Best products from r/carbonsteel
We found 25 comments on r/carbonsteel discussing the most recommended products. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 25 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.
1. De Buyer Mineral B Element Pro Round Frying Pan, 28 cm, 51.79 x 35 x 9.4 cm, Silver
- Natural non-stick properties
- Enhanced non-stick qualities when used for the first time
- Undeform able thick skirt
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions2. Lodge Pan Scrapers. Handheld Polycarbonate Cast Iron Pan Cleaners. (2-Pack. Red/Black)
- Pan Scrapers – Includes 1 Red and 1 Black Scraper
- Durable Polycarbonate is dishwasher safe
- Features 4 different shaped corners for cleaning any shaped pan
- Also ideal as a gum, sticker remover
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions3. The Ringer - The Original Stainless Steel Cast Iron Cleaner, Patented XL 8x6 Inch Design
- PATENTED XL 8X6 DESIGN FOR DURABILITY. We don’t use just any chainmail. The Ringer uses premium grade never rusting stainless steel that is machine soldered, and built for strength. The machines that manufacture our patented product were originally intended to protect police officers from stab wounds. When life is on the line, you can’t risk chinks in your armor. We bring that same strength to your kitchen sink and believe in quality that won’t let you down
- MADE IN NORTH AMERICA. When you buy the Ringer, you aren’t going to be left with some flimsy, hand-crimped chainmail made overseas which will pull apart and end up scratching your skillet with a rough ring edge. Most competing products are manufactured in China, leaving you with a low quality scraper. We searched worldwide to find the best quality around, and we found it here in North America. Simply put, The Ringer is set to last as long as your cast iron skillet
- TOUGH ON GRIT, GENTLE ON FLAVOR. Wash off the grit AND preserve the flavor with soap-less, detergent-free grit removal. You don’t need to fear your seasoning being stripped off by harsh soap or cleaners. With The Ringer all you need is warm water and you’re good to go. Let’s keep your flavors in the family, not with the fishes. Works great in addition with cast iron seasoning or cast iron conditioner
- MULTI-USE SCRUBBER, DISHWASHER SAFE. Kitchen sponges are 200,000 times dirtier than a toilet seat with 10,000,000 bacteria per square inch. Gross, we know. Don’t worry; this multi-purpose scrubber can be used for cast iron, glassware, stainless steel, a pizza stone, plates, baking sheets, a tea pot, cookie sheets, cauldrons, tortilla press, a hibachi, a waffle maker, a pie pan, a Dutch oven, griddle, woks, and casserole dishes. To clean, just throw it in the dishwasher
- IRON CLAD GUARANTEE. We’re confident that you’ll love The Ringer as much as we do. Used and loved by cast iron enthusiasts world wide, we’re confident you will be just as obsessed. Aren’t Satisfied? Let us know and we’ll get you taken care of
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions
5. 5-Piece Universal Knife Edge Guards are More Durable, BPA-Free, Gentle on Your Blades, and Long-Lasting. Noble Home & Chef Knife Covers Are Non-Toxic and Abrasion Resistant! (Knives Not Included)
- GENTLE ON YOUR BLADES: Our knife guards are felt-lined so that they protect your knives’ integrity without marring their finish or dulling their blades as they slide in and out of the sheath.
- SAFER, NON-BPA MATERIALS: Our chef knife covers are constructed from ABS plastic, which unlike its common alternative PVC plastic, is non-BPA and non-toxic.
- LONG-LASTING CONSTRUCTION: In addition to it being safer, we chose ABS plastic over PVC for our knife sleeves as it is harder, more resistant to abrasions, and has a higher impact strength. We also designed our knife sleeves to be thick, cut-proof, and more durable than thinner, flimsier edge guards.
- UNIVERSAL KNIFE BLADE SIZES: 5-Piece assorted knife protectors are designed to fit most paring, utility, boning, Santoku, chef, and bread knives. See dimensions below to determine if your specific knife set is well suited!
- KNIFE SHEATH DIMENSIONS: (1) 4.75" x 1", (1) 6” X 1”, (1) 6.25” X 1.25”, (1) 8.5” X 2”, (1) 10.5” x 2.25”. Sheath Dimensions are to cover the length of your blade. (Knives Not Included)
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions6. Fox Run Cookie/Brownie Spatula, 1 x 2.25 x 7 inches, Stainless Steel/Wood
- VERSATILE FUNCTION: In addition to being great for cookies, it's also perfect for cakes, small pizzas, casseroles, quiches, and pancakes!
- EASY STORAGE: This spatula is perfectly sized so that it can be stored easily and without unnecessary mess
- NO DESSERT LEFT UNCOVERED: With a beveled edge, this spatula slides under cookies and other desserts with ease! Combined with its smooth woodenhandle, you'll have more control over your scraping than ever before
- MEASUREMENTS: This cookie turner weighs 16 ounces and has dimensions of 1 x 225 x 7 inches
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions7. De Buyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan 12-1/2" Diameter
- Heavy quality iron frying pan ideal for searing, grilling and browning meat, fish, and eggs; lyonnaise skirt enables food to easily slide onto a plate
- Thick heavy quality iron heats up quickly, uniform heat distribution; reaches high temperatures--enables the Maillard reaction and caramelization of juices
- Natural non-stick properties--gradual seasoning of the pan--the more it is used the less the seasoning sticks to the food
- Riveted iron handle--unbreakable; French-style curvature for easy handling and ergonomic grip
- Use on all cooktops, including induction
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions8. De Buyer MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan 12.5-Inch - 5610.32
100-Percent Natural and 99-Percent Pure Iron. Care - deglaze and Do not use detergentsBee Wax was discovered by deBuyer as a by-product in nature to help protect these pans against oxidation and assist in seasoningWithout PTFE or PFOA and no chemicals added; naturally non-stick after seasoningMade i...
▼ Read Reddit mentions9. SolidTeknics AUS-ION 9-inch High Wall Skillet by Solidteknics - Seamless Steel - Satin Finish
- VG-MAX steel hardened to 61 degrees Rockwell
- 34 layers of stainless steel on each side of the blade for dramatic Damascus finish
- Sharpened to 16 degrees on each side of the blade for extreme sharpness
- Lifetime
- Handcrafted in Japan
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions10. Chef King 10 Gauge Steel Griddle, 12 Inch x 20 Inch
- Indestructible
- For 30" ranges and camping
- All Natural Stick Free Cooking
- Package dimensions: 22.0inches L x 12.0inches W x 2.0inches H
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions11. MINERAL B Round Country Chef Carbon Steel Fry Pan 9.5-Inch
- Carbon Steel Pan: 99% iron and 1% carbon, slippery with better sear, without any synthetic coating
- The Darker The Better: Signature beeswax finish protects against oxidation
- Nonstick Kitchen Essentials: Has natural nonstick once seasoned; Follow seasoning care instructions
- Made in France: Engineered and manufactured following the most stringent quality requirements
- About de Buyer: French maker of premium kitchen accessories, pastry equipment, and cooking utensils
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions12. Dexter-Russell All-Purpose Turner, Stainless Steel with Walnut Handle, Made in the USA
Heirloom quality built 5-inch turnerHigh quality stainless steel working endLovely walnut handle attached to tang with 3 rivetsThe Dexter Edge, the right solution since 1828Made in the USA
▼ Read Reddit mentions13. De Buyer Mineral B Frying Pan, 10.2 Inch, Silver-Grey
100-Percent Natural and 99-Percent Pure IronGuaranteed without PTFE or PFOA and no chemicals added; naturally non-stick after seasoningBee Wax was discovered by deBuyer as a by-product in nature to help protect these pans against oxidation and assist in seasoningCare : don't put it in the dishwasher...
▼ Read Reddit mentions14. MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Crepe/Tortilla Pan 9.5-Inch
- Tortilla Pan: Carbon steel pan is ideal for all your batters, crepes, pancakes, and tortillas
- The Darker The Better: Signature beeswax finish protects against oxidation
- Nonstick Kitchen Essentials: Has natural nonstick once seasoned; Follow seasoning care instructions
- Made in France: Engineered and manufactured following the most stringent quality requirements
- About de Buyer: French maker of premium kitchen accessories, pastry equipment, and cooking utensils
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions15. De Buyer Crepe Pan, Blue Steel, Made in France, 8-Inch Cooking Surface, 9.5-Inches Rim to Rim
De Buyer's French Crepe Pan offers the perfect cooking surface for creating, flipping, and plating perfectly thin, crisp and delicate crepes every timeMade in France from blue steel; easy to season and maintain; nonstick quality improves as natural patina builds up with use over timeShallow depth an...
▼ Read Reddit mentions16. ShellKingdom Portable Outdoor Emergency Butane Stove Burner for Camp
Automatic safety shut off.No matches necessary, windshield to protect flame.Adjustment Control.Portable design, Free easy to carry storage and carrying case.Gas Cartridge is not included
▼ Read Reddit mentions17. CARBONE PLUS Round Fry Pan 11-Inch Special Handle for Long Oven Cooking at High Temperatures
- Pan especially designed for cooking at high temperatures in a traditional oven firmly riveted strip steel handle in black with a special treatment can withstand extended periods in the oven
- Easy handling ergonomic grip lyonnaise skirt
- Natural non-stick properties heat the pan well before cooking mallard reaction and caramelization of juices season before first use gradual seasoning
- Care deglaze and rinse with Warm water Dry and oil lightly store in a Dry place do not use detergents or put in the dishwasher
- For all heat sources, including induction and oven cooking
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions18. Chef King 7 Gauge Steel Griddle, 14 Inch x 23 Inch
IndestructibleCommercial Grade and SizeAll Natural Stick Free CookingPackage dimensions: 23.5inches L x 14.5inches W x 2.2inches H
▼ Read Reddit mentions19. Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel Round Fry Pan, 11 7/8"
VARIETY OF USES: Brings top-notch heat distribution and temperature control, preserving the vitamins and nutrients in your foods, making it excellent for searing meats, browning omelets, grilling fish, and cooking a wide range of dishes, even dessertsNATURAL NON-STICK MATERIAL: Made of of black carb...
▼ Read Reddit mentions
Top comments mentioning products on r/carbonsteel:
Summary
1. De Buyer Mineral B Element Pro Round Frying Pan, 28 cm, 51.79 x 35 x 9.4 cm, Silver
- Natural non-stick properties
- Enhanced non-stick qualities when used for the first time
- Undeform able thick skirt
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions2. Lodge Pan Scrapers. Handheld Polycarbonate Cast Iron Pan Cleaners. (2-Pack. Red/Black)
- Pan Scrapers – Includes 1 Red and 1 Black Scraper
- Durable Polycarbonate is dishwasher safe
- Features 4 different shaped corners for cleaning any shaped pan
- Also ideal as a gum, sticker remover
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions3. The Ringer - The Original Stainless Steel Cast Iron Cleaner, Patented XL 8x6 Inch Design
- PATENTED XL 8X6 DESIGN FOR DURABILITY. We don’t use just any chainmail. The Ringer uses premium grade never rusting stainless steel that is machine soldered, and built for strength. The machines that manufacture our patented product were originally intended to protect police officers from stab wounds. When life is on the line, you can’t risk chinks in your armor. We bring that same strength to your kitchen sink and believe in quality that won’t let you down
- MADE IN NORTH AMERICA. When you buy the Ringer, you aren’t going to be left with some flimsy, hand-crimped chainmail made overseas which will pull apart and end up scratching your skillet with a rough ring edge. Most competing products are manufactured in China, leaving you with a low quality scraper. We searched worldwide to find the best quality around, and we found it here in North America. Simply put, The Ringer is set to last as long as your cast iron skillet
- TOUGH ON GRIT, GENTLE ON FLAVOR. Wash off the grit AND preserve the flavor with soap-less, detergent-free grit removal. You don’t need to fear your seasoning being stripped off by harsh soap or cleaners. With The Ringer all you need is warm water and you’re good to go. Let’s keep your flavors in the family, not with the fishes. Works great in addition with cast iron seasoning or cast iron conditioner
- MULTI-USE SCRUBBER, DISHWASHER SAFE. Kitchen sponges are 200,000 times dirtier than a toilet seat with 10,000,000 bacteria per square inch. Gross, we know. Don’t worry; this multi-purpose scrubber can be used for cast iron, glassware, stainless steel, a pizza stone, plates, baking sheets, a tea pot, cookie sheets, cauldrons, tortilla press, a hibachi, a waffle maker, a pie pan, a Dutch oven, griddle, woks, and casserole dishes. To clean, just throw it in the dishwasher
- IRON CLAD GUARANTEE. We’re confident that you’ll love The Ringer as much as we do. Used and loved by cast iron enthusiasts world wide, we’re confident you will be just as obsessed. Aren’t Satisfied? Let us know and we’ll get you taken care of
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions5. 5-Piece Universal Knife Edge Guards are More Durable, BPA-Free, Gentle on Your Blades, and Long-Lasting. Noble Home & Chef Knife Covers Are Non-Toxic and Abrasion Resistant! (Knives Not Included)
- GENTLE ON YOUR BLADES: Our knife guards are felt-lined so that they protect your knives’ integrity without marring their finish or dulling their blades as they slide in and out of the sheath.
- SAFER, NON-BPA MATERIALS: Our chef knife covers are constructed from ABS plastic, which unlike its common alternative PVC plastic, is non-BPA and non-toxic.
- LONG-LASTING CONSTRUCTION: In addition to it being safer, we chose ABS plastic over PVC for our knife sleeves as it is harder, more resistant to abrasions, and has a higher impact strength. We also designed our knife sleeves to be thick, cut-proof, and more durable than thinner, flimsier edge guards.
- UNIVERSAL KNIFE BLADE SIZES: 5-Piece assorted knife protectors are designed to fit most paring, utility, boning, Santoku, chef, and bread knives. See dimensions below to determine if your specific knife set is well suited!
- KNIFE SHEATH DIMENSIONS: (1) 4.75" x 1", (1) 6” X 1”, (1) 6.25” X 1.25”, (1) 8.5” X 2”, (1) 10.5” x 2.25”. Sheath Dimensions are to cover the length of your blade. (Knives Not Included)
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions6. Fox Run Cookie/Brownie Spatula, 1 x 2.25 x 7 inches, Stainless Steel/Wood
- VERSATILE FUNCTION: In addition to being great for cookies, it's also perfect for cakes, small pizzas, casseroles, quiches, and pancakes!
- EASY STORAGE: This spatula is perfectly sized so that it can be stored easily and without unnecessary mess
- NO DESSERT LEFT UNCOVERED: With a beveled edge, this spatula slides under cookies and other desserts with ease! Combined with its smooth woodenhandle, you'll have more control over your scraping than ever before
- MEASUREMENTS: This cookie turner weighs 16 ounces and has dimensions of 1 x 225 x 7 inches
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions7. De Buyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan 12-1/2" Diameter
- Heavy quality iron frying pan ideal for searing, grilling and browning meat, fish, and eggs; lyonnaise skirt enables food to easily slide onto a plate
- Thick heavy quality iron heats up quickly, uniform heat distribution; reaches high temperatures--enables the Maillard reaction and caramelization of juices
- Natural non-stick properties--gradual seasoning of the pan--the more it is used the less the seasoning sticks to the food
- Riveted iron handle--unbreakable; French-style curvature for easy handling and ergonomic grip
- Use on all cooktops, including induction
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions8. De Buyer MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan 12.5-Inch - 5610.32
100-Percent Natural and 99-Percent Pure Iron. Care - deglaze and Do not use detergentsBee Wax was discovered by deBuyer as a by-product in nature to help protect these pans against oxidation and assist in seasoningWithout PTFE or PFOA and no chemicals added; naturally non-stick after seasoningMade i...
▼ Read Reddit mentions9. SolidTeknics AUS-ION 9-inch High Wall Skillet by Solidteknics - Seamless Steel - Satin Finish
- VG-MAX steel hardened to 61 degrees Rockwell
- 34 layers of stainless steel on each side of the blade for dramatic Damascus finish
- Sharpened to 16 degrees on each side of the blade for extreme sharpness
- Lifetime
- Handcrafted in Japan
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions10. Chef King 10 Gauge Steel Griddle, 12 Inch x 20 Inch
- Indestructible
- For 30" ranges and camping
- All Natural Stick Free Cooking
- Package dimensions: 22.0inches L x 12.0inches W x 2.0inches H
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions11. MINERAL B Round Country Chef Carbon Steel Fry Pan 9.5-Inch
- Carbon Steel Pan: 99% iron and 1% carbon, slippery with better sear, without any synthetic coating
- The Darker The Better: Signature beeswax finish protects against oxidation
- Nonstick Kitchen Essentials: Has natural nonstick once seasoned; Follow seasoning care instructions
- Made in France: Engineered and manufactured following the most stringent quality requirements
- About de Buyer: French maker of premium kitchen accessories, pastry equipment, and cooking utensils
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions12. Dexter-Russell All-Purpose Turner, Stainless Steel with Walnut Handle, Made in the USA
Heirloom quality built 5-inch turnerHigh quality stainless steel working endLovely walnut handle attached to tang with 3 rivetsThe Dexter Edge, the right solution since 1828Made in the USA
▼ Read Reddit mentions13. De Buyer Mineral B Frying Pan, 10.2 Inch, Silver-Grey
100-Percent Natural and 99-Percent Pure IronGuaranteed without PTFE or PFOA and no chemicals added; naturally non-stick after seasoningBee Wax was discovered by deBuyer as a by-product in nature to help protect these pans against oxidation and assist in seasoningCare : don't put it in the dishwasher...
▼ Read Reddit mentions14. MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Crepe/Tortilla Pan 9.5-Inch
- Tortilla Pan: Carbon steel pan is ideal for all your batters, crepes, pancakes, and tortillas
- The Darker The Better: Signature beeswax finish protects against oxidation
- Nonstick Kitchen Essentials: Has natural nonstick once seasoned; Follow seasoning care instructions
- Made in France: Engineered and manufactured following the most stringent quality requirements
- About de Buyer: French maker of premium kitchen accessories, pastry equipment, and cooking utensils
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions15. De Buyer Crepe Pan, Blue Steel, Made in France, 8-Inch Cooking Surface, 9.5-Inches Rim to Rim
De Buyer's French Crepe Pan offers the perfect cooking surface for creating, flipping, and plating perfectly thin, crisp and delicate crepes every timeMade in France from blue steel; easy to season and maintain; nonstick quality improves as natural patina builds up with use over timeShallow depth an...
▼ Read Reddit mentions16. ShellKingdom Portable Outdoor Emergency Butane Stove Burner for Camp
Automatic safety shut off.No matches necessary, windshield to protect flame.Adjustment Control.Portable design, Free easy to carry storage and carrying case.Gas Cartridge is not included
▼ Read Reddit mentions17. CARBONE PLUS Round Fry Pan 11-Inch Special Handle for Long Oven Cooking at High Temperatures
- Pan especially designed for cooking at high temperatures in a traditional oven firmly riveted strip steel handle in black with a special treatment can withstand extended periods in the oven
- Easy handling ergonomic grip lyonnaise skirt
- Natural non-stick properties heat the pan well before cooking mallard reaction and caramelization of juices season before first use gradual seasoning
- Care deglaze and rinse with Warm water Dry and oil lightly store in a Dry place do not use detergents or put in the dishwasher
- For all heat sources, including induction and oven cooking
Features:
▼ Read Reddit mentions18. Chef King 7 Gauge Steel Griddle, 14 Inch x 23 Inch
IndestructibleCommercial Grade and SizeAll Natural Stick Free CookingPackage dimensions: 23.5inches L x 14.5inches W x 2.2inches H
▼ Read Reddit mentions19. Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel Round Fry Pan, 11 7/8"
VARIETY OF USES: Brings top-notch heat distribution and temperature control, preserving the vitamins and nutrients in your foods, making it excellent for searing meats, browning omelets, grilling fish, and cooking a wide range of dishes, even dessertsNATURAL NON-STICK MATERIAL: Made of of black carb...
▼ Read Reddit mentions
Sounds like the pan is too hot when you’re adding the sauce. Use as much heat as you like to cook the proteins and vegetables, but let it cool a bit before adding the sauce. It can sizzle, but it shouldn’t smoke or burn. This is especially true if the sauce has sugar in it.
To clean I really like the Lodge scrapers, followed by either the Ringer chainmail scrubber or a Japanese tawashi scrubber.
https://www.amazon.com/Lodge-Scrapers-Handheld-Polycarbonate-Cleaners/dp/B0039UU9UO
https://www.amazon.com/Ringer-Original-Stainless-Cleaner-Patented/dp/B00FKBR1ZG
https://www.amazon.com/Tawashi-TK-614-01A-Japanese-Scrubbing-Brush/dp/B001F6S40Q
I absolutely love my debuyer. Can’t go wrong with it imo. You are correct m, they are designed with a very slight raise in the middle of the pan (very slight, nothing crazy), supposedly to help prevent warping in be other direction which would cause it to spin on flat cooktops (I use glass-top electric). If you get debuyer I recommend the mineral B “pro” from amazon, as all of their other lines come with coated handles that are not technically oven safe. The “pro” mineral B’s are fitted with stainless steel handles with no coating and are really comfortable to hold.
This is the one that I purchased ,28 cm, the bottom fits my 8” electric burner almost perfectly: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00NSHWEHE
https://imgur.com/a/HGvrkHg/
I have a set of these: https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B077DXHWYS?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title
There is a felt like material on the inside that holds oil well (I use mineral oil). I clean my knives well, dry them, and put them in their covers.
They come out with a very light coating of oil. Plus, the edges are protected.
I started with this one and it’s the perfect size for me, a Little over 11” at the rim and about 8” across on the bottom. Debuyer is a solid brand and the handle on this one looks great and is very comfortable. Unlike most other CS pans, the stainless handle on this series has no coating and is completely ovensafe. Debuyer pans are also thicker than some others @3mm so less chance of warping - but they are pretty heavy as a result.
Link (no referral/affiliate link): De Buyer Professional 28 cm Iron... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00NSHWEHE
I personally love this spatula and don’t use any other one for griddle cooking after getting it: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001TRIPVE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_rd9HDbDYS137C
Idk why but the tiny cookie spatula is amazing
I'm confused about that pan. It doesn't look like any DeBuyer pans I know. I can't find it on the DeBuyer website either. Might be a fake. It's also very expensive.
My biggest DeBuyer is probably a 12". It's very heavy as well. Not as heavy as a cast iron would be, but still heavy.
https://www.amazon.com/Buyer-Carbon-Steel-Frying-Diameter/dp/B000ECQ83M/ref=sr_1_6?keywords=debuyer+pan&qid=1557153755&s=gateway&sr=8-6
That looks like a better one. It's a 12.5" pan. It's even cheaper and it looks like the real deal. Although I can't know for sure because it lacks some pixels.
I have just completed this research mission and learned that the lighter carbon pans tend to warp. While forgiven on gas, clearly not a good option for glass top. I ended up with the de Buyer on the basis of it being reportedly better quality control and thicker. https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B00462QP1G
When you mentioned high wall i looked up on amazon if there were more that were deep, the only one i could find was the Aus-ion. the rest look like typical skillets maybe a bit lower (cant really tell from pictures) I might use a crepe pan once in a while but nothing that often that makes me want to buy one RIGHT now.
are the other brands pretty reasonable on wall height?
I make pancakes all the time on this griddle with zero sticking. Do I use butter? Hell yes. But honestly I use exponentially more than I need simply because I'm not eating pancakes for a healthy meal. That and I typically want to have enough browned butter that I can immediately throw on the scrambled eggs as soon as the pancakes come off so everything is nice and hot.
I was in the same situation and went with the 11" and I'm glad i did. I think the 12.5" would have been too big and cumbersome to use as a pan. I'm looking at adding the 9.5" too.
Edit: fyi, my 11" pan weights almost 5.5 lbs, so it's still relatively hefty pan. If you really want something lighter I would get the 9.5".
https://www.amazon.com/MINERAL-Round-Country-Carbon-9-5-Inch/dp/B00462QP2K
Everything from Dexter Russell.
I have two spatulas of varying sizes and their dough scraper... Obviously the dough scraper isn't used on the CS, but the spatulas are awesome. I also have a chainmail scrubber, but I don't find the need for it on my CS, just my cast iron. I find a plastic scraper, water, and a paper towel will take off anything stuck to the CS.
These are the De Buyer items im wanting to pass on. Mine are used and have some seasoning on them to varying degrees of course. If your interested they’re yours if you have a shipping label.
De Buyer 5610.26A Mineral B Frying Pan, 10.2 Inch Silver-Grey https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00462QP0W/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_b5HwCbNE2S18S
MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Crepe/Tortilla Pan 9.5-Inch https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00462QP34/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_Z5HwCbRYMCCAJ
Blue steel crepe pan, 9-1/2 Inches https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0019N4ZHQ?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
I have one like this. It uses cylindrical gas canisters. I’m am in Europe and they are very common. Any portable/camping gas stove will do though.
https://www.amazon.com/ShellKingdom-Portable-Outdoor-Emergency-Butane/dp/B01N5FE67P/ref=pd_sbs_0_2/136-5413540-7840144
Sigh, bottom bulges out. Yeah I'm considering getting a De Buyer. I made a thread about it earlier. The only Carbone Plus I saw on amazon is $60 for some reason.
I got it from a restaurant supply store near me.
But amazon has it also:
Chef King 7 Gauge Steel Griddle, 14 Inch x 23 Inch https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001BQYS3C/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_3NeECbJSPBDG3
https://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/B000KENOTK/ref=dp_olp_all_mbc?ie=UTF8&condition=all If you aren't opposed to open box, dented or 'used'. There's a few for around 35 bucks.