Best products from r/tradfri

We found 10 comments on r/tradfri discussing the most recommended products. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 10 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.

1. GE Zigbee Smart Switch In-Wall Lighting Control, Neutral Wire Required, Works Directly with Alexa Plus, Echo Show (2nd Gen), White & Light Almond, 45856GE

    Features:
  • ALEXA COMPATIBLE – The smart switch connects to Echo Plus and Echo Show (2nd gen) without a separate hub for voice control with Alexa. It is also compatible with all other Alexa devices through a certified hub.
  • SUPPORTED HUBS – Works with hubs from SmartThings, Wink, PEQ and Logitech Harmony Home Hub Extender as well as home systems by your favorite cable companies, including Cox, Rogers, Comcast Xfinity and Comporium. It is not compatible with Philips Hue (Zigbee Light Link – ZLL).
  • NEUTRAL WIRE REQUIRED – Features space-saving screw terminal and uses existing wiring to upgrade any single-pole or multi-switch installation equipped with a neutral wire. Max load supports 900W incandescent, 1/2HP motor and 1, 440W (12A) resistive.
  • REMOTE OPERATION – Mobile devices wirelessly schedule and control the ON/OFF function of permanently installed LED, CFL, incandescent and halogen lighting. Energy reporting provides valuable information and automations to reduce electrical costs. The wireless range is up to 150feet. from the controller or closest Zigbee device.
  • INTERCHANGEABLE PADDLES – Includes white and light almond rocker-style paddles to match existing décor (black, brown and ivory sold separately) and features an LED indicator to show switch location. Wall plate is not included.
GE Zigbee Smart Switch In-Wall Lighting Control, Neutral Wire Required, Works Directly with Alexa Plus, Echo Show (2nd Gen), White & Light Almond, 45856GE
▼ Read Reddit mentions

Top comments mentioning products on r/tradfri:

u/theantirobot · 3 pointsr/tradfri

I believe that wouldn't work because those 30 watt drivers output DC power for LEDs, but lamps like you linked are designed to work with AC power. Although the Tradfri bulbs are LED, they are designed to work with AC power and have a small driver built in, where as the panel you linked requires an external driver.

There are a couple ways to approach this:

  • use a tradfri bulb in the lamp you are building
  • use a zigbee switch at the wall, like this one: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B019HTH2A0

    I'm not sure if the Tradfri hub supports that kind of in wall switch, but if you're interested in a project like this you probably ought to consider larger options. Ikea is just one maker of zigbee bulbs and accessories (Tradfri). There is a whole zigbee ecosystem. If Tradfri won't work with the wall switch, you could get a Wink hub that will work with both your Tradfri bulbs and the switch.
u/-Kyrt- · 5 pointsr/tradfri

I too speculate that it could be related to this, but in fact Hue has worked with outlets for a long time - Philips themselves produced an outlet for their LivingWhites range, the Osram Lightify/Smart+ outlets are compatible, and as I mentioned there are other on/off ZigBee 3.0 controllers that work with Hue - including a plug.

I would love to hear from people who have investigated this (e.g. have some insight into how the new ZigBee 3.0 outlets like this are reporting themselves and how that differs from the Tradfri outlet). I will do a bit more research myself, e.g. certification details, and see if these models are supported in deCONZ/zigbee2mqtt - see how they tick.

u/data-chh · 2 pointsr/tradfri

I’ve experienced the same and agree.
Hue bulbs get dimmer, the quality of the light feels better, and the transitions are smoother.
That said, my house has 23 Trådfri shades of white, 3 Trådfri 1000lm warm white and 2 Trådfri colors. However, 14 of those lights are the 400lm with the smaller base (I bought some E26 E27 to E12 Adapters like these to be able to have dim bulbs for our bedrooms.
Having the whole house would’ve costed a whole lot more with hue. Doing it all over again, I’d pick the whole house Trådfri rather than just a few rooms that are hue. It makes all of the difference making scenes with a whole home. However if cost is not an issue, I would probably go with hue, they are a better product.

u/rclonecopymove · 1 pointr/tradfri

Yeelight strip

Lifx strip (still expensive but no hub required)


[More DIY option ](https://www.amazon.com/Nexlux-Wireless-Controlled-Waterproof-Assistant/dp/B072DXFKRH/
)

with the last option you can add extensions easily or right angle connections (if you want to do the back edge of the TV etc.

u/rangerofhobbiton · 3 pointsr/tradfri

Something like this is what I used to stop my mother in law from turning off the switch.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06XP9M2FT

u/forsagar · 1 pointr/tradfri

I also have same problem for my track lights. This is the only option I found for me if you need smart dimmable plug.


Lutron Caseta dimmable plug

There are bunch of manual dimmable plug as well if you are looking for cheap option.

Lutron Dumb dimmable plug