Reddit mentions of Lioele Auto Eyebrow #3 Gray Black

If you're open to Asian products, Lioele Auto Eyebrow Pencil (#3 Gray Black) is a great cool-toned gray brow product for black brows. I can't speak to whether it's waterproof or not, but it lasts through several hours of volleyball on me! It's usually available on Amazon for around $10.

I really like the Nyx eyebrow cake powder in black/gray. It doesn't have that red undertone that makes the color look unnatural.

As an alternative, this Lioele brow pencil has a very natural color to it too. Plus it comes with a spoolie at the other end.

Dude, using like four different eyebrow products has been a GAME CHANGER and LIFE SAVER for me. :) First I extend the length of my brow tails using this after brushing my brows with the spoolie. Then I fill in and shape the rest of my brows using this. Then I'll fill in any bare spots with this stuff. Finally my last step is securing those beasts with this!!!! I hope this helps. :)

I have dark hair but the same problem you do with it thinning out to nothing past the "nub" section. I use this Lioele Eyebrow pencil every morning. I prefer this one over others because it builds very well which allows you to choose how dark you eyebrows will be. The different eyebrow kits can do the same thing but I have found that eyebrow pencils are much more convenient.

Like others have suggested, I would also check /r/MakeupAddiction for more advice though. That is where I found all of the eyebrow products I tried before I ultimately decided to use my Lioele pencil.

Lioele auto eyebrow pencil in gray #3! You can get one from Amazon if you don't have any Asian beauty stores in your area. Perfect for black hair. The pencil is angled so it's super easy to apply, and it lasts. I've filled in my brows before fencing tournaments and still had them look the same after 4 hours of ridiculous sweating. My only quibble is that the packaging is kind of brittle and you'll probably lose the spoolie cap before you use up the pencil, but I wholeheartedly recommend it anyway.

I actually love the stark contrast of the black brows against my skin, I use black eyeshadow for the most part.

That all said, on days that I'm feeling lazy and don't want to spend time making sure they don't look like sharpie brows, I use this gray pencil: http://www.amazon.com/Lioele-Auto-Eyebrow-Gray-Black/dp/B008J7I8MS/ref=sr_1_1?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1414961452&sr=1-1&keywords=lioele+eyebrow+pencil

It's not too harsh, just very neutral gray, so I just swipe for a bit and then set it with clear eyebrow gel. I think they are an Asian company. The reason I looked into that was because Dark brown/black hair is so common over there. Hope that helps.

Fabulous! Here's my list. I have very, very high expectations for dupes (got screwed over too many times trying to dupe NARS Orgasm), so if something isn't exact I'll say why!

Foundation:

High End - Giorgio Armani Maestro Fusion Makeup

Budget - L'Oreal Magic Nude Liquid Powder The ingredients are in the same order, except the L'Oreal has less irritants!

Finishing Powder:

• HE: Hourglass Ambient Finishing Powder in Dim Light
  
  
• Budget: Pumpkin & Poppy Inner Glow Powder in Celestial
  
  Eyeshadow Palette:
  
  
• HE/ME: Urban Decay Naked Palette
  
  
• Budget: Makeup Academy Undressed Palette
  
  Eye Primer (okay, cheating a bit):
  
  
• HE: Too Faced Shadow Insurance Glitter Glue
  
  
• Budget: ELF Essential Glitter Primer, Darling Girl Glitter Glue, or Fyrinnae Pixie Epoxy (can't link - Fyrinnae somehow blocked my IP address!)
  
  Face Primer:
  
  
• HE: Benefit Porefessional
  
  
• Budget: NYX Pore Filler
  
  Eye Liner:
  
  
• HE/ME: Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner
  
  
• Budget: Clio Waterproof Pen Liner in Kill Black
  
  Brow Product:
  
  
• HE: Anastasia Brow Wiz
  
  
• Budget: Lioele Auto Eyebrow
  
  Blush:
  
  
• HE: NARS Blush in Orgasm
  
  
• Budget: Sleek Blush in Rose Gold Not exact, but the best dupe I've found through my arduous journey
  
  Highlighter:
  
  
• HE/ME: Benefit Watts Up
  
  
• Budget: Sonia Kashuk Chic Luminosity Highlighter Stick in Sparkling Sands (not exact - Sparkling Sands is more yellow. I wouldn't really call them dupes)
  
  
• Other budget: Fyrinnae Highlighter in Confidence (can't link, blocked IP). Colour-wise, they're almost exact, except Benefit has more and bigger sparkles and Fyrinnae has a stronger sheen. '
  
  Contour (skipping bronzer - sorry, don't use them!)
  
  
• HE: Illamasqua Cream Pigment in Hollow
  
  
• Budget: I'm just going to link cool-toned contour products, because I can't find exact dupes. Darling Girl Koalification, Pumpkin & Poppy Oak Bark, NYX Blush in Taupe (maddeningly pink)
  
  MLBB Lipstick:
  
  
• HE: Chanel Rouge Coco in Mademoiselle
  
  
• Budget: Makeup Academy Lipstick in 11 (11 is mysteriously missing...)
  
  Other MLBB Lipstick (found yesterday!)
  
  
• HE: MUFE Artist Rouge Natural N9
  
  
• Budget: Revlon Colorburst Lip Butter in Pink Truffle
  
  Just remembered: Lip balm!
  
  
• HE: Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment
  
  
• Budget: Notoriously Morbid Coffin Kisser The ingredients are not the same, but some things in the Fresh lip balm (beeswax, apricot kernel and jojoba oil) are also in Notoriously Morbid's version. If you're sensitive to coconut oil or shea butter though, look out!
  
  I have a rather extensive list of lipstick dupes, so if anyone's interested I can reveal it :) Happy shopping!

Thanks so much for doing this! I've been hoping to get a new eyebrow pencil recently haha :)