Reddit mentions of Feuerhand Hurricane Lantern - German Made Oil Lamp 10" - with Care Pack

Yeah, there's no whoosh like the Northstar, def. If you burn 'em with citronella oil there's a little crackle and they smoke a bit (by design, helps repel bugs) but with clean kero and a properly trimmed wick they're dead quiet.

That large-tank one I linked upthread will last 4 days or more on a single tank, which is about 1/4 of a gallon (2-gallon jugs are about $10). I tend to fill mine up about once a season.

If you want one built like a tank, Feuerhand still makes them much the same as they were 100 years ago, and I guess they're about as much as a new Northstar.

The Dietz are still pretty darn solid, though, and you can get 3 of them for the price of one Feuerhand. Lamplight Farms makes some fairly decent ones for about $20 as well.

Only thing I'd avoid is the flimsy tin ones by Rothco and the like that you see at Walmart and other places. Most people's poor impression of kero lanterns comes from using crappy big-box store ones with cheap wicks.

While you may not consider it strictly relevant to the generator question, I'd suggest that you also look into one of these oil lamps for hurricane prepping, as apparently they're meant to be able to withstand those level winds.

I just figure that if the power goes out at night and you don't have anything else, this might at least give you a small amount of light. If someone got hurt around your home, it might enable you to find and help them.