I use natural deodorants as much as possible. I use the Crystal (salt) rock deodorant after I shower.

This is the one recommended in the May 5, 2017 email.

https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU/

I found some on Amazon.

I dunno. My rock looked like this, but less pink and more white, irregularly shaped, and scratchy-lookin'. Apparently it's salt.

As long as I put it on right after the shower, it's miraculous.

I use a salt deodorant like this one. It usually lasts the whole day but I don't sweat too much to begin with.

I used this one for about a year and it was fantastic until I got some sort of weird infection and my doc told me to stop using it. It went away shortly after but it wasn't bad and it may not have even been that. I'd give it a shot if I were you, can't beat that price.

http://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Body-Deodorant-Stick-4-25-oz/dp/B000L978FU/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1414967863&sr=8-2&keywords=rock+crystal+deodorant

This. Best stuff ever. Lasts for years. No scent, just makes the environment inhabitable for the stinky bacteria.

I like that thai crystal stuff. I thought it was hokey until my mom got me a stick. One stick will last for years, and I've clocked it as lasting up to 3 days with no BO.

This one doesn't have aluminum in it, as far as I know. I'd appreciate someone letting me know if I'm mistaken.

This may not be the most popular option, but I use one of those salt crystals:
http://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stick-Stones-America/dp/B000AN1JEI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1418575735&sr=8-1&keywords=thai+deodorant&pebp=1418575737788

Unscented, but doesn't stain shirts like antiperspirants do. Also lasts over a year.

I use arm and hammer. I think it's unisex. It's this one: https://www.amazon.com/Arm-Hammer-Essentials-Natural-Deodorant/dp/B00MUE56R6 (I don't buy it from Amazon but I think it's the same product)

Like this. Is NOT anti-perspirant.

*edited link because the other went to the mobile site

I've been using this one

Proraso Shave Soap

Proraso Pre/Post Shave Cream

Proraso Aftershave

Proraso Glycerin Pre Shave Soap

Leisureguy's Guide to Gourmet Shaving

Blade sampler pack

Tabac Deodorant

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shave Stick

Taylor of Old Bond Street Avocado Shave Cream

L'Occitane Shaving Cream, Cade

That looks right, here's the one we use: Crystal Body Deodorant Stick - 4.25 oz https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000L978FU/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_bvLqxbECSY82G

Try this: http://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-in-Basket/dp/B000FVA6XU/ref=sr_1_20?ie=UTF8&qid=1311551298&sr=8-20

Crystal Mineral Deodorant Stick, Unscented, 4.25 oz

I use salt rock for deodorant. last all day, and the stick last for a year believe it.

The one I have is a rollerball form: CRYSTAL BODY DEODORANT Roll-On - Unscented (2.25 fl oz) - 3 Pack https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00028QFAY/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_2mQBDbZTQXZ1A

Is it this? https://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Mineral-Deodorant-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU/ I didn't realize Crystal was a brand, thought it was just a type.

this or this

This one is made in Thailand

I use salt deodorant. https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU?th=1

Guys, don't use AP's. The aluminum oxide causes Alzheimers. I am a big dude and I sweat a lot too, so I'm not preaching without practicing here. Get yourself a thai crystal stick or use purely deodorant.

https://www.amazon.com/THAI-Natural-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounces/dp/B000AN1JEI

Have you tried switching to a non-antiperspirant such as this:
http://www.amazon.com/Arm-Hammer-Essentials-Deodorant-Fresh/dp/B001CI6RQK

in combination with dress shields? http://www.amazon.com/Kleinerts-Disposable-Underarm-Dress-Shields/dp/B000J09VGA

Ever heard of lavilin?

Not OC but I use a Crystal deodorant and it works. You just have to use it on your clean and damp underarms. It really helped in lightening my armpits tbh.

Yo hace dos años que uso la misma piedra y todavía me queda un tercio…

You could try using one of these. It messes with the salinity of your skin so bacteria can't grow.

This. Also I've been using it for over 4 years and haven't had to buy more, it laaaaasssstttsss.

Crystal deodarant

Edit: Oh this won't prevent sweating. Lo siento.

There is rock deodorant. While it has a higher melting point than gel or the white stuff, it also doesn't work.

How about old school roll-on, powder, or undershirt combination?

I really like Dove - they have a prescription strength version. I haven't tried this particular one before. Degree has a super-strong version (or they used to) - that's what I used in high school when I was athletic and at my stinkiest, as a teen.

To be honest I use something similar to this but I do have to re-apply on really hot days. I'm more worried about chemicals than reapplying, though.

You'll get more replies in /r/xxketo.

not sure if you've used Underarmed before but it's worked absolute wonders for me.

I'ma save you all right now.

https://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI/ref=sr_1_2_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1466894237&sr=1-2&keywords=thai+crystal+deodorant

No smell, no spots. Can't beat it.

It's not a roller, it's a stick. This is it.

Definitely the most effective thing I use to combat the brutal Japanese summers. That and Gatsby Ice Citrus wipes.

I've been using this for a year now and I'm not interested in anything else

As skeptical as I was, I found the crystal deodorant to work just fine. It is colorless, odorless and just plain works.

This deoderant works the same way. Just put it on after you shower and you're good for 24 hours+ It's literally a stick of salt that kills bacteria.

I use the crystal deodorant, and it's a little odd to get used to at first, but it works great! You have to reaaaaallllly get it all over your underarm area though, not just in the pit...I rub mine a little bit on the sides of my armpit and then a lot farther up and down (like a bit down onto my sideboob area and on my arm where it touches my side boob area). I definitely had a few days where my body was sort of getting used to not having traditional deodorant on, so I was a bit stinky, but it didn't last long. Now the only time I get stinky is if I'm doing really heavy physical activity in the heat, but that would have happened even when I wore normal deodorant. This is the kind that I buy because I hate the dispenser on the stick version, but the stick version works just the same. My favorite thing about it is that it's cheap and it lasts a super long time. The only time I've had to buy new deodorant since I've started using it wasn't because I ran out (I wasn't even close), but it was because I dropped the crystal chunk and it fell awkwardly and shattered.

Safety Razor

Blades

Deodorant - Herban Cowboy Dusk Scent.

Body Wash - tea tree oil from Trader Joe's (buy it there and not on Amazon due to price).

You don't have to shave your armpits, just trim them. You need to get the hair short enough for the deodorant to reach skin. I use a 2 guard on my trimmer every couple of weeks.

Then, use Crystal hippie deodorant, I prefer the liquid roll-on. It's not a traditional deodorant nor is it an anti-perspirant, it's a salt stick. The salts dehydrate and kill the bacteria that cause B.O.

You'll still sweat, but your sweat won't smell bad; instead you will smell pleasantly neutral. It also won't turn the armpits of all your shirts yellow, nor will anti-perspirant residue run off onto your shirts and get pits all crusty. The Crystal hippie deodorant still has aluminum, but it's a different compound that your body won't absorb. Super hippies still won't use it, but they stink, so that's the tradeoff.

http://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stick-Stones-America/dp/B000AN1JEI
here's the link to the product, maybe the reviews will help. I got mine from amazon a while ago because I'm obsessed with online shopping, but they also have it at kroger around here as well as more specialty stores (like whole foods or whatever).

I live in the midwest and used this from May-now, and definitely saw some really hot days. You only really get stinky if you don't shower daily/get really sweaty and re-wear the same shirts multiple times.

Deodorants simply work to reduce stinky pit smell; antiperspirants usually use aluminum salts to kind of plug up the sweat glands in your pits to decrease the amount of moisture that comes out. It's what our bodies have evolved to do, so I figure why mess with that? Obvs it's up to you to decide, and if you try the stone and don't like it, you can probably find some hippy to give it to :P

Anyway, hope that helps!

[edit: also one of the reasons I thought about the stone was that I kept staining the pits of my shirts with the traditional antiperspirants I was using, which sucked! I haven't had that issue at all with the stone]

I use this one on my legs. I've heard people say the alum in this isn't the same as in the alum blocks sold for shaving, but idk. It seems to work, but may sting more than other ones. Honestly I only use it for about 25% of my shaves because I'm lazy, so maybe I'm not the best source...

I use Crystal brand natural deodorant (this stuff). No gross baby powder/flowery scent & it lasts forever.

No your boyfriend is being a fucking asshole baby about this; there are natural salt based deodorants that could work for him, just break up with him he's being an idiot

I use this stuff.

I (like others) found that using a deo w/ antiperspirant only made things worse. You can also take baking soda in the shower, rub it on a wash clothe (I usually used soap too) and wash your underarms. The baking soda will typically reduced sweating. Also, baby powder (after you are out of the bath and dry) after putting on deo.

Try the crystal deodorant. I had a hard time with sweating and getting rashes from normal deodorant. The crystal helps neutralize your sweating. I no longer have to worry about BO.

https://www.amazon.com/CRYSTAL-BODY-DEODORANT-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU

Edit: Am male, but wife uses same deodorant too and has no problem with sweat now :)

I have no idea what the answer to your problem is, but I can suggest products that I use. First is Crystal deodorant - it is literally just a salt crystal rock thing, just one ingredient. You can buy a travel size at places like Whole Foods to see if it works for you. If one of the ingredients in your deodorant is causing trouble for you, maybe using a simpler product will eliminate the issue.

The other product is Certain Dri. It works a little differently than your average deodorant. It stops you from sweating and lasts a few days, even after you shower.

I use a 'crystal' deodorant (http://amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI/). I think it is actually mostly salt. It is super cheap for how long it lasts but it DOES prevent bad odors for me and it's unscented status allows me to put perfume on top of it. I had when deodorant conflicts with perfume.

No, it's a block of mineral. The only alum I'd pay extra for is Thai Crystal deodorant sticks and only because it is specially shaped and seals for travel/protection.

Mineral salt deodorant (Non-affiliate Amazon link)

Basically a brick of salt that you get wet and rub under your pits. All that salt kills the bacteria that make you stink. It's unscented so it doesn't clash with your cologne.

Ah, it's not the end of the world. Tom's also makes a liquid that uses a salt crystal like this which I've heard is an alternative. Some of the reviews say that Tom's gave them a giant itchy rash though? Now I'm a bit scared.

https://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI

I am all about this deodorant stone right now. It's soooo weird but so cool, it's like legit a stone that you wet and rub on your pits. It doesn't stop you from sweating (which is unhealthy anyway) but it kills the odor in your sweat so that you aren't stinky.

This suggestion can't help with the current situation - but have you ever tried Crystal Mineral deodorant? it forms a mineral layer where the bacteria that cause underarm stink can live in so you sweat, but no smell https://www.amazon.com/Crystal-Mineral-Deodorant-Stick-Unscented/dp/B000L978FU/ref=sr_1_4?crid=3Q4JHF0LWX09N&keywords=crystal+deodorant&qid=1573248898&sprefix=crystal+de%2Caps%2C202&sr=8-4

If nothing else works, try buying a bag of activated charcole and putting it in a plastic bin with your sweater and sealing it shut for a few days

My wife recently had me try her hippie crystal deodorant stick. I was very skeptical because I'm a pretty stinky guy at times, but I'll be damned. It works super damn well on me.

Most days that's all I use, but some days I combine it with my regular deodorant. I still sweat obnoxiously too much, but antiperspirants irritate my skin too much.

Get some Crystal Deodorant. Take a shower before your ride, and put that on anywhere you expect an oder. The minerals keep you from sweating in your nether regions and kill the bacteria that produce the stank.

I got the travel size of this. You wet it and also wet your clean armpits (can't be put on without cleaning your pits wth soap first) and rub it all around each pit for 30 seconds. It neutralizes the zone, making all the smelly bacteria not smelly anymore. People say you still sweat with it, I say I sweat even less than what I was with regular deodorant, and now I smell like literally nothing in there. Also, the rock lasts forever. That is, unless you drop it in your sink and it breaks, which is why I went with a travel size. I know someone who has the kind where it's a whole rock in a dish like this and she's on year 5 and the darn thing is not done yet.

Also, it was explained to me that one of the reasons aluminum in regular deodorant is bad for you is because since it's a large metal particle, it literally clogs your sweat glands. So in doing that, your telling your body it's basically not doing a good job of sweating (because you're blocking the sweat) so your body is like "omg we need to work harder!" so it produces more and more sweat. After a few years of that, your body is like on hyperdrive of making you sweat, rendering your deodorant useless. So when I switched to the crystal and quit blocking the sweat glands from doing its natural thing, my body was like "hell yeah we're doing a kickass job we don't need to work as hard to push this crap out anymore" and now I don't even sweat almost at all anymore.

Because modern deodorants are absolute crap filled with chemicals you don't need, fragrances and binding agents. Eventually these leave resides that clog pores that can lead to issues and rashes.

I use this which is what people mostly used before the advent of trying to sell you bullshit you don't need all in the guise of providing profits to investors.

https://www.amazon.com/THAI-Natural-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounces/dp/B000AN1JEI

This may take awhile for you to get used to this but works excellent for me - hardly any smell at all - no rashes - no bullshit shit lasts fucking forever.

Your armpits smell because modern deodorants just mask smell they don't make the environment inhospitable for growth to even take place to where it becomes an issue with smell. Once you start using this give it a week or two as your body and skin adjust.

I cut my own hair. Every 2 weeks when I cut my hair I put the "blending" guard on the clippers and run them over my armpits to trim back my arm pit hair. Its long enough that its not itchy but short enough to be more hygienic.

I use Thai Crystal Deodorant Stone under my arms. It has no scent and it doesn't stain. Its Potassium Aluminum Sulfate which is sometimes referred to as Alum block. There is a debate as to whether its safe because of the link between aluminum and Alzheimer's disease. Some people claim the Potassium Aluminum Sulfate molecule is too large to pass through your skin. Its up to you to research but from what I've read its no worse than any other under arm deodorant product sold in grocery stores.

I think the stuff works great. No gummy feeling under my arms and no stains on my shirts. A Thai Crystal Deodorant Stone lasts me 8 months to a year. I get from Whole Foods Market for about 8 bucks. It requires you to wet the stone with cold water and rub a wet hand over your armpit then vigorously rub around under your arm for 30 to 60 seconds but after the area has been covered I've gone up to 3 days with no pit odor. You apply it right after a shower. It won't do anything if you already stink, it prevents the smell from developing in the first place. When stones get too small for under my arms I use them on my face after I shave and on small cuts to stop the bleeding.

http://www.amazon.com/Thai-Deodorant-Stone-Crystal-Deodorant-Ounce/dp/B000AN1JEI

I’m guessing you’re using this to avoid aluminum (and other nasty evil chemicals). I don’t know why, because we’re likely exposed to more naturally-occurring aluminum in the environment every day than you’d rub on your pits. And no, not from manufacturing. Aluminum makes up about 8% of the Earth’s crust and is the most abundant metal in the crust. It’s the 3rd most abundant element following oxygen and silicone.

That said, the ingredient for this thing is potassium alum, aka potassium aluminum sulfate
(which is a chemical compound despite their claims that it’s “completely free of chemicals.” Because literally everything is a chemical.) so: aluminum. Screenshot of their Amazon page.

Btw, that “chemical-free” hunk of potassium aluminum sulfate you’ve been using is also used as an organic fertilizer. I figure you probably buy only organic, so there you go.

So while you’ve pointlessly tried to avoid rubbing it on, you’ve likely been eating it.

In other words: you and everyone else who bought into the fear-mongering got played. As usual. For something that almost certainly does not work. Which they actually admit on the above product page.


Edit: note that I said “I’m guessing,” because there may be other reasons people have for rubbing a rock on their pits. But the vast majority of users are in fact scared of the eeeevul aluminumz chemikillz. Sadly, they just believe whatever garbage scam these companies push and throw money at them.

If you have never tried using the crystal-type deodorant, give it a go. BO comes from certain bacteria digesting the sebum secreted from certain parts of your body (the smelly ones: pits and crack to crotch). Deodorants typically only provide some fragrance to cover the stanky build-up, but the crystal works by killing those bacteria. It takes a few days (one week at most) for its effect to build up, but it does work.

Years ago, as a starving college student, I worked construction ~30 hours a week to pay for tuition, etc. Working in the hot, humid central Alabama summertime and scrambling to clean up for classes resulted in the desperate fetid stench that can only be described in relation to the swamps of Dagobah. Repeated showers didn't work. Antiperspirants didn't work. Industrial strength scents designed for pubescent boys didn't work. As someone who had always prided himself on his personal hygiene, I was really deeply traumatized; suddenly, for reasons beyond my control, I had become the stinky guy that everyone avoids. The only think that worked was that crystal.

Finally, as an added bonus, it is remarkably cheap since one stick will last for years if you ignore the directions and apply the dry stick to a wet armpit immediately after showering instead of wetting the stick under the faucet.