(Part 2) Reddit mentions: The best mattress toppers
We found 163 Reddit comments discussing the best mattress toppers. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 87 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the products ranked 21-40. You can also go back to the previous section.
21. Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper - Soft - 2 Inch - King Size
Latex Provides Amazing Pinpointed Support - Sleep Better Instantly100% Natural Latex - No Synthetic Latex - No FillersSoft but also supportive (Firmness rating is 20 ILD)4.0 lbs/cubic ftLatex Foam Naturally Stays Cool
Specs:
Color | Natural |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 80 Inches |
Size | 2" King |
Weight | 32 Pounds |
Width | 76 Inches |
22. Milliard Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper – 2 Inches Thick with Premium 2.5 Pound Density and a Cover That’s Removable and Washable – King – 78”74”2
- Maximum comfort – Constructed with luxurious 2-inch thick, 100% gel memory foam that softly contours to the curves of your body to reduce pressure points, prevent soreness, and relieve stress, joint pain, muscle pain, and arthritis symptoms
- Complimentary cover – A free, silky-soft bamboo fiber cover is included with this topper. The cover features a non-slip bottom to prevent it from moving around in bed, and it’s removable and washable, so you never have to worry about keeping your topper clean
- Long lasting – Premium 2.5-pound density foam supersedes all other toppers in its class and prevents it from flattening and losing shape over time
- Cooling effects – Unique open-cell technology and gel infused beads work together to regulate sleep temperature and increase ventilation while you sleep
- Allergy Relief – our CertiPUR-US certified foam is naturally hypoallergenic to provide relief for allergy and asthma sufferers
Features:
Specs:
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 78 Inches |
Size | King |
Width | 74 Inches |
23. Queen Size 3 Inch Thick, 5 Pound Density Gray Gel Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Pad Bed Topper Made in The USA
- Instantly makes any mattress more restful, comfortable, and supportive in sagging areas of mattress
- 3 inches of extra supportive 5 lb memory foam conforms to your body perfectly
- Made in the USA using enviromentally friendly processes.
- Memory foam reduces pressure points that cause you to toss and turn, so you sleep better.
- Topper features a five-pound density and the famous gel-like
Features:
Specs:
Color | Natural |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 80 Inches |
Size | Queen |
Width | 60 Inches |
24. 3 inch Twin XL Size Accu-Aire 3.3 Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Topper Made in The USA
- Made in the USA, excceeds PURGreen, EPA and CPSC certification standards. 3 Inches Thick
- Scientifically advanced visco elastic memory foam wicks away excessive heat build up.
- Accu-Aire will provide you with more pressure relieving comfort without increased temperatures.
- Accu-Aire is unique because of its ability to soften and contour to the shape of your body relieving pressure.
- Accutex Foam USA visco elastic memory foam has been the ultimate leader in premier comfort bedding.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Neutral |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 80 Inches |
Size | Twin XL |
Width | 38 Inches |
25. Zen Bamboo Ultra Soft Rayon Derived from Bamboo Mattress Topper - Premium Hypoallergenic Mattress Pad - King
- Premium quality: Our topper is manufactured with top quality materials to ensure long-lasting durability, and is stitched with a double-needle baffle box to keep fill balanced and in place.
- Cooling bamboo: Special blend of soft microfiber and natural bamboo helps regulate body temperature and prevents heat from being trapped between the body and the mattress.
- Machine washable: No expensive dry cleaning necessary! Simply wash the Zen Bamboo Mattress Topper in cold water and tumble dry on the low setting.
Features:
Specs:
Color | White |
Size | King |
26. Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper Twin Extra Long, Plush 2 Inch Thick, Premium Gel Infused Twin XL Memory Foam Mattress/Bed Topper/Pad for a Cool, and Comfortable Sleep. Made in The USA
- Indoor Plants Growing: 48"x24"x60" grow tent for indoor plant growing in a small apartment or house. Great enclosure allows proper light, humidity and temperature for sprouting seedlings, sexing plants and flowering. Perfect for tomato plants, pepper, cilantro, vegetable lettuce, ect.
- Light Proof: 98% reflective Mylar interior lining, tear-proof 600D double stitched grow tent room kit blocks all light from escaping, HID lighting, HPS grow light and MH bulbs, no light leakage by the circular openings with double drawstrings or by observation window with light-tight seal.
- Ventilation: All vent holes are circular double sleeved. Ventilation openings are to handle cables and for air circulation by exhaust fan, ducting hose, carbon filter, ballast and reflector. Better allows proper light, heat and air flow for seed germination and flowering period in indoor gardening horticulture.
- Easy to Setup: Ergonomic and Easy to assemble. No tools needed, just make sure all the rubber feet are going the same direction. The hydroponic growing room is also easy to dissemble for clean-up or relocation. Extra canvas floor tray holds water for 3 days as a test with no leaks.
- CUSTOMER CARE: We offer premium products for you while exceeding highest industry standards and offer thoughtful and considerate customer care.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 79 Inches |
Size | Twin XL |
Width | 38 Inches |
27. Zinus 3 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress Topper / Green Tea & Charcoal Infused for Freshness / CertiPUR-US Certified, Full
REFRESHING SLEEP, BUILT RIGHT IN - If good sleep is your cup of tea, then you’ll love our recipe for rejuvenating rest; refreshing green tea and moisture-absorbing charcoal are infused into memory foam that cradles you so you awake restored and refreshedNATURAL INGREDIENTS - This 3 inch layer feat...
Specs:
Color | White |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 74 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Full |
Weight | 11.22 Pounds |
Width | 53 Inches |
28. LUCID 2 Inch 5 Zone Lavender Memory Foam Mattress Topper - Queen
- 2 inch memory foam mattress topper with five body zones to maximize comfort
- Memory foam is infused with the relaxing scent of lavender and textured to improve breathability
- Textured zones reduce pressure at different points of body contact to prevent tossing and turning
- Specialized memory foam formula is designed to be extremely soft, airy and responsive
Features:
Specs:
Color | Lavender |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 60 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Queen |
Weight | 8.95 Pounds |
Width | 80 Inches |
29. 1-Inch Slab Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Twin
- Adds an extra level of comfort and support to a mattress or air mattress
- Relieves pressure points by adjusting to the body's contours, reducing tossing and turning
- 1-inch thick visco-elastic memory foam
- Crafted from temperature sensitive memory foam; spot clean
- Twin size measures 34 x 72 x 1 inches
- Made in the USA
Features:
Specs:
Color | Beige |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 72 Inches |
Size | Twin |
Weight | 1.76 Pounds |
Width | 34 Inches |
30. Linenspa 3 Inch Convoluted Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper - Promotes Airflow - Relieves Pressure Points - Queen, LS30QQ30CSGT
Light and breathable open cell memory foam molds to the contours of your body to relieve pressure points aches while you sleepConvoluted, egg crate design provides maximum airflow and comfort by evenly dispersing your body weightMesmerizing blue swirl design creates a fun and cool sleep environment;...
Specs:
Color | Topper Only |
Height | 22.83 Inches |
Length | 14.17 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Queen |
Weight | 5.93 Pounds |
Width | 14.17 Inches |
31. LUCID 2" Gel Infused Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Queen
- Topper
Features:
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 60 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Queen |
Weight | 14 Pounds |
Width | 80 Inches |
32. Full/Double Size 3 Inch Thick, 4 Pound Density Gray Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Pad Bed Topper Made in The USA
Instantly makes any mattress more restful, comfortable and supportive in sagging areas of mattress3-Inch of extra supportive 4-Pounds memory foam conforms to your body perfectlyMade in USAMemory foam reduces pressure points that cause you to toss and turn, so you sleep betterTopper features a 4-poun...
Specs:
Color | Natural |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 73 Inches |
Size | 3" Thick-Full |
Weight | 25.51 Pounds |
Width | 52 Inches |
33. Ultimate Dreams Queen 3" Talalay Latex Medium Mattress Topper
Luxurious feel and naturally resilient, our latex topper is available in three firmness levels: Soft (19 ILD), Medium (28 ILD) or Firm (36 ILD)Talalay latex provides up to 33% more pressure relief than conventional foam and fiber cushioning materialsContours to the shape of your body for the ultimat...
34. Soft Heaven Mattress Cover - All Around Zipper - Non Skid Bottom - Hypoallergenic Bed Bug Dust Mite - Luxury Jacquard Velour Fabric - Replacement Cover for 7", 8" or 9" Thick Memory Foam or Latex or Conventional Mattress (Queen 60"x80")
- 150 lbs. load capacity per shelf, Assembled Dimensions: 22.5 in L x 9.1 in W x 32 in H
- 4 casters for easy mobility
- 3 shelves with raised borders to prevent objects from falling or rolling off
- Height adjustable shelves for versatility and to accommodate storage needs
- Made with chrome plated steel for durability
Features:
Specs:
Color | Brown537 |
Height | 4.61 Inches |
Length | 16.3 Inches |
Size | 7+537 |
Weight | 2.95 Pounds |
Width | 11.5 Inches |
35. Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Plush Queen Size 2 Inch Thick, Premium Gel-Infused Memory Foam Mattress/Bed Topper/Pad for a Cool, Conforming, and Comfortable Sleep. Made in The USA
COMFORTABLY PERFECT. You deserve a better night's rest. Add an extra level of comfort to your existing mattress with our plush medium-soft 2 inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper. Our innovative gel foam mattress topper queen helps to relieve pressure points, relax muscles, help spinal alignment and ...
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 79 Inches |
Size | Queen |
Width | 59 Inches |
36. Linenspa 2" Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Twin XL
- Two inches of ultra-plush memory foam that conforms to your curves and hugs you to sleep
- Infused with temperature regulating gel beads that capture and dissipate heat to help prevent overheating
- Comfortable memory foam distributes weight evenly to soften the feel of your mattress
- Available in plush 2-inch and 3-inch profiles; the 3-inch topper will hug your body more than the 2-inch topper
- A comfortable and affordable way to rejuvenate an old mattress, soften a hard mattress, and prolong mattress life; backed by a 3-year warranty
Features:
Specs:
Color | Topper Only |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 79 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Twin XL |
Weight | 7.5 Pounds |
Width | 37.5 Inches |
37. Zinus Sleep Master 2 Inch Memory Foam, Short Queen Mattress Topper,
2 inches ventilated memory foam for ideal pressure relief and supportRejuvenate your mattress with memory foam comfortOnly the highest Quality memory foam - memory foam is CertiPUR-US certified for durability, performance, and ContentSmartly Shipped-Our patented technology allows our mattress topper...
Specs:
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 72 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Short Queen |
Weight | 9.66 Pounds |
Width | 58 Inches |
38. Full / Double Size 3 Inch iSoCore 3.0 Memory Foam Mattress Pad, Bed Topper, Overlay Made From 100% Temperature Sensitive Memory Foam
Super Soft, Luxurious and Resilient, Memory Foam Conforms to the Contours of your BodyNext Generation Memory Foam Technology, 100% iSoCore 3.0 Visco Elastic Memory FoamiSoCore 3.0 memory foam products will improve the one third of your life that is spent in bed.This luxurious visco elastic material ...
Specs:
Color | Natural |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 75 Inches |
Size | Full |
Weight | 0.64 Pounds |
Width | 54 Inches |
39. Twin XL Size 3 Inch Thick, 4 Pound Density Gray Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Pad Bed Topper Made in The USA
- Instantly makes any mattress more restful, comfortable and supportive in sagging areas of mattress
- Twin XL 3 inchs of extra supportive 4 lb memory foam conforms to your body perfectly
- Made in USA. Memory foam reduces pressure points that cause you to toss and turn, so you sleep better
- Topper features a four-pound density and the famous gel-like feel
- Item must be left in an ambient temperature above 72 degrees to fully decompress since they are temperature sensitive visco elastic memory foam
Features:
Specs:
Color | Natural |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 78 Inches |
Size | 3" Thick-Twin X-Large |
Weight | 18.37 Pounds |
Width | 36 Inches |
40. 2 inch Twin XL Size Accu-Aire 3.3 Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Topper Made in The USA
Made in the USA, excceeds PURGreen, EPA and CPSC certification standards. 2 Inches ThickScientifically advanced visco elastic memory foam wicks away excessive heat build up.Accu-Aire will provide you with more pressure relieving comfort without increased temperatures.Accu-Aire is unique because of i...
Specs:
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 80 Inches |
Size | Twin XL |
Width | 38 Inches |
🎓 Reddit experts on mattress toppers
The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where mattress toppers are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
One thing I have learned over the years is that while quality can be expensive, it doesn't have to be. Also, what one person loves and thinks is the "softest set of sheets ever!!!!" can feel like sandpaper to another person. (OK that's two things. Oh well.)
I have major sleep and texture issues, so I have spent a lot of years perfecting my bedding. After much searching and much cost, I ended up finding out that the Target UltraSoft sheets are my second favorite ever (to some discontinued Lands' End knit, their current knit is not the same.) I love that these sheets come in individuals, so you can buy just the ones you need. On the opposite end of the spectrum, I just got a new pillowcase from Sheex at Bed, Bath, and Beyond, and it is amazing. Someday I will get their Bamboo Sheet Set as my summer/alternate sheets.
For blankets, I'm a big fan of the warm fuzzy ones. Target again has some from a couple of their brands (Threshold and Shabby Chic) but I find they're not quite as good quality as they used to be. I have recently acquired a new SherpaSoft blanket from Bed, Bath, and Beyond which is amazing. It is thick, soft, and warm and happened to be on clearance plus I was able to use one of their coupons for it.
I absolutely love a down comforter, but I'm allergic to actual down. I stumbled across the Pinzon Down Alternative comforter at Amazon, I have had mine for nearly 5 years and it is still in excellent condition. Duvet cover is super personal depending on style, but if you have a thing for flannel, I highly recommend the Pinzon flannel duvet cover as well. Another thing I've had for years and love, the Pinzon 190-gram is my favorite flannel, even above LL Bean and Lands' End.
Due to some surprise issues (hello, holes in my former (not the Target) favorite sheets!) I also ended up going on a spree and replacing some bedding basics last weekend. I have a memory foam topper on my mattress, which means I needed a cotton mattress pad/cover otherwise my topper turned into a heat-generating slab of concrete. I tried something from a local store that didn't work, ended up back at Amazon for the Zen Bamboo Ultra Soft Mattress Topper. Slept on it last night and it was fabulous.
And finally, after a couple of failures, I stumbled across this adjustable! pillow from Coop Home Goods on Amazon, which is absolutely amazing. I like a soft pillow but need neck support, but most pillows are too thick for me. I love that you can simply zip the pillow open and remove a bit of the fill, or add more if you like a firmer pillow (they sell additional fill linked from the pillow page.)
Congratulations on your new house, and good luck with your bedding shopping! A well-attired bed makes the whole experience so much nicer.
I got https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00UYG8HRS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o03_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Which is sold by Sleep on Latex via amazon ( https://sleeponlatex.com/pages/our-story-2 )- who is mentioned here frequently. The issue, however, is that they only seem to sell dunlop and from what I tried in the store I liked the bounce of talalay.
I got a 2" soft which will augment my mattress' current 2" comfort layer. I was going to go for a 3" but my wife is a back sleeper and so 2" felt like a good middle ground.
I also went with them because it ships via prime and reading the feedback they are responsive in case a return is needed and will help facilitate shipping back a giant king sized slab of foam. =)
I'm hopeful I can figure something out! My next step would be moving towards diymattress.net since they sell talalay toppers. Which on that note, I found their website section on how to build a mattress interesting.
Reviews can only tell you so much unfortunately. Everyone is a little different in what they want.
Goods about that mattress: Uses the combi-zone coils from Leggett and Platt, which are good coils. They aren't revolutionary technology that that Voila came up with and there are some options for getting them in a mattress. http://www.mattresses.net/ulhypoco.html
Another good is that it does use some latex in the comfort layers.
The bad: I have no clue what the other foam layers are, what their density is and whether they will last. Memory foam layers should be at least 4 pounds per cubic foot (pcf) or 5 pcf density (especially if you are heavier)
Polyfoam should be at least 1.8 with 2 being the minimum for heavier people.
If they are willing to tell you more about the densities of the foams and you are ok with everything, then it might not be a terrible buy.
However, if they don't tell you what's inside the mattress, it's best to assume the worst and potentially move on to something else.
That link I included is a mattress that I got and have had good success with so far. It might be worth considering along with other options. It could also be part of your DIY project as you can order those components separate from the mattress. They also make a slow recovery latex that is supposed to be more like memory foam.
All things to think about, and good luck. It's not a bad idea to go down the rabbit hole when researching. https://www.themattressunderground.com/
Edit: DIY
http://www.mattresses.net/copocobylean.html
http://www.mattresses.net/kibawozimaco.html (the coils are 9inch, get the 12 inch to include the topper in the mattress)
For the comfort layer these are two options.
http://www.mattresses.net/puslrelato.html
https://www.amazon.com/Density-Elastic-Memory-Foam-Mattress/dp/B006QWWW5C?th=1
The advantage of going the DIY route is that you can customize if you don't like the feel. for example, say you get the memory foam, but it doesn't quite cushion or support as well as you would like. You can add a medium or firm 3 inch latex layer and have the memory foam on top of the mattress. Of you can replace the memory foam in 5 years when it starts to wear out because the coils will still be good.
I was on the forth floor of Murray last year and will be again this coming year. You will need to bring an Ethernet cord for your PS4, as well as a coax cable for your TV. Try and make both of them a minimum of 6 feet. Most of the time you will need them to wrap around the room to make it to your devices. My coax cable was like 15 feet and super cheap. The first week everywhere is going to be sold out of them so get them ahead of time.
My roommate couldn't keep from stealing my stuff from the big fridge so I had to get my own (again, something sold out the first week of classes).
There isn't too many outlets in the room so a power strip is helpful, one with usb ports at the end saves space.
You shouldn't need a safe unless you really need to protect something extra carefully. There is a lock on your door as well as the door to the hall way. Connected to your desk is cabinet that can be locked, something like this will work.
Also, the most underrated thing I brought was a 2 inch memory foam type padding to go on top of the mattress something above an inch will do wonders. I think I got mine from target for like $40 and it really is amazing compared to the standard mattress.
In Murray you can change the temperature with the thermostat in the room so I never needed a fan, though I had the one on the ceiling on all the time.
Mattress protector/encasement: Hypoallergenic bag to seal bed bugs, dust mites, and spills in/out of mattress. https://www.amazon.com/Encasement-Waterproof-Hypoallergenic-Breathable-Protector/dp/B00Z06F2OI/ref=sr_1_4?keywords=Mattress+protector&qid=1562627220&s=gateway&sr=8-4
Mattress topper: Egg crate or gel foam that is placed on top of the mattress for extra comfort. https://www.amazon.com/Memory-Foam-Topper-Mattress-Sleep/dp/B01GICXDN4/ref=sr_1_6?keywords=Mattress+topper+twin+xl&qid=1562627405&s=gateway&sr=8-6
Mattress pad: Lightly padded/quilted but otherwise similar to a fitted sheet, placed below sheets to protect mattress & hold everything together. (Kinda like underwear for your mattress.) https://www.amazon.com/Gilbin-College-Quilted-Mattress-Polyester/dp/B00MGWK06E/ref=sr_1_9?crid=HBFAAZPF1KD5&keywords=mattress+pad+twin+xl&qid=1562627643&s=gateway&sprefix=Mattress+pad+er+twin+xl%2Caps%2C146&sr=8-9
Mattress protectors are a good idea if you have dust mite allergies, or have concerns about the cleanliness of the mattress. Topper is good if you are used to a plush pillow-top type mattress or find the mattress too firm. Mattress pad is really useful if you are using one of the other two things, or to add a little buffer if the mattress material is plastic or rough.
ETA: You can find combo protector/pads, topper/pads, etc. too. So many options.
I share most of your sentimates regarding air mattresses. For that reason, this year I decided to spend some extra moolah on getting a nice one. It's made out of a kevlar like material and doesnt leak at all. It's super light and rolls up to the size of a sleeping bag (or less to be honest).
Also I bought a REALLY nice 3 or 4 inch thick foam mattress that fits perfectly on it. Those with a solid sheet and I'm going to be sleeping soundly.
Here are links to each:
KingCamp 2-Person PVC-Free Ultralight Camping Air Bed Mattress with Battery Operated Pump, 6 Pounds https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01D19MO4G/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_DIJYAb0NXR5AY
Zinus 3 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Full https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071FVJ3XY/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apap_lFrlCFcKMqTcW
the herb Lavender is known to help with sleep a lot, you can burn Lavender incense like a hour or so before you go to bed, make some tea with it, make a dream pillow or ever buy a Lavender infused mattress topper like this.
https://www.amazon.com/LUCID-2-inch-5-Zone-Lavender-Mattress/dp/B01H2N2G3Q
note: I hear that Lavender tea can be very strong it might be best to mix it with something else.
A mattress topper will make your bed feel ten times more comfortable
As for me I would like this tea pot
Congrats on the job and good luck!
Absolutely get new bedsheets then, maybe a new stuffy, and maybe a squishy mattress topper so it feels different when you lay on it. Consider painting the frame too, but have friends over to help you, but don't do that one immediately.
Make it different. Trust me on that one. Move the art on the walls around too. Create some tangible physical changes.
i have that exact topper and it is amazing. I'm at 330 lbs at 5'7 for reference. i got it because i got a new mattress that was very firm (need it to be or it would sag horribly under my weight) and it is a godsend. I am a side sleeper exclusively.
it isnt noticably warm to sleep on, although i have a waterproof cover over it (like a fitted sheet with a rubber layer) and then normal sheets. but i do not notice it being warmer than a typical mattress.
it is very plush and it has held up extremely well to weight and body heat in the 2 and a half years i have had it. (using it at minimum 6 nights a week, usually all 7). it is noticeably discolored from heat in the apot i sleep on, but it is just as plush as it was when i first got it (i know because the other half of the queen mattress is virtually unused and flipping the topper feels exactly the same). i do not know if it absorbs body oils, and if that would make it smell, because like i said i use a water proof sheet to avoid that.
it did smell a bit funky the first few days but after a week it went away, and it was unnoticeable under the sheets (i used it for a month before getting the waterproof sheet, so that observation is through one layer of cotton sheets).
i definitely recommend getting the topper!!!!!
edit: sorry i have the 2inch one!!
LUCID 2" Gel Infused Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Queen https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00PBIVWC6/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_J3sjDbBG2KX9C
People have already said it and I'm going to agree with them. As long as the mattress you have now is still good, just get a topper for it. When the whole mattress needs to be replaced, look into investing into a quality memory foam mattress then. In the meantime, save some money.
Toppers come in various densities that affect the quality of it. Higher the density the better usually. We bought this one about 8 months ago and are (so far) very happy with it.
For an aging mattress your best option to extend it's life is a latex topper. For maximum comfort I recommend Talalay poured latex.
One if the most economical options is Dreamfoam Bedding's latex topper. It comes in several sizes. It's a 3" inch thick topper with no cover. This is standard practice. You put it under a mattress cover than put your sheets over it. A queen size will run you $354 but there is usually no sales tax. Amazon also offers 6 month zero interest if that helps.
>Ultimate Dreams Queen 3" Talalay Latex Medium Mattress Topper https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00EK0FJDY/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_ahvEAb0R0TZ81
The $600 max is really limiting you. Otherwise you could go with flexuscomfort.com , sleepez.com , or sedonasleep.com which all offer queen-size mattresses with split-firmness latex layers.
Even if you give up on the split firmness to save money, you are still limiting yourself at $600 since presumably one of you is over 200 pounds, and people over 200 pounds need a mattress with higher-density foam, which is more expensive than the cheap foam found in many cheap mattresses. If you could go up to $712, then brooklynbedding.com would be a good choice, since it uses high quality materials suitable for people of any weight. (I'd consider returning that frame if you could, and then put the money to a better mattress -- you can use the mattress on the floor until you are able to afford a foundation or bed frame)
If you absolutely must stick to $600 max, then the best I can recommend would be to go the DIY route. You can get a 6-in thick polyfoam core for $219 plus shipping here:
https://diymattress.net/products/foam-base-core-certipur-us?variant=30901531788
then you can get a 3-inch Talalay blended-latex layer here for $300 plus shipping:
http://www.kttenterprises.com/price-warranty-density-chart.html
(or you could get two 2-in thick twin-XL size latex layers, different firmnesses, and cut them down in width so they fit on the queen-size core)
And last, a mattress cover. Here is one for $70 :
https://www.amazon.com/Soft-Heaven-Mattress-Cover-Hypoallergenic/dp/B00WB8M9BC/
or one for $55 :
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F4IEXH4/
That might all come out a little above $600 after you add in shipping.
So this isn't gel but if you can afford it or have really generous gifters I love Tempurpedic.
Here is an example of the gel and they come in all different inches.
I have this one and I actually really like it. Super affordable too. Made the on-campus beds much more bearable. I have the 2-inch and that's been good enough for my needs. :)
A big fan would definitely help- sometimes the towers are a bit wimpy. And for the topper, I do love memory foam- something like this: https://www.amazon.com/Zinus-Green-Memory-Mattress-Topper/dp/B072MS926S/ref=sr_1_2?s=home-garden&ie=UTF8&qid=1501778442&sr=1-2-spons&keywords=memory+foam+topper&psc=1
Go buy yourself a good foam pad. Not something for backpacking or the like. Something like this. Do that. Bring a couple of handwarmers into bed with ya, and you'll be amazed at how warm it will be. Not much else required, really.
I'm making this recommendation not because I had one and liked it, but because I didn't have one and it's probably the one thing that would have increased my comfort greatly.
I found this on amazon for $50, but tbh I have no idea whether it actually is a good product or not. However as long as it holds up to use and doesn't give off an offensive odor it should be appreciated.