Reddit mentions: The best diaper liners

We found 76 Reddit comments discussing the best diaper liners. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 30 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.

8. Ubbi Twin Pack Cloth Diaper Pail Liner, Washable and Reusable, Eco-Friendly, Water and Odor Resistant, Drawstring Closure and Door Knob Hanger, 7-Gallon, White

    Features:
  • Washable and reusable
  • PVC free
  • 7 gallon capacity
  • Waterproof
  • Odor resistant
Ubbi Twin Pack Cloth Diaper Pail Liner, Washable and Reusable, Eco-Friendly, Water and Odor Resistant, Drawstring Closure and Door Knob Hanger, 7-Gallon, White
Specs:
Color698904100836
Height27.49999997195 Inches
Length2.49999999745 Inches
Release dateFebruary 2015
SizeAmazonUs/PEKJ9
Weight0.2425084882 Pounds
Width15.99999998368 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

9. Bumkins Diaper Pail Liner, Owls

Heat sealed seamsMachine washableResists odors and stainsReusable for less wasteFits most diaper pails
Bumkins Diaper Pail Liner, Owls
Specs:
ColorOwls
Height1.2 Inches
Length9.5 Inches
Release dateJuly 2014
Weight0.4 Pounds
Width7.9 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

12. Five-Layer Charcoal Bamboo Cloth Diaper Inserts (12-Pack)

Five-Layer Charcoal Bamboo Cloth Diaper Inserts (12-Pack)
Specs:
Height2.9 Inches
Length14.6 Inches
Weight1.65 pounds
Width11.3 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

🎓 Reddit experts on diaper liners

The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where diaper liners are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
Total score: 43
Number of comments: 23
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 11
Number of comments: 3
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 10
Number of comments: 4
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 8
Number of comments: 4
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 8
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 3
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 3
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 1
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1

idea-bulb Interested in what Redditors like? Check out our Shuffle feature

Shuffle: random products popular on Reddit

Top Reddit comments about Diaper Liners:

u/redheaddit · 2 pointsr/organization

Not medical field, but I've worked with needs like this before.

The simple human can has an interior plastic liner that should prevent the plastic bag from sinking. It's not as tedious as it sounds, but when the tag is full you remove the entire liner before removing the bag of dirties, put in the clean bag, pull it taught and shove the rest of the plastic at the top through a little hole and that keeps it from falling until you're ready to remove the bag. Plastic cans won't help with that issue unfortunately.

Reusable wipes are a great idea for your situation. I used the ubbi pul liners in a 6.6 gallon sterilite step can when I cloth diapered my daughter. They say 7 gal, but it's a good tight fit on that step can and it will prevent it from falling into the can. Wash the liner with the cloths each cycle, and having a 2 pack means you always have one clean. You might be able to get away with washing the wipes 1-2x weekly depending on the specific situation, so stock up on wipe cloths based on the projected need between washings.

Ubbi Twin Pack Cloth Diaper Pail Liner, Washable and Reusable, Eco-Friendly, Water and Odor Resistant, Drawstring Closure and Door Knob Hanger, 7-Gallon, White
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00M6B9IQ8/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_x4AEDbW4BFPV9


STERILITE 10949004 Step Can, Black, 6.6 Gallon (fyi that price is currently outrageous, but you can find these at Target, Kmart, dollar general, Walmart, etc)
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00COYBB3K/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_ubBEDb1ZY29DD


I've used these wipes for babies

OsoCozy Flannel Baby Wipes - Reusable And Washable - 15 Pack (Unbleached) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000138GNY/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_.dBEDbJJGMRYP

But I think for a mostly grown man, you could get something thicker like cheap cloth napkins, or kitchen hand towels, or those bundles of washcloths at any big box like this:

Simpli-Magic 79078 Cotton Washcloths (Pack of 24), Size: 12" x 12"
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0794SLW55/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_VqBEDbWCH8GVM

Fyi, buy the wipes in a single color that is NOTHING like your other linens, if you plan on keeping this stuff fully separated and want to ensure there isn't a potential cross contamination or stains on your nicer linens.

You can search for wash routine recommendations basically on any cloth diapering forum these days, but it usually goes something like this:

Only white vinegar in a soak and rinse cycle, then wash with a cloth diaper safe detergent (I've used Charlie's Soap for all our laundry for over 12 years but there are other brands that people swear by so check them out) with an oxygen booster (oxy clean) to disinfect and whiten. Dry as normal.

If you encounter barnyard smells in clean laundry or if he ever develops a fungal infection, bleach it all in hot water and dry it in the sun and you will be good to go. Otherwise, bleaching is overkill and will tear the linens apart in no time.

And last, I hope you recover fully from your surgery. Take care!

u/rlkrn · 5 pointsr/clothdiaps

My father in law laughed in my face & said “I give it 21 days” before you quit.

We are going on to month 14 right now. I seriously wish I had bet him something because I could have totally gotten my kid a college fund or a car or something.

But in all seriousness. Cloth is by far & away my favorite. If you find the right support group (friends are the best/local community, Reddit is a great resource, I’m not a huge fan of fluff love university, tbh it’s kinda catty at times!) it’s even better!

As for diapers, we use mostly Alva pockets & mama koala diapers . They are relatively cheap compared to others & sold on amazon which makes it so much better.

We don’t mind our bumgenius pockets as well as bumgenius freetime all in one diapers, but their price is kinda crazy compared to the others that work just as well. (Also sold on amazon)

I wasn’t a huge fan of AIO because they take a while to dry.

For overnight we do either sustainablebabyish overnight or cloth-ezz workhorse fitted diapers & a cover . Love them both & he doesn’t leak!

As for other things — I love bumpkins wetbags wetbags. They are thick & durable as well as cute. & we use cloth wipes. Any of them work & just water. I’ve also learned you can wash disposables wipes & then when you are assembling diapers you can just pull them out & trash them then (so if you do disposables don’t worry).

Also - best thing I ever did was ease myself into cloth. So we started with disposables until my son was big enough for one size diapers. Then we did cloth only while we were home & during the day. & then we did it all daytime hours. & then we did 24/7/365. But it was a comfort thing to figure out leaks & just diapers, but also how to pack a diaper bag!


Sorry for the long post!

u/disisash · 4 pointsr/clothdiaps
  1. I used these liners and these liners I double them up. Sometimes they go on sale. I have also used the grovia brand, they worked well but were not reliable in stock.
  2. I have not used mama kangaroo, but I have used Alvas, I liked them okay. My kids both out-peed microfiber quickly. I actually use tri-folded burp rags laid into a cover. I have tried other brands and Grovia diapers did not work at all for either of my kids (with the exception of a couple of their older newborn diapers). I think you should get a variety of diapers to try and figure out which ones work best. I like Flip covers and rumparooz
  3. I have only CD one newborn and I used mostly newborn cloth, but I think most of my one size diapers would fit a newborn. It would be a matter of figuring out absorbency, I think. I definitely recommend getting some newborns as you don't really have to figure out sizing and if will make it easier for both you and your husband if you don't have to figure out sizing right from the start.
  4. I can't help with that one :)
  5. I bought a $10-ish 5 gallon trash can from walmart and made my own liners from PUL that I got at Joanns. I was super easy.

    Take your time figuring sizing/absorbency out and don't be afraid of secondhand diapers. I tend to find a lot at those huge consignment sales.
u/ElizabethLTCD · 3 pointsr/clothdiaps

> While that second bullet above notes the fit is good, I'm a little shocked by how soaked the prefold is when I change him. He's soaked each one through to the cover, which isn't soiled but damp. Is this normal?

Yes: it's totally normal especially with Thirsties covers which have a thinner waterproof lining than the other brand I use, Rumparooz.

​

> Can we re-use a cover that's been dampened by urine if we wipe it down and let it dry out?

Yes, but just a head's up--it might stink after a few times of wiping down/drying out :)

​

> We change his diaper just about every 2-3 hours, both day and night. Is this too infrequently for cloth? He doesn't fuss over a wet diaper, but I want to be hygienic. With disposables it didn't seem as bad because of their wicked absorption. As a note, our prefolds were only prepped with 2 washes before being used.

I'd wash a few more times to get to maximum absorption. That being said, it's pretty typical to change cloth diapers every 2-3 hours. I still do with my 18 month old girl. If you're concerned about your baby peeing through, you could add a diaper doubler for extra absorption, which is what we started doing around 6 months with both our daughters.

​

> Even though we've had no leaks, I did have a question about fit: The covers we have have double gussets, and the inner one is tight along his thigh and seems to fit very well. The outside one, however, is looser. Is this normal for a newborn? Will the outer one eventually be tighter, or are we doing something wrong?

This is totally normal and you're not doing anything wrong. The beauty of the inner gussets is that they are supposed to be tighter to contain the poop so you avoid blowouts. For us, the Thirsties' covers worked well until our babies got mobile (around 7-8 months). After that, the gussets were actually not tight enough because the elastics relaxed and the girls were so wiggly that they needed something tighter, and we started getting a lot of blowouts. We upgraded to those Rumparooz covers I mentioned earlier--they have double gussets too--and were happy with the thicker waterproof layer and thicker elastics.

​

Congrats on your baby! If you want to learn more about cloth diapers in general, check out my website: www.learntoclothdiaper.com

Hope it helps!

​

u/UrbanIditaroder · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

We graduated from MF at about the same time. Our favorites are charcoal bamboo like these. They're fluffy (read: a little bulky), but stay soft and are super absorbent.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00MJ8K092/ref=mp_s_a_1_5_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1500302435&sr=8-5&keywords=charcoal+bamboo+inserts&dpPl=1&dpID=61HWPGB-kUL&ref=plSrch

We also like bamboo, slightly less absorbent but less bulky. Very soft too.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00OXTNBIW/ref=mp_s_a_1_4_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1500302555&sr=8-4&keywords=bamboo+inserts&dpPl=1&dpID=41NkXg-z%2BcL&ref=plSrch

We double them for a nap diaper, and had to resort to disposables for overnight at some point. Good luck!!

u/shaffeycakes · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

We use sun baby pockets, but I'm sure they're pretty similar. We use charcoal bamboo inserts that are amazing. Little dude was leaking through the white ones (I don't know what they were.. I bought the diapers/inserts secondhand) constantly and these new ones work like a charm: Naturally Natures Cloth Diaper Inserts 5 Layer - insert - Charcoal Bamboo Reusable Liners with Gussets (Pack of 12) (Grey) liner https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MJ8K092/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_f-49ybYNVEW18

u/JadedorTraded · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

These are the ones I use, and cinching them closed I haven't had smell issues. If you're more interested in the dry bag route, I have 0 expertise, lol. Good luck! I'm sure someone on here has better advice for that route. :)

u/BellaLou324 · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

I love my Charlie Bananas, and these BabyKicks have an hour glass shape that fit perfectly.

I also have some second hand charcoal bamboo inserts that I love, but don't know the brand name. They look like these and I love them because they are absorbent but thick enough that they aren't just bunching up in the diaper, which is a problem I have with every other bamboo insert.

u/BubbaDawgg · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

I put a very thin booster under the flaps which helps a lot.

This was the first that I bought but it’s been unavailable for a long time. Bamboo Booster Doublers

So we tried these gauze doublers and that have worked as well.

Just make sure that you don’t get ones that say inserts as they are extremely bulky. You can also put the doublers on top of the flaps which may help smooth it out a bit.

u/volyund · 3 pointsr/Parenting

Yes, an easy solution is adding an extra 12 oz holding diaper pad into the diaper. Something like this:https://www.amazon.com/NorthShore-Disposable-Diaper-Doubler-Adhesive/dp/B01MDQWJ7Y/ref=sr_1_3_s_it?s=baby-products&ie=UTF8&qid=1519164843&sr=1-3&keywords=diaper%2Bpad%2B12%2Boz&th=1

We had to use if for over a year with our daughter, but it worked great.

u/pinkkeyrn · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

We use dandelion ingeo disposable liners from Amazon. They wick great and have been almost perfect as far as catching poos. They feel like a soft dryer sheet and stay in place.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JG2B4W7/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_X462DbAA0044D

u/delsol10 · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

Kind of a "use your judgement" thing for us. If there's a little smear, we let it go. We also use disposable liners which, more often than not, catch a lot of the poop, and just toss with the wipes. They don't degrade very well despite their labeling and marketing as "flushable"!! So we just toss. But saves us lots of would-have-had-to-rinse-this-nightmare diapers.

Fyc: Dandelion Diapers Biodegradable and Flushable Envionmentally Friendly, Safe, Natural Diaper Liners, 100% Bamboo VISCOSE Fiber, 200 Sheets https://www.amazon.com/dp/B010OPURY4/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_9T3.zbS7G7ZXM

u/nick91884 · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

I got the dekor hands free diaper pail on amazon and the 2 pack of cloth diaper pail liners that fit it and it works great, no smells, similar to the diaper genie we used to use with our first born(we did disposables) but has waterproof (either TPU or PUL, i didn't pay attention)liner has a draw string to close up the bag in transport.

Pail: Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail, White https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00R5BVLXW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_VQ.9ybK16R9YB

And liners: Dekor Cloth Diaper Liners, 2 Count https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00IZULWCC/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_iS.9yb9C4NS8V

We are happy with it and 2 liners is necessary so you have one to use while the other is in the wash with the diapers so I'm glad it came in a 2pack

u/nothertheothergirl · 3 pointsr/Parenting

Others have already recommended the cloth diapering subreddit, but to add my experience we didn't really cloth diaper the first few weeks despite having the supplies on hand just because we were in survival mode and extra laundry was out of the question. Then we moved on to pocket diapers (which have covers and inserts - the inserts absorb the pee) with liners. The liners seemed silly at first but they make life easier without being as expensive and wasteful as a full on disposable diaper. So no, totally not dumb to switch over at this point.

Now we only occasionally cloth diaper on weekends - lately we've either been travelling or dealing with a yeasty diaper rash and I've heard that yeast in a pain to remove from a cloth diaper so disposables it is. Day care requires disposables and I've never had luck with cloth diapers overnight (I probably could if I tinkered with it more, but I'm just not that committed).

I did the math at one point and even assuming we had paid for all the cloth diaper supplies ourselves (which we didn't thanks to our registry) we would have broken even on costs just over my three month maternity leave, so every diaper now that's cloth instead of disposable is like free money, a little bit at a time. A year later and the diapers and inserts we bought are still going strong.

u/hypnochild · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

Did you specifically get the dekor wet bag pail liners? I have these and they fit the pail just fine. They are a bit of a tight fit around but they definitely fit. It comes in a 2 pack so that you always have one even when you’re doing laundry.

https://www.amazon.com/Dekor-Cloth-Diaper-Perfect-Diapers/dp/B00IZULWCC

u/jwhoa83 · 4 pointsr/clothdiaps

Love My® Baby Cloth Diaper 12pcs 4layers Super Water Absorbent Antibacterial Bamboo Inserts https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00OXTNBIW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_vvy6AbKY0XGHE

u/withlovesparrow · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

I've been using a combo of hemp liners from (Amazon topped with some inserts I made myself (3 layers 55% hemp, 45% organic cotton fleece, 1 layer microfiber both bought online). My two year old is a super heavy wetter so we really needed the extra work horse hemp in there, microfiber just doesn't hold enough on its own. But I like how quickly it soaks everything up. Her skin is so sensitive with out it she gets red every diaper change.

u/missmermaid91 · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

I use a flushable liner for poops Flushable Liners they're super cheap and let the pee through to the liner. When she's got anything that isn't caught by this, it gets it off fairly well. I turned up our water pressure a little bit and make sure the water is as hot as it goes!

u/anniemg01 · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

haha. It does make their butt totally puffy. I got my diapers second hand from a mom that had ordered way too many, otherwise I wouldn't have know about the charcoal either. I don't know if these are the exact ones I have, but they look exactly like this: http://www.amazon.com/KerrBear-Kids-5-Layer-Charcoal-Diapers/dp/B00B3VL2J8

u/thatwouldbeawkward · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

For the pocket diapers, we are very satisfied with these as inserts. They seem to work much better than the microfiber that comes with the Alvas.

u/palmettomom2609 · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

This is the exact one I used last year and loved it! Side snaps so it's easier to pull off! I plan on getting more this year!

u/HomeBasedMom · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

All bamboo inserts I’ve found have been 2 thin bamboo layers with microfiber inside. Alva’s liners seem to be the same. They’re safe against baby’s skin but will still act like microfiber.

u/BillieHayez · 3 pointsr/clothdiaps

CBIs are just bamboo outsides with charcoal fibers in them; their major composition is microfiber layers on the inside. Try going with hemp inserts like Thirsties or these: (6 Pack) HappyEndings Heavy Wetter 4 Layer Hemp / Organic Cotton Diaper Inserts https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00H07AHGS/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_Lzn7BbXEP7ZQA. Continue to pair it with your newborn prefold, and that should help a lot.

u/MarthaJeane · 2 pointsr/clothdiaps

Well liners and inserts I use totally different things.

Inserts I use a microfiber on top of a thirsties hemp insert. They’re relatively thin and SO absorbent. For liners I just usethese disposable ones because I haven’t ventured into the land of reusable liners yet. The disposables work well for right now so we’ll see how it goes.

u/AreGophers · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

Charcoal bamboo inserts are decent enough. They're microfiber sandwiched between two layers of bamboo, so they're more absorbent than plain microfiber. And they can be used next to the skin

I personally would go with actual bamboo inserts or padfolded prefolds. That's what we use in our covers and pockets both, and we rarely get leaks.

These seem like a decent option, though I feel like you could probably find them cheaper elsewhere.

10/Pack KaWaii Baby Premium Label 5-Layered Organic Bamboo diaper Inserts| compatible with One Size Diaper 8-36 lbs Washable Reusable|NO Microfiber or Fleece inside| https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B0787QXPV7/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_KOn-BbTTNGGRY

u/chronicpots · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

(6 Pack) HappyEndings Heavy Wetter 4 Layer Hemp / Organic Cotton Diaper Inserts https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00H07AHGS/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_haGDAbZ3DZNRZ these. My little guy leaks with microfiber especially if he wears onesies because of compression leaks. A lot of hemp or bamboo inserts have microfiber cores but these have organic cotton and they hold liquid better, they're trim and really absorbent.

u/hellothisisme825 · 1 pointr/clothdiaps

Yeah! I added it to my Amazon List:

(6 Pack) HappyEndings Heavy Wetter 4 Layer Hemp / Organic Cotton Diaper Inserts https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00H07AHGS/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_wD9QCb4021RWC

u/Cmngirl · 6 pointsr/clothdiaps

You could get some hemp inserts http://amzn.com/B00H07AHGS They are very trim. You put the flat next to the skin and the insert under it.