Reddit mentions of Neutrogena Pure & Free Baby Faces Ultra Gentle Cream Broad Spectrum 45+ Sunscreen, 2.5 Fluid Ounce

2 things:

1. Makeup + sunscreen != adequate sun protection. More often than not you'd have to put a METRIC SHIT TON of makeup on to even get most of the protection. So... my advice, you can use it, but don't rebuy, you definitely need a separate sunscreen. And you're just paying more for literally no reason because no one is going to put THAT MUCH makeup on. (However, I do want to see a photo of someone trying. lol)
   
   
2. It sounds like both of your options aren't the greatest, I like the Neutrogena ultra sheer dry touch (I have SPF 45) and Neutrogena pure and free baby sunblock. But your results may vary. The baby stuff is a bit greasy from time to time, but I like it when I'm outside a lot or on the lake/swimming/whatever because it doesn't cause my skin to dry out.
   
   You could also do a search on this sub for sunscreens.
   
   Edit: to answer your question: the Ansolar fluid would probably be the best of your options for what you have available right now, but the oiliness might cause breakouts. Sorry I don't have a better answer, sunscreens are generally hit or miss with a lot of people and it's hard to say what's best.

The one you said you're looking for is a chemical sunscreen.

Edit: This and this are both physical.

I love this stuff.

I have sensitive skin and eyes and it is a rare sunscreen that doesn't make my face and eyes burn, but this one doesn't. It didn't seem to bother my son either. It also has the two active ingredients recommended by the Mayo Clinic for sunscreens: zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.

But, mostly I just try to keep him out of the sun. He has a wide brimmed sunhat and I put him in a loose, white, long-sleeved onesie, if he's going to be in a sunny place. More than anything, I just keep him under a tree or umbrella.

Hi, tortie, you might like this web site, lots of background info/science stuff:

http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/imperfect-protection/

So, you want chemical free (sunscreen chemicals burn my eyes big time) and fragrance free.

https://www.amazon.com/Blue-Lizard-Sunscreen-Sensitive-Fragrance/dp/B0019MT7SY/ref=sr_1_4_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1472837567&sr=1-4&keywords=sunscreen+zinc+fragrance+free

https://www.amazon.com/Neutrogena-Pure-Faces-Sunscreen-Ounce/dp/B0067H6KQ8/ref=sr_1_6_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1472837567&sr=1-6&keywords=sunscreen+zinc+fragrance+free

https://www.amazon.com/Neutrogena-Sensitive-Sunscreen-Lotion-Fluid/dp/B013QNAUOS/ref=sr_1_27_s_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1472837567&sr=1-27&keywords=sunscreen+zinc+fragrance+free

"About the Product

No.1 Dermatologist recommended sun care

Fragrance-Free

Oil-Free"

This one does not bother me, but may bother you:

https://www.amazon.com/Roche-Posay-Anthelios-Ultra-Light-Sunscreen-Sensitive/dp/B004W55086/ref=sr_1_32_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1472837567&sr=1-32&keywords=sunscreen+zinc+fragrance+free

Also, #1 line of defense: good hat, good clothes:

http://www.sunprecautions.com/

If you have tried the above and they are a no go, let me know.

Neutrogena: lots of people with very sensitive skin have very good results with it.