Phono preamps don't usually have a volume control. They bump the output of the turntable up to line level and correct the equalization, but any volume control is done via the amplifier.

If you look at something like this you'll see it has a specific set gain for MM vs MC cartridges, which can't be changed.

What is your cartridge and stylus? Time for a replacement?

Depending on taxes, the Schitt may cost more buying on Amazon at $149 than directly from Schitt at $129 new or $99 B-stock plus around $11 for shipping.

Other options at or below $200 on Amazon.

• Cambridge Audio Alva Solo
  
• Emotiva Audio XPS-1 Phono Preamp
  
• Music Hall PA1.2 MM/MC Phono Pre Amp
  
  Manufacturer Direct:
  
  
• Bugle3 - Phono Preamp MM/MC
  
  DIY: Muffsy Phono Preamp

I am looking to choose the best budget pre-amp of these 3 (or similar suggestion) for my vinyl setup:

1. Music hall PA 1.2 phono pre-amp
   
2. ART DJPREII Phono Preamplifier
   
3. Fosi Audio P1 Tube Pre-amp
   
   I currently have the Music Hall PA 1.2 (came with the TT) but I'm open to selling it and buying a cheaper, better pre-amp. Not particularly impressed with the power or sound, and the blue light is blinding. Glad it came with the TT and wasn't purchased separately on my own dime.
   
   

   SETUP:
   

   
   TT: Debut Carbon Esprit SB (DC) w/ Ortofon Red
   Receiver: Yamaha RX-V379 (no built in pre-amp)
   Towers: Klipsch RP-280F x2
   Center: Klipsch R-52C
   Surrounds: Klipsch R-14S x2
   Sub: Klipsch R-150 SPL 15"