Reddit mentions of Mate: Become the Man Women Want

I guess we wait until other scientist come out in a few days and say the opposite. The issue with this topic is we really don't know the answer. There truly are two tribes; the biological side and the environmental side (and bits in between). Climate change is already well established and believed widely but no one is very sure at all which one is right; biology or society.

 

Scientists are not perfect and often many of them have agendas to push, political, personal or for business interests. Please be aware Quillette have a libertarian bias and would certainly be against gender policies and interventions. They have supported such alt-right talking heads like Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson - people have pretty different opinions on them but the support of them by Quilette shows where their political allegiances lie and their agenda sits.

 

Scientist 1. I mean the first guy doesn't talk about the science at all, he just states his opinion on what happened and what Google have done. He clearly agrees with the author of the document and the agenda he had. Having a scientist agree with your opinion doesn't mean anything.
> not one at all based in bigotry or any other malicious motive.

I'm afraid I have to disagree with that already

 

Scientist 2. The second guy is clearly backing up his own work. Other scientists would argue against his work and findings and also what was written in his comment here.

 

So, so far neither of the scientist have really said... well anything really.

 

Scientist 3. I'm not sure there's much point in delving into this after I found this "self help book" for men wanting to pick up women. It seems like PUA Red Pill nonsense and I'm not interested in delving into that swamp. He even mentions the whole Matrix thing. He tweeting this once: "Dear obese PhD applicants: if you didn't have the willpower to stop eating carbs, you won't have the willpower to do a dissertation #truth" - I mean come on, his agenda is incredibly clear as crystal.

 

Scientist 4. She doesn't really say much except put in her opinion on whether the piece the Google employee wrote was a good call or not.

 

Take a look as some of the criticism of this type of science, evoluntionary biology to see what might be some of the standard types of critiques of this kind of scientific thought.

 

So to be honest... I find this article doesn't really say very much at all. It's certainly not the smack down pieve the alt-right make it out to be.