Reddit mentions: The best dog flying discs
We found 46 Reddit comments discussing the best dog flying discs. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 23 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.
1. Chuckit! Flying Squirrel Spinning Dog Toy, (Orange/Blue), Multicolor, Medium (10 in x 10 in) (0511300)
- FLYING DOG TOY FOR LARGE DOGS: The flying squirrel frisbee spinning toy for dogs is aerodynamic for playing fetch in the yard or park Lightweight and buoyant material is made for poolside and lakes
- RUGGED TOUGH: The flying squirrel is a durable toy for dogs is designed to withstand chewing tossing Curved sides of the flying disk allows pets to easily retrieve toy Frisbee glows in the dark for night time play
- PET TOYS: Get ready for bonding fun with your dogs cats Check out a variety of our pet toy products such as frisbees, perches mirrors for birds, prey wand toys for cats, plush toys, light-up interactive toys more
- CHUCKIT FETCH TOYS: Chuckit creates toys that enrich the human-animal bond bright colors help dogs puppies stay engaged Checkout Chuckit for ball launchers, bouncy balls, frisbees, indoor dog toys, glow toys more
- JUST FOR PETS: Petmate makes a variety of pet products for dogs, cats, chickens other small furry friends Check out our brands such as Aspen Pet, Arm Hammer, Booda, Chuckit, Jackson Galaxy more
Features:
Specs:
Color | Multi |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 10 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | January 2007 |
Size | Medium (10 in x 10 in) |
Weight | 0.04 Pounds |
Width | 10 Inches |
2. Chuckit Paraflight Flyer Dog Toy Large
- 10 INCH FRISBEE: Ideal frisbee for dogs for high-flying games of fetch, designed for long-distance flight The Paraflight fetch toy floats in water - great for playing at the pool, beach or lake
- DURABLE DESIGN: This large dog frisbee features a multilayer nylon interior with soft rubber edges that's gentle on puppy's gums and teeth. Frisbee gradually descends for jumping and catching mid flight
- PET TOYS: Get ready for bonding fun with your dogs and cats. Check out a variety of our pet toy products such as frisbees, perches mirrors for birds, prey wand toys for cats, plush toys, light-up interactive dog toys and more
- CHUCKIT FETCH TOYS: Chuckit creates toys that enrich the human-animal bond. Bright colors help dogs and puppies stay engaged. Checkout Chuckit for ball launchers, bouncy balls, frisbees, indoor dog toys, glow toys, and so much more
- JUST FOR PETS: Petmate makes a variety of pet products for dogs, cats, chickens other small furry friends Check out our brands such as Aspen Pet, Arm Hammer, Booda, Chuckit, JW, and more
Features:
Specs:
Color | Blue/Orange |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 10 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Large |
Weight | 0.0002866009406 Pounds |
Width | 10 Inches |
3. Petmate Zipflight Dog Toy, Small
- GLOW IN THE DARK FRISBEE: Engage with dogs after dark with this aerodynamic flying disc for dogs that's designed for long-distance flight. The lightweight, buoyant design floats on water for beach & poolside play
- Make Fetch Happen: Made of a durable, multi-layer of dense polyester canvas, this lightweight fetch toy's bright colors provide increased visibility and its aerodynamic shape is perfect for long-distance games of fetch
- Go Fetch: Chuckit Performance toys are designed with you and your dog in mind; Try our full range of interactive indoor and outdoor dog toys including tumblers, flyers, fetch toys, chew toys and more
- Chuckit Fetch Toys: Chuckit makes toys that enrich the human animal bond and helps dogs and puppies stay engaged; Try our full line of ball launchers, bouncy balls, frisbees, indoor dog toys, glow toys and more
- Just For Pets: Petmate makes a variety of pet products for dogs, cats, birds, and other furry friends; Check out our brands such as Aspen Pet, Arm & Hammer, Booda, Chuckit, and more
Features:
Specs:
Color | Assorted |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 7 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Small |
Weight | 0.1102 Pounds |
Width | 7 Inches |
4. COLLAR Puller Standard Two Rings not just Toy for Dogs Active Toy for Dogs Fitness Toys for Dogs Ideal for Medium and Large Breeds Dog
- Puller is more than just a toy for dogs. This is a fitness tool! Puller necessarily consists of 2 rings this greatly increases the intensity of the workout
- It's light; which allows the owner to train a dog for a long time it's easy to work with even for children and women
- Unique material it does not damage dog's teeth and gums
- It floats; which opens up additional opportunities in training and interacting with the dog
- It is odorless; which is very important when training dogs puller does not leave an odor on the hands unlike most of the products for dogs
- Ideal for: Labrador, Retriever, Pit Bull, Belgian Shepherds Malinua, American Staffordshire Terrier, Doberman Pinscher etc
Features:
Specs:
Color | Purple |
Height | 11.023622036 Inches |
Length | 11.023622036 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 28 cm/11 in |
Weight | 1.1 Pounds |
Width | 1.574803148 Inches |
5. Hyper Pet Flippy Flopper Dog Frisbee Interactive Dog Toys [Flying Disc Dog Fetch Toy – Floats in Water & Safe on Teeth] (Colors Will Vary), Multicolor, 9"
ALL-SEASON INTERACTIVE DOG TOYS: Designed for a high-flying game of fetch with your dog in the water, grass, or snow. This dog frisbee is the perfect solution for fitness, exercise, and trainingDURABLE DESIGN AND SAFE ON TEETH: This frisbee for dogs features a durable, multilayer nylon construction ...
Specs:
Color | Multicolor |
Height | 0.85 Inches |
Length | 9 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 9" |
Weight | 0.18 Pounds |
Width | 9 Inches |
6. KONG - Extreme Flyer - Durable Rubber, Soft Flying Disc for Power Chewers, Black - Large Dogs
Durable KONG Extreme Rubber makes for a softer, softer catch during fetchSupport healthy exercise and instinct to playMade in the USA. Globally Sourced Materials.Available in one size: L
Specs:
Color | Black |
Height | 1.38 Inches |
Length | 12.2 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Large |
Weight | 0.42 Pounds |
Width | 4.72 Inches |
7. Floppy Disc "USA", Soft Flying Disc Toy for Dogs, 7 inch
Now Proudly Made in USAMakes hard plastic discs obsoleteSafe and gentle for your dog's teeth and gums, great for smaller dogsDurable fabric and rubber tubing makes a toy that flies great and floats tooDesigned as a toss and fetch toy not intended for use as a chew toy
Specs:
Color | Pink/Green |
Height | 0.5 Inches |
Length | 7 Inches |
Size | 7-Inch |
Weight | 0.1 Pounds |
Width | 7 Inches |
8. Xvolt Floppy Disc USA, Soft Flying Disc Toy for Dogs, 10 inch
【Adjustable Sensitivity】5 training levels are prepared for your dogs, and the anti-bark collar is easy to use without harm. You can choose the most appropriate sensitivity based on the actual condition of your dogs. Finally, you can control your dogs without any tools!【Automatic Self-protectiv...
Specs:
Color | Pink/Green |
Height | 0.8 Inches |
Length | 10 Inches |
Size | 10-Inch |
Weight | 0.219 Pounds |
Width | 10 Inches |
9. Nerf Dog Nylon Flyer Dog Toy, Frisbee, Lightweight, Durable and Water Resistant, Great for Beach and Pool, 9 inch diameter, for Medium/Large Breeds, Single Unit, Red
NERF-TOUGH: Nerf-quality materials make our Nylon Dog Toy perfect for fetch and for teaching your dog new tricksHIGH VISIBILITY: The bright red nylon flyer is easily trackable for both you and your pet, no matter where or how far you toss itMADE TO LAST: Lightweight, durable, and weather & water res...
Specs:
Color | Red |
Height | 11.76 Inches |
Length | 1.5 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 9 in Nylon Flyer |
Weight | 0.13 Pounds |
Width | 9.3 Inches |
10. Hoop La Hoop - Lge
Hoop shaped dog toy for throwing.Ideal for a game with your dog.S: 5.9in, M: 8.3in.
Specs:
Color | pink,yellow, green |
Height | 8.267716527 Inches |
Length | 8.267716527 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | tal-lt |
Weight | 0.99 Kilograms |
Width | 0.393700787 Inches |
11. Starmark 11" Easy Glider Durafoam Disc (Colors May Vary)
- Made from an extremely durable patented material that is safe on your dogs teeth and gums.
- Easy to throw straight and level
- even if you are inexperienced.
- Also floats in water for catching fun at the pool
- lake or beach.
- 11 inch diameter.
Features:
Specs:
Height | 0.3 Inches |
Length | 13.4 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Weight | 0.55 Pounds |
Width | 10.5 Inches |
12. Petzip Soft Frisbee Pet Fetch Toy, Blue/Orange/Red/Green
Soft edge will not hurt pet's mouth and teethBright colors, visible in all outdoor environment (grass, snow, dirt, etc.)Easy to clean, wipe it with damp cloth or spot cleanWell balanced to fly distanceMade of durable fabricListed price is for one item only with random color.
Specs:
Color | Blue/Orange/Red/Green |
Height | 1.5 Inches |
Length | 10 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 10 x 10 x 1.5 inches |
Weight | 0.5 Pounds |
Width | 10 Inches |
13. Hyper Pet Flippy Flopper Dog Frisbee Interactive Dog Toys [Flying Disc Dog Fetch Toy - Floats in Water & Safe on Teeth] (Pack of 2, Colors Will Vary)
ALL-SEASON INTERACTIVE DOG TOYS: Designed for a high-flying game of fetch with your dog in the water, grass, or snow. This dog frisbee is the perfect solution for fitness, exercise, and trainingDURABLE DESIGN AND SAFE ON TEETH: This frisbee for dogs features a durable, multilayer nylon construction ...
Specs:
Color | Multi |
Height | 0.99999999898 Inches |
Length | 9.9999999898 Inches |
Number of items | 2 |
Size | 2 PACK |
Weight | 0.45 Pounds |
Width | 9.9999999898 Inches |
14. RUFFWEAR - Hover Craft Flying Disc for Dogs, Red Currant, Large
HIGH-PERFORMANCE FLYING DISC: The Hover Craft high-performance flying disc is ideal for fetching sessions on both water and land. It’s a great way to enjoy fun and interactive outdoor play with your dog.MOLDED FOAM CORE: The Hover Craft's molded foam core makes for excellent flight performance an...
Specs:
Color | Red Currant |
Height | 1.37 Inches |
Length | 9 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Large |
Weight | 0.15 Pounds |
Width | 9 Inches |
15. Aerobie 28C12 Dogobie Disc Outdoor Flying Disc for Dogs - Colors May Vary,Multi
MADE FOR DOGS: The Aerobie Dogobie Disc is a flying disc designed specifically with dogs in mindAERODYNAMIC: Dogobie's design is easy to grip, throw accurately, and catchDURABLE: Disc is puncture and tear resistant to ensure long-lasting useENCOURAGES ACTIVE PLAY: Great for bonding with your pet and...
Specs:
Color | Multi |
Height | 0.75 Inches |
Length | 8 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | January 2017 |
Size | basic |
Weight | 0.09 Pounds |
Width | 8 Inches |
16. Starmark Easy Glide DuraFoam Flying Disc Dog Toy, Color Varies 11"
- Quality and performance driven products for your pet
- Tested for safety and health
- Provide a better quality of living for your pet with Starmark
Features:
Specs:
Color | Assorted |
Height | 15 Inches |
Length | 11 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 11 in |
Weight | 0.55 Pounds |
Width | 2 Inches |
17. HurriK9 Flying Ring Launcher for Dogs (Starter Pack - Launcher + 3 Extra Tough Spandex Rings)
- STRONGER RINGS: tough rings are wrapped in spandex to make them 3x stronger than the standard rings. With the added weight these fly up to an average of 45-65 ft. versus 100 ft. for the standard rings. Contains Launcher and 3 Extra-Tough Rings.
- DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CLASSIC & EXTRA TOUGH RINGS: We offer 2 types of rings. Both are made with lightweight durable EVA foam; the Classic Rings fly up to 100+ Feet, and the Extra Tough Rings fly up to 65+ Feet; Extra Tough Rings are professionally sewed with a durable spandex fabric made to be over 3x as tough.
- SUPER DURABLE AND SAFE NON-TOXIC MATERIALS: We use safe non-toxic material that has been tested per Children & Dog toys requirements at a 3rd party laboratory. Ball launcher is designed to be less tough on your shoulder.
- CONTAINS 1 LAUNCHER + 3 EXTRA TOUGH SPANDEX RINGS: Exercise your dog quickly, maximize flight distance, enjoy your dogs fetching skills with this easy to use dog fetcher toy!
- WE STAND BY OUR PRODUCT: From testing the product on hundreds of dogs already, we've seen that around 95% of dogs quickly learn to love the HurriK9 rings. If your dog ends up in the 5% of dogs that simply doesn't want to chase the rings, just contact us within 7 days of receiving the product, and we'll send you a prepaid return label and give you a full refund.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Starter Pack (3 Extra Tough Rings) |
Height | 7.8 Inches |
Length | 26.5 Inches |
Size | Extra Tough Pack (Launcher & 3 Spandex Rings) |
Width | 7.8 Inches |
18. Petface Toyz Crinkle Dumbell Dog Toy, 20 cm, Blue
Great to throw for your dog and design can make it easier for them to pick upMade from a blend of durable and non-toxic synthetic materialProvided with a variety of textures to stimulate their sensesRubber crinkle dumbbell tug and chase dog toyGreat for fun games on land and in the water
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 0.393700787 Inches |
Length | 0.393700787 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | October 2017 |
Size | 20cm |
Weight | 0.220462262 Pounds |
Width | 0.393700787 Inches |
19. Hyper Pet Flying Duck Slingshot Dog Toy
Slingshot Dog Toy: Thumb released, high flying, bungee style slingshot dog toy that launches up to 10 feet.Floats: Floats in the water, so it's great for the beach, lake, or pool.Interactive Play: Intended for interactive and fetch play, not a chew toy.Material: Made of lightweight, durable ballisti...
Specs:
Color | Green |
Height | 11 Inches |
Length | 16 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Large |
Weight | 0.36 Pounds |
Width | 2.5 Inches |
20. Hartz Mountain 00767 TuffStuff Flyer Dog Toy
- Assorted colors
Features:
Specs:
Color | blue, green, orange, red |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 9.5 Inches |
Weight | 0.3 Pounds |
Width | 9.5 Inches |
🎓 Reddit experts on dog flying discs
The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where dog flying discs are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
I agree on balls and frisbees. I'm a huge fan of the brand ChuckIt. Especially the balls like these. They seem to hold up very well. They have a lot of give like a tennis ball which my dog loves. But they're pretty much solid rubber so they're not going to crack and break like tennis balls. But still have a lot of bounce and are relatively soft. I like the same brand for frisbees too. They're soft (but still have actual structure to them so they fly) so I don't have to worry about wear and tear on my dog's teeth. And they float so they're good for the beach/lake/river/pool. The frisbees aren't as tough as the balls and a determined dog can wreck one pretty quickly. Like within a few hours. But they hold up very well to normal frisbee use. And you're better off getting them online than at Petsmart. They're usually around $18 there and under $10 online.
Jolly Balls are fun too. The ones with the handles seem to lose the handle pretty quick. And the ones with the rope will have the rope pulled out. But the ones with the rope don't have a gaping hole in one side once the rope comes out and the ball itself doesn't fall apart unless a dog is actively trying to wreck it. I have one that I bought 6 months ago that's still in good shape.
Hi there,
My Lab/GSD mix used to act out similar to your dog. She'd be high energy, chew her bed while in her crate, and suffer from separation anxiety. I would try to take her on walks and jogs to burn off some of her energy, but it never seemed like it was enough (or frankly, I would get tired of running before she did). In hindsight, what I should have focused on was more quality exercise time than quantity.
Our routine now is to go to the park after work for about half an hour and have an intense session of fetch. We started off with just a ball, but she would occasionally lose interest in playing with it. So after some practice and training, we switched to this frisbee and she absolutely loves it. Because of how into fetch she is, we're also able to incorporate training into the session, with tossing the frisbee as the reward. After a good 30 minutes of sprinting around, when we come home she pretty much just goes straight to her bed and sleeps for the rest of the night.
In the end, she's happy with the level of exercise she gets and I'm happy with her being calm at home.
I also live in a townhouse too - no yard. My puppy was like this too. He still is sometimes but he's loads better. Things I've done:
I take him out often. We go on three walks a day, at least two of which involve a lot of grass. My hope was the more time he spent on grass, the less exciting it would be.
When we're on the grass I also work on attention exercises. Every time he looks at me, I give him a treat. I don't ask him to look at me, I just reward him when he chooses to. After only a week or two of this he started looking at me A LOT more.
If I see him going for a patch of grass that I know he'll rip up, I say "leave it". This kind of works because my puppy is naturally drawn to clumps anyway.
I also wanted to play fetch outside. My problem was he'd chase the ball, but then not pick it up. (Though in the house he picks it up and brings it back fine.) I found a different toy that I keep for special outdoor fetch sessions. I got this: https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/B00F90J638/ref=ya_aw_od_pi?ie=UTF8&psc=1# my puppy loooves it. I only play with it outside though in order to keep it special.
We use the Chuckit! Large Paraflight. They are kinda expensive, but the best ones we've found. Most of Chuckit! brand that we have tried has been great.
They are pretty stiff when you get them, but get a little softer after the dog chews them a bit. I'd say one lasts a good three or four months of regular use (carries it everywhere, loves to chase it). They will float, although she really doesn't like to swim, so hers only ever ends up in the water by accident. Definitely recommend!
My ACD goes absolutely nuts for the chuckit frisbees. She likes plastic ones but they are so sharp. Hates rubber ones because they fly too fast and she can't catch them as easily. Loves loves loves the chuckit ones, they fly well and are pretty durable.
Chuckit Paraflight Flyer Dog Toy Large https://www.amazon.com/dp/B008ESY894/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_hp1ODb8AH756C
Glad you might start disc dogging! We've been active in the sport for about a decade, and if your dog can get the hang of it, it's tons of fun.
Here's a floppy, non-scary, easy to throw and catch disc you could start with (we used this when our dogs were puppies):
https://www.amazon.com/Floppy-Disc-Soft-Flying-Dogs/dp/B00DFABI8A
You can then progress to something specifically for dogs that's competition-grade but fairly light and easy to catch, like this:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0022V73DW/ref=psdc_166432011_t2_B001HL7J9G
Roll it on its edge away from him so he chases it down. Roll it farther and farther so he loves to grab it from behind. Gradually work up to throwing a very low floater (you might have to crouch a bit) that he can catch without jumping, then extend the distance. Then work on making flat, longer throws that are about waist-high; practice having your dog start next to you or behind you so he has to run to catch up and catch it.
A couple of tips...High jumping can be really dangerous until the dog learns how to land on all fours, so practice throwing consistently flat and waist-high. (I swear for every hour we practice with a dog, we practice two hours alone just getting better at our disc handling!) Also, keep the discs away from him except when you play together; discs should be special and not just randomly lying around.
Good luck!
This is by far Louis' favorite frisbee. It's not indestructible, but it's held up very well for us. He only started getting more serious about Frisbee in the last 6 months, but I've used it for trick training so this thing has been knocked around and used frequently. It's also not too difficult to pick up from the ground.
On the other hand, I've found the Nylon frisbees to be the best for teaching the dog to catch a frisbee in the air. It took a little transition to go from nylon to the chuck it frisbee and then we'll transition to regular frisbees, but the nylon ones definitely helped build Louis' air grab confidence.
Oh this is hard.
http://www.amazon.com/Chuckit-Small-Zipflight-Colors-Vary/dp/B004XO828Q/ref=wl_it_dp_o_pC_S_nC?ie=UTF8&colid=1X2VKQHLODCNW&coliid=I3CB56KE9TQB90
This screams summer because me and my best bud Rex love going out on a warm summer day for a good game of frisbee :) He needs a new one though since his is all chewed up and ruined! It is his favorite thing we do together I think! BINGO! Thank you for the contest :)
ChuckIt! Ultra Balls. I've met just one dog that preferred regular tennis balls to Ultra Balls. These Ultra Balls are ridiculously durable. They're not indestructible, but they last a long time even with heavy chewers. Also, they bounce really high and are easy to clean.
ChuckIt! Flying Squirrel. A good frisbee, a great tug toy, very durable. The feet will fall off and the frame will come out long before the fabric rips.
The Kong Black Flyer is hands down my favorite (and my dogs' favorite) frisbee. It takes a little getting used to because it's so floppy, but it flies great and it's incredibly durable. I also like Kong's Puppy Flyer as it's similar but not as bulky and cumbersome as their red one. ChuckIt makes some great frisbees too, as does West Paw
It depends on the dog- one of my corgis loves fetch and tug toys, so a soft frisbee keeps him happy. My other corgi loves to chew and gnaw, and her favorite is this rubber star ball.
They also both love antlers to chew on.
Ahh, a picky puppy! I recommend trying out these treats: fish4dogs cubes, canned hotdogs (the stinkiest kind you can find) and tuna packed in water not oil. Those fish cubes have never failed to work for me, but a good idea is to try out really abhorrently smelly foods.
You could also work on developing toy drive, although I've heard that this is sometimes difficult in sensitive herding breeds who are more likely to want to give you the toy than battle for it. Small/medium sized hooplahoops are flexible and great for puppy tug, and you can practice a) working him up with just how amazing this toy is, and b) trading one hoop for another by throwing the first one and then introducing a 'drop' cue when you throw the second one sort of like this.
I have this one that I like a lot. The only issue I have with it is that my dog likes to play tug-of-war with it and the fabric in the middle gets a bit stretched out of shape. I also have one that's a round rubber donut that has fabric stretched in the middle (attached at three points around the disc so some of the rubber is exposed. Bailey likes to play tug with that one and it holds up better. I cannot seem to find it online for the life of me.
I have found these foam frisbee's are easier on my BC's little mouth and it floats no matter what... perfect for water fetch! Plus for me, they're easier to throw. Her durafoam frisbee has teeth marks all over but it's lasted us 2 years and looks like it'll stick around much longer than that. She loves it!
https://www.amazon.com/Starmark-Easy-Glider-Durafoam-COLORS/dp/B007TW9HRO
I trained "catch it" with a cloth type frisbee that does ok in some wind and can be tossed a fair distance without turning over
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00CIC3WYE/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I would say "catch it" and move the frisbee to my pup's face, lightly tapping her nose until she grabbed it like a tug toy. "Good catch!" Then progressed to a very short toss right at her (inches), then working up to a foot. Then short tosses away when she got the meaning of "catch it". After a week or two of this process it was throwing the frisbee like normal. I usually do a quick reminder "catch it?" and tap her nose with it (but she'll grab it). Then toss it. Shouldn't take too long if the dog is predisposed to fetch already.
She's having fun! She would be great a frisbee. Get her a floppy disc frisbee like this:
Hyper Pet Flippy Flopper Soft Dog Frisbee Interactive Dog Toy, Colors May Vary https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00486UC4G/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_ofv7BbKJFBJXP
I mean, having owned a border collie, I rember distinctly having to secretly trash his soft frisbee every 3 months because it was torn up from playing. He didn't destroy them purposefully, he just loved them to death.
I also remember that he could smell new ones, he found and unwrapped his year's supply every Xmas morning. I miss that dog.
For anyone who's interested, these were the ones he loved
Edit: These were actually his favourite, the others were good though!
I agree with everyone on the Nylabone. I made this spring pole (you can find instructions on the same site) for my pit and she loves it. Also this frisbee has survived quite a while in her grasp.
If he doesn't have a million and one dog toys yet, something like this can be great to get outside and play with the pup!
Heartbreaking. I was not able to find anything, OP. Have you tried getting her a fabric disk? Here's one that's small enough for Bailey: https://www.amazon.com/Floppy-Disc-Soft-Flying-Dogs/dp/B00GM3PB1C
Another similar: https://www.petco.com/shop/en/petcostore/product/chuckit%21-paraflight-dog-toy?rrec=true
I feel bad that Bailey was so attached to her toy. They're just like we are. They associate favorite objects with good times, family, comfort and security. Maybe take her to Petco and let her choose her own new toy to make some new memories with?
Amazon sells cloth ones with a rubber internal ring from Hyper Pet. They're amazing.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07NPXLZXD
Chuckit! Large Paraflight https://www.amazon.com/dp/B008ESY894/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_JEcIAb5FVF77E
Here ya go, friendo! Enjoy many hours of flinging it around. We go through at least one every 2 months!
Are you using an ultimate-style frisbee? Dogs can hurt their teeth on those if they're going fast, so he may have a bit of a fear reaction. Maybe try with a soft frisbee like this one?
After that, the short distance/increasing distance thing is a good way to start. You can also throw the frisbee near someone else who picks it up if it lands on the ground, thus only rewarding if your pup catches the frisbee.
Also looks like ruffwear makes a red frisbee:https://smile.amazon.com/Ruffwear-Hover-Distance-Flying-Currant/dp/B00B23QL5M/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1493735640&sr=8-1&keywords=ruffwear+frisbee
http://www.amazon.com/Aerobie-Dogobie-Disc-Color-Vary/dp/B0000ASDD1
my dog will play with this for HOURS
I can't be the only one who wanted to see the toy in action!
Found it on Amazon, and there's a video demonstration of it in flight.
She might well destroy these too, but my dog loves these rings: https://www.amazon.com/COLLAR-Puller-Standard-Active-Fitness/dp/B00F90J638/ref=asc_df_B00F90J638/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=218543830990&hvpos=1o1&hvnetw=g&hvrand=8660270350075837787&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9022185&hvtargid=pla-319929860581&psc=1
I've been using them to teach him hold/fetch, because they're about the only things he'll actually sink his teeth into and not just chomp at. He also hasn't managed to destroy them yet!
We have a 1 1/2 year old female husky. She chews soft toys up in a heartbeat, especially if they have stuffing (we will find little pieces of stuffing everywhere). The toys that she has not been able to destroy are:
-pretty much anything by KONG that is only made of the plastic/rubber
-ORCA toys, which are also a harder rubber (our dog loves this one: http://www.amazon.com/Petstages-ORKA-Jack-Chew-Toy/dp/B0009YJ3QO)
-Believe it or not, she LOVES this foam frisbee and we have had it for over a year with little to no damage (aside from a few teeth marks). It will not tear: http://www.amazon.com/StarMark-Easy-Glider-TCEGMM-Colors/dp/B000FMFM2E
She also loves rawhides, which she can chew through faster than some other dogs, but it still takes her some time.
Here's the toy :)
https://www.amazon.com/HurriK9-Flying-Launcher-Starter-Spandex/dp/B01HHJJETE/ref=sr_1_1?s=pet-supplies&ie=UTF8&qid=1499787986&sr=1-1&keywords=ring+launcher
We use a Hertz tuff stuff frisbee for our 1 yr old. It flies pretty well and it lasts longer than a week. It's reasonably priced at Walmart (under $10 in Canada). We try to mix it up with hard Frisbees, the soft ones, rope toys and the ball and chuck it. I worry about his teeth too :(
http://www.amazon.com/Hartz-Mountain-00767-TuffStuff-Flyer/dp/B002Q0UJI0