Reddit mentions: The best bike panniers & rack trunks

Huge reply inbound!
Kit:
These MWave panniers are fine. I put a large dry bag inside it and it worked great. Frustratingly these only come in left (there is slight shape to help add heel clearance), but you could absolutely have them on both sides without a problem. MWave also makes a double pannier but it doesn't fasten very securely and this is a large problem. I am sure you could probably figure something out, though. Just make sure it isn't too hard to remove them.

I had the cheap Nashbar front panniers which are okay and I would recommend for a not multi-continent trip. The thing though is that they really were unnecessary. Even if you take a fair bit more stuff than you need you should still be able to fit it all in your rear panniers and your cargo rack. If you really insist on taking a ridiculous amount of equipment then take front panniers, but don't take a ridiculous amount of equipment to begin with.

If (like me) you have a cheap sleeping bag and roll mat, these things will be very, very bulky. You will be envious of the people with the $200 roll mats and $700 down sleeping bags. Those things really are nice. They probably store both of those things in a third of a pannier. If you were to store your bulky equivalents in a pannier it would take up the whole thing, so don't do that. I got a large dry bag (get a heavy duty one, like for kayaking) that my sleeping bag and roll mat would fit in. Also get a dry bag for your tent and store that also on your cargo rack. I kept my rain kit in a small dry bag also with these two on my cargo rack, and everything else was in my panniers. Fastening these three dry bags sideways (perpendicular) to my cargo rack with bungees worked very well. I started out without the dry bag for my sleeping bag or tent and brought along a tarp to put over them in case it rained as you can see here which was a terrible idea. Definitely just take dry bags.

Also, a huge plus side of your ridiculously big dry bag with your sleeping bag and roll mat inside-that garners significant sneering from all the equipment snobs-is that it makes for a fantastic camp seat. So neener.
I will highly advise that you spend some money on a couple merino wool shirts and ideally socks as well. And ideally a light hoodie or jacket or something. Basically, you can never have enough merino. The Clymb has amazing deals very often. Merino is a luxury, but it'll make a very large difference. And then you'll find yourself wearing it all the time when you get home, too, and wondering why you own any clothes that aren't merino. (I'm trying to answer this question myself.)

My tent is actually a 6x4 children's tent. I fit all my six foot three of me in it diagonally. It weighs about three pounds, which is rather spectacularly light for a cheap tent- I'd have to spent quite a bit more to get a 'real' tent that weighed so little. In the US, Academy Sports seems to have exceptionally cheap tents that are adequate quality. Just make sure it either has a rain fly or you have a tarp or some means of keeping dry.

Fear of getting lost:
When I started my trip I was terrified of this, and was enormously glad to be going along with a well toured friend. My fear was completely unfounded. Like /u/DannyPinn said, just go, and you'll quickly get very comfortable with it.

If you're in a not remote place than you have lots of people and tools to be able to figure it out. If you are in a remote place than there's probably only one route to go anyway, and the people will be way more willing to help you and give you their time. Also, if you're using Warm Showers (why wouldn't you??) then you'll be getting the best advice possible for free from your kind hosts. Well, I would bring them a bottle of wine or something, but for nearly free anyway.

And the thing that should make you the most comfortable is that people love touring cyclists. We are the opposite of hitch hikers in that regard- people want to spend time with us, have us stay the night at theirs just so they can figure out why the hell we're doing this, and generally are enormously enamored with the idea and think we're crazy. People will help you if you let them. A lot. I could not and still cannot comprehend the amount of generosity I received. This incomprehensible never ending string of intense kindness from strangers that I experienced last Summer was one of the most perspective and life changing experiences I have had in my life. People will take care of you. Don't worry, be happy. =)


Edit:
Forgot to mention some things.
Rain gear: If you anticipate that you will be in rain you absolutely need overshoes. Everyone I have met has disliked their overshoes and found them not very functional. I have these ones and they are absolutely fantastic. They don't let any water in at all.

I bought super cheap rain pants and a jacket. The advantage of the ones that don't even try to be breathable is that they truly are water proof, but cycling in them is hell. If you try to compromise and get cheap, breathable waterproofs you will find that they are neither very breathable or very waterproof. If you are doing a Summer tour in a dry place these are probably fine. If you anticipate downpours than you need to decide if you want to be miserably moist and hot inside impermeable waterproofs or if you want to fork out the hundreds of dollars for Gore Tex. Whatever you choose, never buy a waterproof that also is a jacket. Always buy liners. If you need extra warmth wear an extra jacket. Jackets that are both waterproof liners and thermal insulation are silly and destroy the layering principle. I see these in outdoors stores a lot, but I never see outdoors people wearing them. I guess urban guppies buy them or something, because I've never seen anyone actually using one.

Pedals/shoes:
I started out my tour completely sold on clipless pedals. I had been using them for several years, and I still love them for road cycling. I will not be taking them on another tour, however. At the pace that you will be cycling most of the time they will not give you any benefit, and the disadvantage of needing another pair of shoes is actually a very high cost for touring cyclists. Shoes are bulky.

In my opinion water resistant approach shoes with large flat pedals is the best choice. However, if I were doing a summertime tour through Baja California or something like that I would probably just take some Chucks(read: whatever shoes you're comfortable walking around all day in).

I'm going to point you towards bike and seat combo options that allow for carrying some cargo since you seem to want to go car-light(er) around town. If cargo isn't something you care much about you can basically pick any non-carbon fiber bike that has decent rear braze-ons for mounting a quality rack as most bike seats mount this way. So moving on to recommendations...

• Any touring bike (randonneur, touring, adventure touring, or even commuter bike) that has braze-ons for both front and rear racks. Surly LHT, Soma Saga, Kona Sutra (holy hell those got expensive), Trek 520, Schwinn LeTour (the old ones) all come to mind. Bought new those are all going to push your budget but used will keep you under with a bit to spare to get it sorted by a LBS.
  
  
• SomaYuba Boda Boda - This is a compact cargo bike with an integrated rear rack. It is shorter than traditional long cargo bikes like the Surly Big Dummy so it's easier to manage both on the street and in storage, putting it on the bus, etc. You can mount a child seat directly to the rack for your toddler but as he/she gets older and more mature they can just sit directly on the rear deck (there are accessory handlebars you can add so they can hold on). This is my dream bike right now. Can carry up to 2 kids on the back as well as cargo. Under $1,000, but you'll have to buy a seat and maybe a couple other accessories.
  
  If you know that cycling is something that will always be important to you and you are serious about reducing your car usage I'd strongly encourage you to find a way to up your budget to around $1,700 including accessories and buy one of the touring bikes I listed above. It could possibly be the last bike you ever buy, and reduced driving will help recoup that extra cost over time. Here's an example price list of what I would buy if I were you:
  
  
• Surly LHT complete bike - $1,275 link
  
  
• Tubus Tara front rack - $120 link
  
  
• Axiom Monsoon Aero front panniers - $98 link
  
  
• Yepp Maxi seatpost-mount child seat - $210 link. using the seatpost mount means you don't need to spend extra money on a quality rear rack (don't go cheap on that - it needs to hold the weight of the seat).
  
  A child's seat is going to cost you around $200 (+/- $100) no matter what so that's a sunk cost. Front rack and pannier are such a small price for the value that you get; tubus is one of the best racks so you can save money in this area or omit completely if you don't want to carry cargo. Note however that it will be tough to fit rear panniers AND a rear child seat because of clearance issues which is why having a front rack helps a ton on this type of setup.
  
  The biggest place to save money is the bike itself. you should be able to find a used but well-sorted newish touring bike for $900 or less depending on your market. But if you buy new from a reputable LBS they will do a proper fit for you and get you on the right size frame with a comfortable setup that will let you ride all day without issue - you can't get this buying used and it's definitely worth the money if you don't already have a very good idea what size frame you best fit (i.e. seat tube length, effective top tube length, reach, handlebar height, etc.).
  
  Good luck!
  
  

I use the DXP for my groceries every week, and have for years. The biggest issue is that when putting stuff into the panniers, you may have to take stuff out of the shopping bags and let them be loose in the panniers to get optimal fill. I'm not sure if I've put 20 pounds in each bag, but I've definitely carried 20+ between the bags. I've carried two twelve-packs in each pannier several times, and the weight was a non-issue.

But I also wanted to be able to carry more groceries, so I ordered those exact bags from Bike Bling. Sadly, they sold out and but were super-friendly and gave me a free upgrade to the Soma Fillmores, which are practically identical. They work great with reusable grocery bags for carrying stuff, and with my Tourist rack, I can use my trunkbag AND two grocery panniers! The main compartment of the DXP is insulated, so I try to put my cold stuff in there, and it's never been an issue. However, you will need one of the Tourist racks that has the second set of rails for panniers to use at the same time as any of the Topeak trunkbags, so be aware of that.

I also have the TrolleyTote that /u/tepidviolet recommended. It definitely holds more than the main compartment of the DXP, but it puts the weight up higher, so the bike feels wobbly if you're getting 20+ pounds of stuff. I love it, but I'm not sure I'd recommend it for your solution. But the nice part about Topeak's MTX system is you can swap all the different parts out! I even have an old Office Bag that I can put on if needed, but I think it's discontinued.

So, if you want my recommendation to get the best bang for your buck: start with one of the various Topeak Super Tourist racks for your bike and get the MTX Trunkbag DXP. I use this bag daily for commute, groceries, errands, etc. It holds a good amount of stuff, and you can pack up/unload the pannier sides as needed. With the Super Tourist rack, you'll have the ability to add on or swap panniers as needed while keeping your DXP, to increase or specialize your load.

For what use? Commuting? Touring? All weather?

For commuting, I think roll-top panniers are best, like these or these. They don't have any pockets, but you don't often need to get into your bags on a short commute, and they're more waterproof than other designs which IMO more than makes up for it. It's better to occasionally need to fuss with your gear (or keep your flat kit in a pocket) than to have to mess with an extra rain shield whenever the weather is bad.

For touring, a roll-top style is essential for the front rack. You need something that can be cinched down tightly into a single mass, rather than something that is going to flop around a little. I have this cheapo set that I bought just to try them out, and my bike is nearly unrideable with them mounted on the front. Movement doesn't matter that much in the rear, though, so if the main aim is touring, I'd go for a more functional set (though something nicer than the ones I posted which are entirely non-waterproof) with pockets and such for the rear like the Iberia ones you posted. You want the ability to get at food, tools, etc. without having to unpack your load every time. How waterproof they are is a secondary concern, as you can always pack the gear in the main pocket in a garbage bag.

I'd be really hesitant to buy that Timbuk2 bag (both of those links go to the same place) without seeing what the rain cover on it looks like or knowing how well it works. For the same price, you could get a good quality pair of roll tops.

I don't have any specific recommendations, but there are a couple of things you ought to look out for. See the mounting mechanism on these. It's a nice idea, but it doesn't work very well. The release mechanism is difficult to operate while wearing gloves, and it doesn't hold the bag to the rack as securely as it should. I have an older, discontinued set of those that have been great in terms of how well they've held up (~5000 miles of daily, all-weather commuting), but I've lost one hitting a massive pothole in traffic more than half a dozen times. Check out the mounting mech on the Timbuk2, or this on from REI (those blue tabs rotate over the rack and physically lock the bag in place).

Basically, figure out what your primary concern is: waterproof, or easy access to pockets. If it's the former, look for a good set of roll tops. In the case of the latter, look for something solid with flaps that completely cover the openings. Next, look at how it mounts, and look for something that locks to the rack yet is easy to manipulate (particularly with gloves). Finally, look at price. Some of the brand name bags are ridiculously expensive, but the cheapos like I posted above aren't worthwhile for anything other than very occasional use.

If it's an 11 mile one way commute, then you'll probably want a road bike. The Raleigh Merit will be well suited for your needs but I would recommend adding or swapping the following:

1. More puncture resistant tires. You can also get Mr. Tuffy tire liners, but those will not have side wall protection.
   
   
2. A good ULock and possibly some locking skewers to secure your wheels and seatpost. I interned right outside of Denver in 2015 and 2016 and regularly bike commuted. Even in the suburbs, bike wheels were regularly stolen if not secured.
   
   
3. A rear rack and a set of panniers. Carrying stuff, including a change of clothes, with only a backpack gets old and sweaty. Plus the whole grocery thing if you're not going to bring a car.
   
   You may wish to check out /r/bikecommuting for additional information. If this will be your first bike, you will also need to get the following items:
   
   
4. A helmet.
   
   
5. Front and rear lights.
   
   
6. Bicycle chain lube and degreaser (automotive works fine) to clean the chain.
   
   
7. A bike specific multitool and tire levers.
   
   
8. An air pump.
   
   If this seems like a lot, don't worry. You can get a really cheap and good pump from Walmart. Just make sure it has a presta valve hole. They also sell helmets which are required to meet the same safety standards as all other helmets sold in the US, as well as chain lube and auto degreaser. Amazon has good deals on the other stuff, especially lights.
   
   Finally, I find this frame mounted cell phone holder extremely valuable. The reason being, that I have a horrible sense of direction and this enables me to view Google Maps biking directions while riding to various places without having to take my phone out. Plus I can easily listen to music while riding.

Lots of good answers here, so I'll just give some extra advice. I highly recommend getting a good bike lock. It'll save your bike and give you peace of mind when you leave it for long periods of time. I personally use an ABUS Granit XPlus. I also recommend getting a rear rack and bag. PakRak makes a really good combo (sold separately).

>tell me your experience and why you started doing it

I didn't want to pay for a car, insurance, gas and upkeep. Now I do it because I've developed such a passion for it. The place I bought the bike from offers free maintenance for life, so that was a good bonus incentive.

Was inspired by this post to show my own reflective gear!

I tried to keep the logos visible so you could see what it all is but:

• Super Engineering Grade Reflective Tape
  
  
• Light Reflective Bike Bar Tape
  
  
• Timbuk2 Maze Classic Messenger Bag
  
  
• Sugoi Zap Versa (it’s a convertible jacket/vest and I think they discontinued it so I can’t find a link, sorry!)
  
  
• BV Bike Bag Bicycle Panniers (these aren’t The Best nor the most reflective but they work fine for a casual commuter like me)
  
  
• Not shown in this picture but a super fun addition: Serum No. 5 ‘Flashing Lights’ Reflective Nail Polish

For people using rear panniers, I'd definitely recommend they look at the Topeak Super Tourist rack - it has the same mounting system as the Explorer model, plus it has an extra set of side bars so (1) you can easily use panniers and a trunk bag at the same time, and (2) the panniers are mounted lower and further back on the bike, which improves stability and helps avoid heelstrike. I've used the Topeak Super Tourist rack with my Ortlieb panniers for daily commutes and long-distance touring and it's worked great.

I'm also a big fan of the Topeak trunk bags - the Quick-Track mounting system used by the Topeak racks and bags is super-easy to use and very secure.

My Helmet
I also wear it to mountain bike, but its nice and light and breathes well; also it has an awesome price.

Panniers which are way better than having to wear a backpack when you ride around.

There are links on the side as well that have reccomendations.

Had a Planet Bike Ecorack on my last ride, it worked well but I was always worried about the tube diameter. I just put an Axiom Fatliner on the new ride and it's stout AF. I love it. Yesterday I loaded up probably 40-50 pounds of groceries in my Venzo pannier on the Axiom rack and it didn't flex at all.

You didn't ask yet, but panniers over baskets, and specifically the Venzo panniers off of Amazon, they're less than half the price of the fashionable ones and do the job just as well. Milk crates and wire baskets are cheaper, and fine if you're just tossing in a backpack or something, but a good set of panniers are waterproof, better at holding loose cargo, and get the weight low for better stability.

Ask 10 cyclists for pannier recommendations, and you'll get 11!

Still, to make sure I'm doing my part, I really love my Roswheel 3 in 1 panniers. It's way more space than what it sounds like you need (it's more than I need too), but gives you plenty of room to toss in a repair kit, a spare jacket/rain gear in case the weather turns on you, heck I even stash my spare/alternate biking gear in there (like the old pair of fingerless gloves I never wear anymore), and when I take them off I toss my lights in too.

This thing gives you pretty close to the best capacity for the price I've seen. Plus, the top bag quickly detaches; I pop it off and carry it with me to the bathroom so I can change into/out of my work clothes.

That bike should work fine, assuming it's all running well. Do you plan to camp or stay in motel/air bnbs? Also are you planning to make and haul your own food? Or just buy as you go? If youre buying all your food and sleeping indoors and you wanna go really light weight you could just get a rack and strap a duffle bag to it with everything you need. If you have camping and/or cooking gear your best option would just be a couple panniers and some sort of bag on top. If money is a factor something like this should work decently well (just don't expect it to last forever). After that all you really need is some basic tools (pump, multitool, tire levers, etc), a way to carry water, spare tubes/patch kit and camping/cooking gear if that's what you're doing. Beyond that most things are comfort and preference.

I own this. It's fine, the seat was terrible and the wheels arrived out of true, but other than that it's a perfectly reasonable bike. That Cannondale looks sweet though, and it's already got the rack and lights. Get some panniers and maybe some fenders and you're good to go.

Yeah I'm gonna give it some time. I like the look of this one, and the way the back of it is shaped makes it easy to pick it up to swing the rear end around when locking up. I'm also thinking I may want to get a front rack. Hopefully something large and sturdy enough to carry something like a case of bottled water.


edit: I think I found the perfect front rack/basket: http://www.amazon.com/Wald-Front-Delivery-Bicycle-Basket/dp/B0012DQAM6/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1426292215&sr=8-1&keywords=Wald+giant+basket

I commuted on a 1994 Stumpjumper for the past few years at school. I used cheaper Kenda 1.95 road tires that are still good after I bought them summer 2011. I also put a rear rack that carried either m-wave panniers for grocery shopping, or a trunk for small stuff.

Lights are a big thing. You can get them cheaply, I've been using a planet bike set for a while. The tail light is either solid or flashing and is very bright, but the headlight leaves something to be desired.

Good luck!

I have a Blackburn EX-1 on one bike so I can use the Blackburn bicycle seat:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005ZIQMCC/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I have a Topeak SuperTourist on my commuter, it's heavy but I like being able to fit my Topeak top bag with a couple of panniers when needed. I think the BadBoy 2 has mount points just above the axle.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000ZKHN6Y/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I used a little clamp thing to attach the two front straps to the seatpost, worked fine. They don't really hold any weight, just stability. Something like this or this.

This has been one of the racks I have used. The best part of them is that they are quick release so you don't need to have any holes in your frame in order to mount it. It is compatible with just about every frame and trunk bag.

Also I found that a trunk bag makes the bike unstable when you are awaiting at a light or getting started. A better choice for me has been these bags. They are deep enough to hold three changes of clothes a computer and 2 pairs of shoes. They comes with rain protectors that will keep the bags and their contents dry and clean.

​

Ibera Bicycle Bag

Quick Release Rack

​

The combination of the two should make the ride that you have easier. Not to mention that the bags have an a ajustability that will allow them to fit any rack that you might have..

​

Well, I use my standard entry level road bike for pretty much everything. It's a 2015 Felt F95 Sora which has been treating me really well. I have around 7,000 Km on it.




For touring, especially for carrying stuff, I wanted something sturdy and cheap so I went with this rack and this easy clip-in bag. The bag is really great as it can easily come off the rack and double as a shoulder carry bag. There's another small saddle bag (Standard) for tools and spares. Additionally, I had 10L cycling backpack (Not in the picture). If you have any other questions, ask away.

Edit: Grammar

I got these for commuting to work and for weekend shopping trips. They're great.


Ibera Bicycle Bag PakRak Clip-On Quick-Release All Weather Bike Panniers (Pair), Includes Rain Cover https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_yqrhDb1K7HQ6D

They can fit a lot and hold weight. They're easy to detach from my small front rack as well. They have rain covers that are light and easy to throw on

I like my Roswheel panniers. They seem well made, have a big thin "document" pocket along the back of inside the main bags and small rear pocket on each side which is nice. Plus they're easy enough to get on and off the bike.

Here's a picture of them on my bike in france....I think they look nice and go well with my colour scheme.

Funny, I just asked myself the same question today, with a very similar use-case (leaving the bike lights in a locked container on the bike while running).

I was thinking of a small hard-case that would have a metal ring or something so that I could put my U-lock through it. That way it wouldn't need to be locked to the bike when the bike isn't locked.

Haven't looked too hard yet, but lockable hard cases for racks definitely exist. I don't know how they are secured to the rack itself, but you could always take a cable lock to secure the box to the bike.

Some I came across on a quick search:

• Pletscher EasyFix Hard Case
  
• M-Wave Amsterdam
  
• Rixen & Kaul KlickFix Bike Box for Racktime
  
  Edit: OK, not really road bike containers, sorry for misreading your question. I leave the comment here anyway.
  
  Edit 2: This thing from PacSafe might work... found via relevant thread on Stackexchange.

Thank you very much for this information! Is there any under-the-seat bag that you would recommend? I will definitely pick up the items that you recommended. They all seem to be important once you get a few miles away from home.

EDIT: And what about one of the racks like this that only connect to the seat, instead of multiple points on the frame?

It looks like there are eyelets for rack mounts so any rack like this should work https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002T5H8MW/ref=s9_top_hd_bw_bEHOX_g468_i2?pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=merchandised-search-3&pf_rd_r=ZWM7T83HJTAQ5WKKA7WP&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=4fa95ac1-9313-504c-a40b-72e9b9823f04&pf_rd_i=3403461

Panniers are can be a bit more 'sized'. Are your boots high tops? I'm thinking something like this https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ET9W146/ref=abs_brd_tag_dp?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER

Full disclosure I have a Blackburn rear rack and some large drawstring top Jaand panniers I found used.

I use this: https://www.amazon.com/Blackburn-EX-1-Disc-Bicycle-Black/dp/B005ZIQMCC/

Note below under "Frequently Bought Together" you'll see a seatpost clamp that also has two mount points for your rack. It works great. No complaints.

Edit: Bah! my brain read rack instead of fender. Yeah, p-clamps are what you need. Don't try to clamp your fenders under your quick release. It seems hella sketchy to me. I'm leaving this, because racks are great and the above setup turns a braze-on-less road bike into a great commuter.

Oh man, besides the pedals I'm not sure these are upgrades as much as they are 'add-ons' but hey I'm done working so I'll pretend by being on Reddit:

Got this light from my LBS with my bike, love that it was bright as shit and rechargeable...I emailed the company about some the band and different sizes since we have the interrupter lever, they were awesome and sent me some to try out

This tail Light because it was also rechargeable and crazy bright...people behind me have rolled up and asked what kind of light it is...me likey

These panniers because the good reviews, minimal looks, and the waterproof aspect..I use these guys along with a random rack from REI everyday....love it..I also got this backpack thingymajig that makes the pannier a backpack

Got these pedals because they allowed me to rock normal shoes when I'm not wearing these, I like that I can tool around with just normal shoes on without worrying about foot placement.

And riding through town with the oblivious drivers/tourists around downtown I'm picking this horn, we'll see how it goes..and maybe a gopro......

If you want a set that's decent, but not top-notch, I've been pretty happy with these.

Not waterproof, but then again, where I live we average 20 inches of precipitation when we aren't in an historic drought.

Thank you! And sure, here ya go 🙃

Back seat post rack with bag = Ibera PakRak Bicycle Seat... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002YSN5W6?ref=yo_pop_ma_swf

Top frame bag (front) = https://www.revelatedesigns.com/index.cfm/store.catalog/cockpit/Magtank

Top frame bag (back) = https://www.revelatedesigns.com/index.cfm/store.catalog/cockpit/Jerrycan

Feedbag on handlebars = https://www.revelatedesigns.com/index.cfm/store.catalog/cockpit/MountainFeedbag

Front rack = https://www.rei.com/product/117429/salsa-exp-series-anything-cradle-dry-bag-and-straps

Dry bag/ compression sacks = https://www.rei.com/product/730882/sea-to-summit-event-compression-dry-sack

Cheers!🍻

Here are some links for the product in the above comment for different countries:

Amazon Smile Link: this


|Country|Link|Charity Links|
|:-----------|:------------|:------------|
|USA|smile.amazon.com|EFF|




To help add charity links, please have a look at this thread.

This bot is currently in testing so let me know what you think by voting (or commenting). The thread for feature requests can be found here.

Not to hijack the thread or anything, but I was curious (since you sound like a seasoned veteran) - what waterproof panniers do you recommend, how much are they, and where did you get them?

I bought these, but they say nothing of being waterproof, and I'm assuming with our weather they won't hold up come Fall...

added https://www.amazon.com/Roswheel-Water-Resistant-Bicycle-Carrier-Pannier/dp/B01FFBQVBK/ref=sr_1_190?keywords=bike+bags&qid=1567658178&s=gateway&sr=8-190

to the bike.... good enough temp solution and frankly other than the color would probably be perfect.

what should you know about saddle bags? Buy a topeak MTX quicktrack rack and the expandable EXP bag This system is too amazing to describe. Small bag for short trips, unfolds into full pannier setup. Securely fastening it to your bike in under 10 seconds is a dream compared to conventional veclro/bungee systems. Both of these together will be over your $80 budget for your helmet/lock/bag but it's well worth it. I'll never use another bag/rack again. The rack is also lighter than the cheaper rack I was using before.

Thanks for your feedback, I decided to buy this rack, because of the quick release system of the bag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLv8108LQN0

Also this bag has great user reviews in the US Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/Ibera-PakRak-Bicycle-Quick-Release-Commuter/dp/B002T5MZ70/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1413082486&sr=8-3&keywords=Ibera+PakRak+Clip-On

In addition to the Ortlieb rollers, I have a pair of Ibera PakRak Panniers that were $80.

Personally I like the Iberas better than the Ortliebs, mainly because I think the roll top on the Ortliebs is a pain in the ass.

I just did a tour up the PA Grand Canyon with the Iberas, and the first night there was a torrential downpour, and heavy rain all the second day. I just put the rain covers on them, and they stayed completely dry. On the 3rd day, it was off and on light rain, and I didn't put the covers on. Again, stayed dry inside. I kept my rain jacket stuffed under the top flap to put on when I needed.

I like the flip up top, makes it very easy to put stuff you might need on top and just flip open to get to it. They're also very well made.

Ibera also makes waterproof roll top panniers like the Ortliebs, but a little less expensive

I commute with the Ibera trunk bag and seat post mount. I've been happy with it. The rack comes off in 15 seconds for weekend rides and the pack fits my lunch, change of clothes, and repair kit easily. The bottom is big enough for my large Tupperware containers to sit flat, which is nice when I'm bringing a double serving of chili for lunch.

r/bikecommuting

I love commuting by bike, my rear rack and my previous pannier were about $60. The rear rack has the added benefit of my wife being able to ride seated on the back (with a cushion for comfort).

I just got this pannier and it has a pretty great capacity, if you had 2 you could haul a lot of groceries.

>https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ

Sounds like this bag may be a better fit. It has a separate shoe compartment, Fidlock magnetic clips, a carabiner hook and padded laptop sleeve. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/pocampo/the-worlds-best-sustainable-bike-bags-with-15-feat?ref=23b9d3

Just FYI, a lot (though certainly not all) of the panniers you see listed for over $100 are sold as a set of two. These Orliebs for instance, which many people consider to be the gold standard, are ~$75/pannier.

Glad to hear the Banjo Bros bag is working out for you though!

Topeak mtx trunk bag. The side panels unzip to unveil fold out panniers, I've been pretty happy with it!

I've been using this seat rack for about a month for my 11 mile commute (one way) and its been great. Cheaper than Topeak and easy to take on and off.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B002YSN5W6

Topeak used to make a laptop trunk bag, but Amazon says it is currently unavailable.

It was perfect for my laptop and all the other stuff I needed on my commute.

I've never had any trouble with my laptops over the years I've been carrying them on my rack.

Cell mount(don't let it distract you):
https://www.amazon.com/Universal-Bicycle-Handlebar-Motorcycle-BlackBerry/dp/B015C03SI8/ref=sr_1_1?s=outdoor-recreation&ie=UTF8&qid=1468274577&sr=1-1&refinements=p_72%3A1248957011

Choices for rack trunks and/or panniers

timbuk2(highly advise you look into it):
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00R936DOS/ref=twister_B00B3XWZD8?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

Hardbox(rack trunk, used to own one, very nice and good for clothing and light gear):
https://www.amazon.com/M-Wave-122461-Amsterdam-Hard-Box/dp/B001EVAYFK/ref=sr_1_13?s=outdoor-recreation&ie=UTF8&qid=1468274731&sr=1-13&refinements=p_72%3A1248957011%2Cp_n_feature_keywords_two_browse-bin%3A6035256011

Affordable rack trunk:
https://www.amazon.com/Bicycle-Roswheel-Trunk-Handbag-Pannier/dp/B008S4SX5E/ref=sr_1_2?s=outdoor-recreation&ie=UTF8&qid=1468274753&sr=1-2&refinements=p_72%3A1248957011


Or if you already have a backback you can go for the oldschool option(i.e. mil crate with zip ties):

Milk Crate:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0001ACQQA/ref=twister_B002BDTFP0?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

zip ties:
https://www.amazon.com/BuyCheapCables%C2%AE-Standard-Locking-Strength-100-pack/dp/B00IRMTYA0/ref=sr_1_sc_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1468275702&sr=8-3-spell&keywords=heavfy+duty+zip+ties


All of these items should have amazon free shipping(two days for prime, 6-8 for non prime members but still free)

I ride with the Axiom Seymour 30's. Not waterproof, but definitely resistant (probably not ok through a downpour). Mounting hardware is ok. Been using them for a year, carrying up to 30 pounds of groceries in them (lots of bottles and cans), and have been pretty solid.

Roswheel bike bags. They're cheap, but they've served me well in the past couple years. Plus the color scheme works wonders with my bike :)

Aside from putting delicate things at the top of my pannier, another option is a trunk bag like this:

http://www.amazon.com/MTX-Trunk-rigid-molded-panels/dp/B000ZKHN50

With the rigid sides, if you don't pack it full, then things like berries are not likely to get squished.

This particular bag relies on having a Topeak rack with the MTX mounting rail on top.

One alternative that I've really liked is this Free Rider Pannier. I use it to carry my backpack, or groceries, or anything. Very useful.

https://www.amazon.com/Green-Guru-Gear-Multicolor-22-Liter/dp/B00SA2ZU0U/ref=sr_1_66

I bought my gf this Wald Giant Delivery Basket for her school stuff and her Maine Coon cat (around 22 14lbs I think confirmed). It's the sturdiest thing I found out there. It doesn't have an actual weight rating as far as I could tell, but it could hold the cat just fine and this reviewer says it's okay for his 25lb dog. I feel confident it would not break, but I can't guarantee it so test it out first with something else if you use it.

The bigger concern would be how it would throw off your steering. 30lbs of dog + 7.8lbs of the basket is gonna do a number on your control. I have no idea if that would be steerable.

I use this:
Ibera PakRak Bicycle Quick-Release Commuter Trunk Bag https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B002T5MZ70/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_3c14CbRYV5H8C
You need to get their rack as well but it works fine for me. I fit in there clothes, lunch, mini pump, tools, tube and accessories.

Yup. https://www.greengurugear.com/collections/panniers/products/freerider-31l-pannier

or from Amazon slightly cheaper (I think it is the same pannier) https://www.amazon.com/Green-Guru-Gear-Multicolor-22-Liter/dp/B00SA2ZU0U/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1512065447&sr=8-2&keywords=green+guru+pannier

I've got a Green guru pannier, fits my disc golf backpack perfectly. I'm about to buy another one for my new ebike.

There are cheap panniers on Amazon. This one is 20 bucks and is the best seller of that kind of thing.

Thanks for the well thought out response! I'll have to look into some clipless shoes that still allow you to walk... I mostly "commute" to the movies, bank, etc. My work is a 7 mile ride, I sweat a lot, and work doesn't have showers... so I'm not too eager to ride to work yet.

Speaking of rear panniers, I was looking into buying this bag, what are your thoughts?

I'm pretty sure those are not waterproof. Axiom does have some that are waterproof. http://www.amazon.com/Axiom-Monsoon-Aero-Waterproof-Pannier/dp/B006Z0O6NQ/

I have a Green Guru Free Rider Pannier that works great for this. Just drop the whole backpack in and go. It works a lot like having a folding basket on the side of your rack, but it's lighter and doesn't rattle.

if you want panniers which are affordable you could go for these. Its not awesome like ortleib or vaude. but its something which would last at least a year or two if you take care of it.

https://www.amazon.com/BV-Panniers-Adjustable-Carrying-Reflective/dp/B00ESLVDIU/ref=sr_1_4?crid=25CUWT5ZU3FBV&keywords=panniers+for+bicycles&qid=1557945714&s=gateway&sprefix=panniers%2Caps%2C170&sr=8-4

They were very similar to this.

These must be the new version of them, they look a bit better made (also, sorry a little more pricey). I'd still recommend them at $60 - $80 which seems to be what they go for these days.

the link you shared are not the panniers he has. the ones he has (and that I have) are about $70. like I said...cheap.
https://www.amazon.com/Ibera-Bicycle-Quick-Release-Weather-Panniers/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ/ref=sr_1_3?keywords=ibera+pakrak&qid=1558961477&s=sporting-goods&sr=1-3

my Virtue Truck with accessories from left to right:

Thule Yepp Maxi Rack Mount Child Seat

Thule Yepp Maxi Easyfit Adapter

Schwinn Kids Bike Helmet - Teddy Bear

Brooks Saddle (used - exact make unknown)

Velo Orange Copehagen Double Kick

RockBros MTB Pedals

Origin8 Urban-Pro Riser Handlebar

Origin8 Time Clock Bell

Cork Chop Bicycle Grips

21x15" Wald 157 Giant Delivery Basket

15x15” Bungee Net

Kobra Ultra Bright Bike Light - 1200 Lumens


I love everything currently on her, but may end up going a bit wider on the bars now that I'm riding the rig fully loaded.

Also a bike that has the ability to add bags to the sides of the back wheel is very important for transporting. A heavy backpack on a bycicle is very tiring.

Wald makes some very good baskets, both front and back. You just have to ride slower when hauling stuff in a basket.

I'm hesitant to replace the bag that I use every day and is still in great condition, just something that I can buy to make it so that I can still use it. After research, I found that I could get a this Topeak Bag and a Topeak Basket for groceries. I could fold my messenger bag and have enough room for stuffs.

I have a set of axioms I've been using for 6 years - I don't think they make my model any more (lasalle) but they've served me well. The panniers themselves are black, but they came with a high vis rain cover with a reflective accents.

These are similar and if the raincovers aren't included they can be purchased separately

If you are worried about showing up unwrinkled. Perhaps something like [This](M-Wave Amsterdam Hard Box https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001EVAYFK/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_gT8XCbWS15V8F) hardcase would suit you better then panniers.

check out wald's front baskets. they're cheap and well built, and you can just put a backpack, or whatever, inside without worrying much about retention. they attach at the axel and at the handler bar, close to the stem. this one is quite large and under $50. personally, i prefer heavier loads on the front of the bike.

Except don't wear a backpack. They make your back all sweaty. Use a trunk bag like this one instead.

These are Axiom Seymour DLX panniers. Don't know about OP's size, but I got the 30L. They are intended as a front pannier but attach just fine to rear racks.

They aren't as waterproof as some other options, though. Just mostly water resistant. If you're going to be in a downpour, I wouldn't rely on these without at least a garbage bag as a liner.

They are on amazon and I think their website is http://m-wave-bike.com/ not sure if you can buy through them there.
Here is an amazon link to their double pannier


He

These Axiom monsoons have treated me well thus far. Not fancy, but the waterproofing is legit, and there's quite a lot of room. The mounting system works well, although I don't take them on and off much, since I have a secure place to park the bike at my work.

edit: phone screwed up link, fixed

You can get a lockable box for your rear rack like this one (Amazon Link), your helmet should fit inside but of course check first.

I picked up the Roswheel 3 in 1 so far so good, minus the missing shoulder strap. I just need to find a better rack so I'll be watching to see what pops up.

I definitely got the wrong panniers (at least inappropriately sized). I got the Topeak MTX EX.

You're right, I don't need all that stuff, especially given that there's a bus line that runs very close to my route. It's just that I've always been one that erred on the side of caution and always try to be as prepared as I can.

I have a single stack 9mm in this. Works fairly well for around town/commuting. The gun does barely fit, and that bag is sizeable, but I actually bought the bag for the phone feature first.

Side bag attached to the luggage rack, soft case with sling wrapped around the opposite side of the seat to secure it and resting against my back while riding. Not comfortable, by any means, but didn't interfere with pedaling. The side bags are this model: https://www.amazon.ca/Ibera-Bicycle-Quick-Release-Weather-Panniers/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ/

I'll probably get the Axiom Monsoon Aero DLX 35 Pannier Set for $90 that I've been looking at. Will see how big my nxt paycheck and might just splurge on the Ortieb Back Roller Classics.

http://www.amazon.com/M-Wave-122461-Amsterdam-Hard-Box/dp/B001EVAYFK

20% off these Iberia panniers. I've actually had my eye on them for awhile, going to pull the trigger today!

https://www.amazon.com/Ibera-Bicycle-Quick-Release-Weather-Panniers/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ/ref=sr_1_1

You can buy http://www.amazon.com/Axiom-Seymour-Pannier-Black-Single/dp/B009P3KQNO/ref=sr_1_14/188-1944618-3075044?s=cycling&ie=UTF8&qid=1417713521&sr=1-14 and cut that cost by at least a 1/3. I commute nearly every day through sun or rain and they've stood up for the past 2 months I've had them. That universal clip is pretty much standard now for commuting. And they have a warranty. I don't get why people drop so much on stuff...

This should work:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Wave-Amsterdam-Box-Cargo-Topcase/dp/B001EVAYFK

Depending on what you're travelling with, you could look into a bike rack and detachable bag.

I use this rack and this bag.

For reference.

No idea how well they will hold up long term, but they shed rain on the first outing.

I have a set of panniers made by a company called Axiom

They are close to your price range, and they are tough bags for an economical price. They are water resistant, but they are not waterproof though.

Sorry on phone http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B001T2XVYU
I have the Topeak MTX rack and use a trunk bag for commuting

I got these ones a couple years ago but I swear they were no more than $50 when I got them. They've held up well for me.

I sort of ended up doing this. I found a pair of these for 25$ on craigslist and my work bag juuuust fits inside. Now it's protected from grit during the commute so I should be able to avoid what others were warning me about. https://www.amazon.com/Ibera-Bicycle-Quick-Release-Weather-Panniers/dp/B00KW2ZIMQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1480685514&sr=8-1&keywords=ibera+panniers

Not with a cervelo but with a fancy (to me) road bike. I use the Ibera pack rack seat post mounted rack and bag. It can wobble a little bit when standing but that's because of the high weight load and center of gravity. all the "stress" is really put on the post and taken off your back!

On Amazon it's about $80 for the combo: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002YSN5W6/ref=cm_sw_r_awd_T0p.ub0JQFSTA


Sorry for the messy link, I'm on mobile.

These are the ones I got. I planned on only using them as front panniers, but turns out I ordered two too many. So I'm managing. They aren't completely waterproof, so I'm going to have and find some raincovers :\

I have the same, use them for commuting for about a year, no complaints at all.

http://www.amazon.com/Axiom-Seymour-Pannier-Black-Gray/dp/B009P3KQNO/