(Part 2) Reddit mentions: The best men cologne

We found 106 Reddit comments discussing the best men cologne. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 73 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the products ranked 21-40. You can also go back to the previous section.

22. Herban Cowboy Cologne, Dusk, 1.7 Fluid Ounce

    Features:
  • Product Type:Beauty
  • Item Package Dimension:5.207 cm L X9.398 cm W X20.599 cm H X
  • Item Package Weight:0.204 kg
  • Country Of Origin: United States
Herban Cowboy Cologne, Dusk, 1.7 Fluid Ounce
Specs:
Height0.91 Inches
Length1.22 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateMay 2015
Size1.7 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Weight0.02 Pounds
Width1.22 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

23. Victoria's Secret Very Sexy for Him 2 Cologne Spray, 3.4 Ounce

    Features:
  • 100% AUTHENTIC
Victoria's Secret Very Sexy for Him 2 Cologne Spray, 3.4 Ounce
Specs:
ColorCologne Spray
Height6 Inches
Length2 Inches
Number of items1
Size3.4 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Weight0.3 Pounds
Width4 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

26. Outlaw Fire in the Hole Campfire Solid Cologne - Explosively Awesome Cologne - 1 oz - Smells like Campfire, Gunpowder, Sagebrush, Whiskey, and a Weekend Camping - Men’s or Women’s Cologne

    Features:
  • WHAT DOES IT SMELL LIKE? Smells of campfire, gunpowder, sagebrush, whiskey, and more.
  • WHAT IS SOLID COLOGNE AND WHO CAN WEAR IT? It’s a pocket-perfect round tin of pressed cologne that you can carry with you wherever you go. It’s not overpoweringly strong, but easy to re-apply if you need a little boost. They're designed to create an ambiance, not an impact. We believe that both men and women can smell like badassery, so this scent transcends gender.
  • HOW CAN I USE THIS SOLID COLOGNE? Rub it directly on your pulse points (yeah, go ahead and rub the tin right on there!) - or - swirl your finger around on the surface until it’s nice and warmed, and then apply.
  • WHAT ARE THEY LIKE? They come in a little tin with a twist-top, and the little tin comes in a very fine (and reusable, I might add) match-style slider box. It’s made with natural ingredients like cocoa butter and beeswax. It’s hard to the touch, but melts when you warm it a little bit.
  • IS THIS GOOD FOR ME? IS IT GOOD FOR THE PLANET? Outlaw products are made with integrity. This means recycled and/or recyclable packaging, Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free, natural and sustainable production practices, and Whole Foods approved ingredients (so you know it’s good!). We guarantee our products. If it’s not what you had hoped it would be, just get in touch with us and we’ll make it right.
Outlaw Fire in the Hole Campfire Solid Cologne - Explosively Awesome Cologne - 1 oz - Smells like Campfire, Gunpowder, Sagebrush, Whiskey, and a Weekend Camping - Men’s or Women’s Cologne
Specs:
Number of items1
Size1 Ounce (Pack of 1)
Weight0.0625 Pounds
▼ Read Reddit mentions

27. 4711 Acqua Colonia Lime & Nutmeg Eau De Cologne Spray, 5.7 Ounce

    Features:
  • A citrus aromatic fragrance for men and women
  • Crisp, spicy, sweet-acidic, warm and uplifting
  • Contains notes of lime and nutmeg
4711 Acqua Colonia Lime & Nutmeg Eau De Cologne Spray, 5.7 Ounce
Specs:
ColorGreen
Height7 Inches
Length2.8 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateNovember 2017
Size5.7 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Weight0.6 Pounds
Width1.7 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

28. Maurer & Wirtz Acqua Colonia Melissa & Verbena Eau de Cologne for Men, 5.7 Ounce

    Features:
  • Long lasting aromatic fragrance
  • Good quality product
  • Made in Germany
Maurer & Wirtz Acqua Colonia Melissa & Verbena Eau de Cologne for Men, 5.7 Ounce
Specs:
Height5.75 Inches
Length2.5 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateFebruary 2017
Weight0.35 Pounds
Width2.25 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

29. Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit De L'homme Frozen Cologne Spray, 3.3 Ounce

    Features:
  • This product is made of high quality material
  • It is recommended for romantic wear
  • This Product Is Manufactured In France
Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit De L'homme Frozen Cologne Spray, 3.3 Ounce
Specs:
Height4.3 Inches
Length2.7 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateJuly 2015
Size3.3 Ounce
Weight0.220462262 Pounds
Width2.5 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

32. Nenuco Cologne/ Agua De Colonia

Delicate enough for childrenFreshly scented splash colognePopular with all ages
Nenuco Cologne/ Agua De Colonia
Specs:
Height6.0236220411 Inches
Length4.330708657 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateDecember 2017
Size20.2 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Weight0.220462262 Pounds
Width6.4960629855 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

34. Murray & Lanman Florida Water, 16 Fluid Ounce

Not tested on animals.Florida Water.
Murray & Lanman Florida Water, 16 Fluid Ounce
Specs:
Height8.89 Inches
Length2.59 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateJanuary 2019
Size16 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Width2.2 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

36. Happy By Clinique For Men. Cologne Spray 1.7 Oz.

    Features:
  • Item Package Length: 10.16cm
  • Item Package Width: 14.732cm
  • Item Package Height: 5.588cm
  • Item Package Weight: 0.5 lb
Happy By Clinique For Men. Cologne Spray 1.7 Oz.
Specs:
ColorAnti-flash White
Height6 Inches
Length2 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateNovember 2005
Size1.7oz.
Weight1 Pounds
Width2 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

39. Taylor of Old Bond Street Mr. Taylor's Cologne, 3.38-Ounce

    Features:
  • Mr. Taylor's Cologne is a masculine fragrance combined with an astringent.
  • English Classic
  • Size 100 ml
  • Made in England
Taylor of Old Bond Street Mr. Taylor's Cologne, 3.38-Ounce
Specs:
ColorMr Taylor
Height1 Inches
Length1 Inches
Number of items1
Release dateAugust 2021
Size3.38 Ounce
Weight0.220462262 Pounds
Width1 Inches
▼ Read Reddit mentions

🎓 Reddit experts on men cologne

The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where men cologne are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
Total score: 19
Number of comments: 6
Relevant subreddits: 3
Total score: 14
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 4
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 2
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 2
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 1
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1
Total score: 1
Number of comments: 1
Relevant subreddits: 1

idea-bulb Interested in what Redditors like? Check out our Shuffle feature

Shuffle: random products popular on Reddit

Top Reddit comments about Men's Cologne:

u/DKowalsky2 · 3 pointsr/Wetshaving

That does make sense - my inclination is to say that the salve won't inhibit the scent from Cool, but the scent of the soap itself is light and would probably only give you whiffs for an hour or two at most, and stick very close to the skin. I might be the wrong person to ask, as 95% of my shaves with Reserve Cool would also use the matching Reserve Cool aftershave splash and Eau de Cologne.

Keeping in mind that the vibe of Cool is "Italian Barbershop" and it's inspired by the old Floid Blue I believe, the listed notes are lemon, bergamot, and lavender. You could seek out a fragrance with similar notes to finish off the shave if you wanted to project the scent a little more. Some well known options you may be able to find in your area are Acqua di Parma Colonia (though this may be a bit more expensive) or 4711.

Edit: Adding links to the Czech Amazon pages for 4711 and Acqua di Parma Colonia. As you can see, there's quite the price difference.

u/ITGuy420 · 1 pointr/AskMen

I wear this stuff when I go out with people. I've received some good compliments from women. I sometimes wear American Eagle cologne as well. Good luck!

u/[deleted] · 1 pointr/AskReddit

I am a girl and my male friend once told me he gets THE best smelling cologne. I told him I hate cologne and didn't believe him. One day I was in his room and caught the smell of it and it is literally the best smelling cologne I have ever experienced. I seriously recommend it. Don't be fooled by the fact that it's Jack Skellington on the container. I'm serious.

u/bikerwalla · 0 pointsr/wicked_edge

You're going to want an alum block to rub over your wet face right after the shave. It tightens your pores, disinfects, and controls any bleeding if you have cut yourself or scraped your skin. If you want one purpose-made for shaving, you can get the one by RazoRock, but you should save a few bucks and instead use a Crystal Body Deodorant; it's chemically identical and comes in a plastic applicator that is easier to hold.

After rinsing off the alum, I would use a toner splash, like Thayers witch hazel and lavender or Ogalalla bay rum, followed by a balm, like Nivea Aftershave for Sensitive Skin.

u/Sundancelancer · 34 pointsr/traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns

Alternativly:

Fire in the Hole Campfire Solid Cologne - Explosively Awesome Cologne - 1 oz - Smells like campfire, gunpowder, sagebrush, whiskey, and basically a great weekend camping - Men’s or Women’s Cologne https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01LK9253O/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_8r3XBb9YDSKEN

u/JustinJSrisuk · 1 pointr/malefashionadvice

It's can be easily found on Amazon, actually. They have the original-scent version of the cologne as well as lotions, body sprays and deodorant.

Muelhens 4711 also produce several a variety of other refreshing colognes in their Acqua Colonia line, like the Pink Pepper & Grapefruit, the Melissa & Verbena, the Blood Orange & Basil, the Lemon & Ginger, the Lime & Nutmeg, the Mandarin & Cardamon, and the Lavender & Thyme. I actually prefer these scents to the original 4711 cologne as they're less-bracing or medicinal and more fresh and crisp.

u/just_a_rock · 3 pointsr/malegrooming

2 cologne's that I've used for about 2 years now that are amazing are: This one which is more for evenings and nights and This one for mornings and afternoons. Most women love the scents of both of these colognes, and remember that the scent is to be found not displayed.

u/dna42zz9 · 4 pointsr/frugalmalefashion

I bought this one on Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/FragranceBodyOilz-Impression-Tobacco-Hypoallergenic-Affordable/dp/B079JGRF5Y/

To be fair, I haven’t smelled the original, but I like the way it smells (definitely like both tobacco and vanilla), and the scent seems to stay on for a while.

u/jhmadden · 1 pointr/shaveoftheday

Razor: Parker SRW with Shark Blades

Brush: Frank Shaving Badger Brush

Cream: Taylor of Old Bond Street: Eton College

Aftershave: Old Spice Classic

First ever straight razor shave! Damn was I nervous... played some classical music to ease my mind. It turned out really well I think, only a couple nicks that weren't bad at all and very little irritation that subsided in an hour.

Incredibly close shave like nothing I've had before. The cream dried halfway through so I had to reapply it, I'm not sure if I was doing something wrong or just took too long.

Will definitely be making this routine maybe a couple times a week due to how long it takes. I'll stick with my electric shaver most mornings because I really wouldn't want to do this while rushing to class :)

u/Triggercat2 · 2 pointsr/SkincareAddiction

This is one I use sometimes in the summer - https://www.primor.eu/natural-honey/37029-colonia-frescor-de-colonia-.html?search_query=Revlon+colonia&results=471

You can also get johnsons and Nenuco (nenuco is the most popular here I think) - https://www.amazon.com/Nenuco-Cologne-Agua-De-Colonia/dp/B004XGQ1PU

Ingredients of these things aren’t great - alcohol & fragrance, but they’re quite nice and refreshing in the summer when it’s hot.

u/TrueChelu · 2 pointsr/vegan

I've been using Herban Cowboy Dusk and I really enjoy it. I'm able to buy it from Natural Grocers but it's also on amazon


Herban Cowboy Natural Grooming Cologne - Dusk 1.7 fl oz Liquid https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B00KC6RTW4/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_2b65BbBFADCV4

u/CuppaSouchong · 0 pointsr/AskUK

I don't know how well known it is in the UK, but here in the States the only after shave I have been able to tolerate is [Florida Water] (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Murray-Lanman-Florida-Water-16/dp/B0055DT4YU). It has an extremely light scent, but still gives you that needed after shave tingle and tightening.
Don't be put off by the name or having a reputation as a "holy water", this stuff really is a good deal and manly as well.

u/pseudoesque · 1 pointr/malefashionadvice

I like Alvarez Gomez during the summer. It is super citrusy and light. Also, it is very inexpensive.

u/ShinyTile · 1 pointr/malefashionadvice

I'm just putting this out there:

http://www.amazon.com/Happy-Clinique-Men-Cologne-Spray/dp/B000277N7Y

Terrible longevity, and mixed reviews, but I love it.

u/notoneofyourfans · 1 pointr/fleshlight

Back when I actually cared about what my Fleshlight sleeves smelled like, I would use a heavily scented powder to powder them. Might work for you also.

u/ripster55 · 1 pointr/AskMen

My hand smells like a combination of sweat from bicycling from the farmers market and Whole Foods Tester spray of Dusk Cologne from Herban Cowbow.

Can't make this shit up. Excuse the dinosaur photobombing the pic. I live in a weird neighborhood.

u/Goose88 · 2 pointsr/AskMen

Mr. Taylor's Cologne from Taylor's of Old Bond Street

It's original, classy, and rare.

u/SL8Rfan · 1 pointr/FixedGearBicycle

This stuff works well.