Reddit mentions of ProFoot Orthotic Insoles For Plantar Fasciitis & Heel Pain, Women's 6-10, 1 Pair

I don't actually - I've probably tried 4 different orthotics and have never needed to. The ones I ultimately really liked for my PF only cover the back half of the foot - these ones. That said, are you taking out the insole that came with the shoe? I don't with my half-ones but normally you do have to do that. It depends how the orthotic isn't fitting too; is it not long enough/too long? Or just there's not enough room with your foot and the orthotic? The ankle brace is probably why you'd need to buy a half size up, which makes sense, and yeah you'd probably want to do that with Vans. (Not sure if you're asking about PF specifically but if you are, I did like these for when I was doing something more 'stressful' like running but they won't be as supportive as a brace). In the very least, vans/converse are common enough that you could find a pair at a store to try on, even if you don't like the style and then find a preferred style/color on their website!

Also, I'm sorry your feet have been hurting. My PF took well over a year to heal and it honestly was devastating to my mental health. I never realized how much my mood depends on being able to go outside for a walk/run, or dance around, or basically do anything fun. I hope you heal soon!

Here is a link to the cushy inserts that have turned my life around:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B007S8XYAA/ref=s9_al_bw_g121_i2