Reddit mentions: The best gardening axes
We found 125 Reddit comments discussing the best gardening axes. We ran sentiment analysis on each of these comments to determine how redditors feel about different products. We found 64 products and ranked them based on the amount of positive reactions they received. Here are the top 20.
1. Husqvarna 26" Wooden Multi-Purpose Axe
- Multi-purpose axe is a single-bit axe in traditional style
- Head is attached to the hickory shaft using both a wooden and Steel Wedge to secure fastening
- Versatile axe used for tree felling, wood chopping, and other jobs
- The long handle provides power to the cut
- Includes a leather edge cover
Features:
Specs:
Height | 1.6 Inches |
Length | 25.6 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Weight | 2.1 Pounds |
Width | 7.2 Inches |
2. Crescent Nicholson 8" Rectangular Double/Single Cut Axe File - Carded - 06706N
American pattern axe sharpening file with a double-cut side and a single-cut sideIdeal file for sharpening axes and miscellaneous garden toolsRectangular shape has a large surface area for faster filing workDouble-cut on one side for rough filing and single-cut on the opposite for finishingThis file...
Specs:
Color | Original Version |
Height | 0.25 Inches |
Length | 13 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 8-Inch |
Width | 2 Inches |
3. CRKT Woods Chogan Tomahawk Axe: RMJ T-Hawk Lightweight Outdoor Camping Axe with Hammerhead, Forged Carbon Steel Blade, and Hickory Wooden Handle 2730
- Forged Tough: 1055 Carbon steel provides durability and edge retention
- Durable: Tennessee hickory is a dense material that withstands hard use
- Multi-Purpose Utility: Easily split wood or hammer tent stakes
- Designed by Ryan Johnson of RMJ Tactical in Chattanooga, Tennessee
- Limited Lifetime Warranty covers any defects in materials or workmanship, see company site for details
Features:
Specs:
Color | Axe with Hammerhead |
Height | 1.64 Inches |
Length | 19.13 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 7.5FT |
Weight | 1.99 Pounds |
Width | 7.81 Inches |
4. S.A. Wetterling Axe 10H Small Axe with Hickory Handle
- Used Book in Good Condition
Features:
Specs:
Weight | 1.6 Pounds |
5. Vaughan SH2 22-Ounce Carpenters Half Hatchet, Flame Treated Hickory Handle, 13-Inch Long.
- Fully polished
- Forged entirely of high quality, high carbon steel
- Beveled nail slot in polished head
- 13" fine flame treated hickory handle
- Extra large, crowned striking face for accurate power blows
Features:
Specs:
Color | Gray |
Height | 6.25 Inches |
Length | 13.75 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | Pack of 1 |
Weight | 1.65 Pounds |
Width | 1.5 Inches |
6. Armory Replicas Viking Age Fully Functional Bearded Axe
- Overall Length: 30.39 Inches / Overall Width: 7.38 Inches
- Thickness: 12.45mm / Blade Length: 6.63 Inches
- Blade Material: Carbon Steel / Material: Wood
- Fully Functional / Hand Forged
- Dull Edge to Customize
Features:
Specs:
Color | Brown |
Size | One Size |
7. Gransfors Bruk Splitting Maul 31.50 Inch Wood Splitting Axe, 450
5 1/2 ib. HeadLength with handle: 80 cm (31.5”)Weight: 3,2 kg (7 lb)Sheath in vegetable-tanned leather
Specs:
Color | Brown and silver |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 32 Inches |
Size | 31.50 Inches |
Weight | 7 Pounds |
Width | 11 Inches |
8. Council Tool 2.25 lb Boy's Axe, 28 inch Curved Handle
- 2.25 lb Boy's Axe with 24 inch Curved Handle
- Hand sharpened, tapered bit for cutting and light splitting
- The interior detail of the eye is tapered and allows for a strong mechanical bond. Approximately 1/2" of overall length of the handle is removed during assembly
- The serrated shape improves bite, and the aluminum choice of material is strong, lightweight, and does not change size with moisture content
- Head coated with black enamel and the cutting edge in clear lacquer to deter rust
Features:
Specs:
Height | 1.3 Inches |
Length | 27.6 Inches |
Size | 28 |
Weight | 3 Pounds |
Width | 6.5 Inches |
9. Estwing Sportsman's Axe - 12" Camping Hatchet with Forged Steel Construction & Genuine Leather Grip - E14A
- FORGED IN ONE PIECE – The most durable, longest lasting striking tools available are crafted from a single piece of solid steel and honed into the optimal design for use.
- OUTDOOR VERSATILITY - A jack of all trades built perfectly for chopping logs, small trees & branches or splitting firewood & kindling.
- HEAVY DUTY SHEATH - Includes ballistic nylon sheath to protect hand sharpened cutting edge.
- GENUINE LEATHER GRIP – Hand sanded and lacquered for a durable yet comfortable finish, this handle doesn't have to sacrifice function for timeless style.
- MADE IN THE USA – Since 1923, our tools have been proudly crafted in Rockford, IL using only the finest American steel.
Features:
Specs:
Color | Steel |
Height | 1.13 Inches |
Length | 12.5 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 12" (Inches) |
Weight | 1.38 Pounds |
Width | 4.75 Inches |
10. Estwing Camper's Axe - 14" Hatchet with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - EO-25A
FORGED IN ONE PIECE – The most durable, longest lasting striking tools availableOUTDOOR VERSITILITY - Perfect for chopping logs, small trees & branches or splitting firewood & kindlingHEAVY DUTY SHEATH - Includes ballistic nylon sheath to protect hand sharpened cutting edgePATENTED SHOCK REDUCTION...
Specs:
Color | Orange |
Height | 14.25 inches |
Length | 4.5 inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 14" |
Weight | 2 Pounds |
Width | 1.25 inches |
11. Brook & Hunter MT-W-AXE Premium Mo-Tool Axe with Wood Inlay Handle
Mo-Tool axeWood inlay handleMultiple tools in oneStainless steel alloy blade: highly polished.Lifetime warranty
Specs:
Color | Wood |
Height | 1 Inches |
Length | 7 Inches |
Width | 3.5 Inches |
12. Estwing MFG Co E2H Carpenter's Hatchet Leather Grip 3-5/8"
- ESTWING CARPENTER'S HATCHET
- 13" L
- Full polished, forged one piece solid steel
- Leather grip
Features:
Specs:
Color | Genuine Leather Grip |
Height | 6.3 Inches |
Length | 13 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 13" |
Weight | 2.06 Pounds |
Width | 1.2 Inches |
13. Estwing Fireside Friend Axe - 14" Wood Splitting Maul with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - E3-FF4
Crafted from the highest quality materialsBuilt for performance and durabilityMade in United States
Specs:
Color | Blue |
Height | 1.5 Inches |
Length | 14.25 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | One Size |
Weight | 0.440924524 Pounds |
Width | 5.83 Inches |
14. Gerber Gator Combo Axe II [22-41420]
- Forged steel head for blade durability + striking force.
- Glass-filled nylon handle hides a coarse blade saw for brush/branches.
- Gator Grip handle material provides sure grip in all conditions.
- Saw is held inside handle magnetically, for easy + secure transport.
- Any condition. Any task. Get out there.
Features:
Specs:
Color | MULTI |
Height | 5 Inches |
Length | 5 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Release date | November 2019 |
Size | One Size |
Weight | 3.6 Kilograms |
Width | 5 Inches |
15. Estwing Tomahawk Axe - 16.25" Lightweight Hatchet with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - EBTA,Black
FORGED STEEL CONSTRUCTION – Maximum strength and durability for a lifetime of hard workOUTDOOR VERSITILITY - Perfect for chopping small trees & branches. Use pick end for breaching, excavation & extricationHEAVY DUTY SHEATH - Includes ballistic nylon sheath to protect hand sharpened cutting edgePA...
Specs:
Color | Black |
Height | 1.25 Inches |
Length | 16.25 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Size | EBTA |
Weight | 0.440924524 Pounds |
Width | 7.38 Inches |
16. 1844 Helko Werk Germany Vario 2000 Universal Axe - German Made Axe Tool for Splitting and Cutting with Interchangeable Head 10053
- Handmade In Germany - A larger, more powerful version of the Vario 2000 Universal Axe, with a longer handle and an upgraded 4 pound head capable of delivering incredible striking power. This axe is designed to handle heavy, difficult felling jobs. The curved, ergonomic handle creates excellent balance and minimizes fatigue. This axe may handle and feel like a traditional felling axe, but the wedge incline head design makes it an exceptional splitter as well.
- Patented Interchangeable Head Design With C50 High Carbon Steel - 53-56 HRC - The Vario 2000 uses Helko Werk's patented axe design - a German engineered bolt-on fastening system that introduces incredible versatility and efficiency across the Vario product line. All Vario heads, handles, and fastening components are fully interchangeable and inter-compatible. The heads are assembled with bolts which are driven through the handle and secured by a butt-plate retainer cap.
- Grade A American Hickory - Matte Lacquer Finish - 150 Grit Sanded Lightly lacquered with black-dipped grip, individually selected for grain orientation and density, and sustainably sourced grade A American hickory
- Includes Full Grain Leather Sheath - 1 Oz. Bottle of Axe Guard Protective Oil - All Helko Werk Axes include a vegetable-tanned premium leather axe sheath to protect your axes and hatchets
- Dimensions - Head Weight: 4lbs , Total Weight: 7 lbs, Bit Length: 5 ⅛ in, Handle Length: 36 in
Features:
Specs:
Color | Silver |
Height | 1.5 Inches |
Length | 30 Inches |
Size | Universal Axe |
Weight | 2.5 Pounds |
Width | 7 Inches |
17. Estwing Special Edition Fireside Friend Axe - 14" Wood Splitting Maul with Forged Steel Construction & Genuine Leather Grip - EFF4SE
- FORGED IN ONE PIECE – The most durable, longest lasting striking tools available
- WOOD SPLITTING MADE EASY - Weighted wedge design makes chopping logs and firewood a breeze
- HEAVY DUTY SHEATH - Includes ballistic nylon sheath to protect hand sharpened cutting edge
- PATENTED SHOCK REDUCTION GRIP – Comfortable, durable & reduces impact vibration by 70%
- MADE IN THE USA – Our tools are proudly crafted in Rockford, IL using the finest American steel
Features:
Specs:
Color | Black-special Edition |
Height | 1.5 Inches |
Length | 14.25 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Weight | 0.440924524 Pounds |
Width | 5.83 Inches |
18. Council Tool 2.0 Lb Hudson Bay Camp Axe, 24 Inch Curved Handle with Leather Sheath
2 Lb head; 24 inch Curved hickory handleForged from 5160 grade alloy steelBit is heat treated and quenched approximately 1 inch from the cutting edge, then tempered for maximum edge holding and toughness; final hardness Rc 52-56Axe head is coated with light oil to prevent rusting and to showcase the...
Specs:
Color | clear |
Height | 3 Inches |
Length | 30 Inches |
Weight | 2.8 Pounds |
Width | 9.5 Inches |
19. Graintex CA1754 Single Bit Camp Axe with 14-Inch Hickory Handle, 1-1/4 Lb
- Hickory handle
- Fully polished head
- Epoxy bonded
- Heat treated and tempered
- Drop forged
Features:
Specs:
Number of items | 1 |
Size | 1-1/4 LB |
Weight | 1.25 Pounds |
20. Husqvarna 32" Wooden Splitting Maul
- Designed for splitting chunks of wood and poll is designed for driving splitting wedges
- Hardened striking face in the neck and can therefore be used as a sledge or in combination with a splitting Wedge
- Includes a leather edge cover
- Head is attached to a hickory shaft using both a wooden and Steel Wedge to secure fastening
- Only sledge axes can withstand use as a sledgehammer
Features:
Specs:
Color | Black |
Height | 2 Inches |
Length | 31.1 Inches |
Number of items | 1 |
Weight | 6.8 Pounds |
Width | 8.9 Inches |
🎓 Reddit experts on gardening axes
The comments and opinions expressed on this page are written exclusively by redditors. To provide you with the most relevant data, we sourced opinions from the most knowledgeable Reddit users based the total number of upvotes and downvotes received across comments on subreddits where gardening axes are discussed. For your reference and for the sake of transparency, here are the specialists whose opinions mattered the most in our ranking.
First off, I think this is the most elaborate contest I've ever participated in, so congratulations for that :P Fear cuts deeper than swords. I hope some of my items are awesome enough for some extra credit ;) Also I wasn't sure if duplicates are allowed. I will revise if necessary.
1.) Something grey and it's been on my wishlist.
2.) Rain, well not technically rain, she is a water bender :P Previously on my wishlist.
3.) Unusual, I think this is something I would use like twice a year. With ice cream or cereal.
4.) Someone else My sister and I want to start playing tabletop games. Previously on my wishlist.
5.) "Book" I took a little bit of liberty with this one because it's a graphic novel. But it's Batman, so...(Previously on my wishlist).
6.) Under a dollar.
7.) Cats There's a catbus in it, which is pretty much the best part of the movie. Previously on my wishlist.
8.) Beautiful As a Star Wars fan having the original trilogy on Blu Ray would be beautiful to me. I love high definition movies, especially ones that are aesthetically pleasing. Previously on my wishlist.
9.) Movie As a Browncoat, I would encourage anyone who has a remote interest in Sci-Fi to give this a chance. Previously on my wishlist.
10.) Zombie tool I don't think this needs explanation.
11.) (Updated) Useful for future. I have a desire to create meaningful video games. Previously on wish list.
12.) Add on I actually had this on my wishlist but removed it because add-on items are lame.
13.) Most expensive As previously stated, I want to be a game developer/designer so not only would it be fun to play with, I could create with it too. Previously on list.
14.) Bigger than breadbox Total in the box it is bigger than a breadbox. Previously on wishlist.
15.) Bigger than a golf ball It's a large book. Previously on wishlist.
16.) Smells good As a guy...I enjoy the scent of lavender.
17.) Safe for children toy I don't think this needs any introduction of why it's awesome.
18.) Back to school drawing helps keep me sane. Previously on my list.
19.) Current obsession I'm a noob to tabletop games. But have been wanting to get into it obsessively within the past month or so. And this also takes my love of A Song of Ice and Fire into the mix. Previously on list.
20.) [Amazing] (http://www.amazon.com/Sony-XBR-65X900A-65-Inch-120Hz-Ultra/dp/B00BSREQI6/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1376281533&sr=8-4&keywords=4k+tv) I've seen one of these in person at the mall and it literally made me stop walking the resolution was so incredible. I know it's as expensive as dicks...but man...when these are affordable...
Bonus 2) Made in Oregon I would have put Tillamook Ice Cream, since it's pretty awesome...but alas not on Amazon.
Edit: Changed an item because I saw it won't count because it's a duplicate.
*Tl;Dr. BUY CHEAP AT FIRST!! Any Morakniv and the Gator Combo hatchet/saw will get you started with shelter building, firewood processing, and campcraft projects. Total is about $50 USD. I hate pruning saws in general, but if you must have one then the Corona is slightly cheaper than the Bahco, performs the same or better, and has more size options. If budget isn't an issue silky makes professional grade saws, but consider just getting a buck saw blade and making a frame yourself.**
 
I've collected an assortment of knives/axes/saws for trips into the woods and since there is usually 3 or 4 post per week asking about knife purchases, I thought I would share some of my experiences I have with budget/mid range cutting tools for Bushcraft.
 
Pictured:
 
Thoughts:
Tools are a personal thing and I expect to hear about it in the comments on where others are coming from. r/bushcraft is largely an echo chamber for mora knives and for good reason. They are inexpensive, high quality, and well designed for the jobs you are likely wanting to do with a knife. Mors Kochanski goes in depth on this subject in his book Bushcraft; it's a must read for anyone starting out.
I would add for the sub-$50.00:
Estwing
Cold Steel Trench Hawk
Cold Steel Trail Hawk
The Estwings are very well built, but they have a somewhat soft heat treat. The Cold Steels are well-made and I particularly like their Trail Hawk (just threw in the Trench Hawk 'cause it's cool). It may be tempting to get the Rifleman's Hawk, but it's too big for an effective 'hawk and too small to be a good woodsman's ax.
Condor also makes some excellent value axes, but they have a lot of choices. You should give them a look!
For your stated use, I'd look at an ax. Here is a 2-part series by Mors Kochanski that should help in the choosing of an ax:
Part 1
Part 2
Axes are sweet. Have fun!
I have a little collection of GB's, including the small forest, scandanvian forest, and mini belt hatchet, and for "all purpose" I'd suggest the scandanavian. It's got a great length handle, the head has a fantastic cut and isn't too heavy so you won't tire too quickly. The only con I'd say is the obvious... they're not great for splitting rounds due to the head geometry. Kindling, absolutely, but anything bigger than your thigh may require some effort.
May i suggest a non-GB? Check out the Helko Pioneer. It is roughly the same length handle as the scandanavian forest axe, but a bit beefier in the hands, and the head is a tad heavier and thicker. It's proven to be a fantastic cutter and it's not half bad at splitting also. It's excellent, quickly became a fave. Great metal too, holds a fantastic edge and has never rolled or chipped on me. Enjoy responsibly :).
----
Edit: expand and add more links
I like to sharpen my axes with a file this one works well. I have different axes for felling and splitting yours looks like it has a hollow or concave grind in my experience these don't make good splitting axes (sorry) but where you are just using it for kindling it should be fine. I like to sharpen my splitting axes with a more robust edge think cleaver vs fillet knife. And just sharp enough that if you push on it and slide your hand down it will cut you so pressure won't break the skin and sliding your thumb along the edge won't cut you but both will. Good luck
Edit: watch this at 17:15 he is done hanging the head and begins in on sharpening
Wetterlings and Gransfors Brux are the considered by many to be some of the best axes and hatchets you can buy (and they certainly cost enough!).
However, on the more normally priced, but still higher-end of things, you can safely get an Estwing, Fiskars, or Condor - with the edge going to Condor for being the most 'traditional' of those more normal priced hatchets.
Of those that I listed, I own the Estwing and Fiskars, as the others have just been out of my price range. I like them both very much. Over time, the finish on the leather handle of the Estwing will crack and flake, which is probably likely due to sun exposure - you will need to maintain the handle a bit eventually. The Fiskars, though definitely the most modern looking - are quite awesome hatchets for the price, and are incredibly durable. It's edge might be a little more fragile (it's just an angle thing, you could probably reprofile it if you were desperate) than the Estwing, but it cuts a little better too - you just have to avoid rocks (as you should be anyways).
I can’t comment on that one, but I have the Estwing Sportsman’s Axe 12” and I definitely like it thus far.
Looks like they are priced fairly similarly on Amazon at the moment. I paid closer to $50 USD for mine, so the current Amazon price looks appealing (especially with Prime).
I also like the Morakniv knives. I have them strewn about my house, vehicles, and my GF’s house. Most all of them are the cheaper $15 version, but I have had zero problems for light to medium tasks.
Happy hiking!
I bought a Fiskars X7 14" hatchet for $23 at WalMart and use it regularly.
I love that hatchet. I attached the plastic sheath to the MOLLE webbing on my pack with two carabiners so it doesn't swing around much. It hacked easily through a 6" diameter Oak limb that had fallen from a tree and after de-limbing, I choked up on the handle of the hatchet to carve a bow-drill kit. I was surprised how versatile the hatchet is. The steel is a little on the soft side, so it will need to be honed regularly, but the softer steel is also very easy to hone with a puck or a stone, so I really don't mind doing it.
I actually just got rid of my Ontario RAT-5 because I simply stopped using it once I got that hatchet. I already had a Mora so I really only used the RAT-5 for batoning.
Best part is, it weighs <2lbs with the sheath. It's a cheap way to figure out if a camp axe or hatchet will work for you. If you like it but want a little more chopping power, you can get the X15, 23.5" chopping axe off Amazon for like $35.
Or, if you decide you like it and want something higher quality, look into Council Tool's Velvicut Boy's Axe or Velvicut Hudson Bay Axe, or something hand-forged by the Swedish elves at Gransfors Bruks or Wetterlings.
Be aware of your technique though. Hatchets and small axes are very dangerous if you aren't cognizant of the swing. If you miss with a short axe, it won't hit the ground, it'll just swing around into your leg, so always use a large safety log underneath your target log to catch the axe, or get down onto your knees if you're chopping something low to the ground. Just generally try not to swing the head of the axe below your hips, it's a waste of calories anyway. Use the lanyard hole on the handle to loop a string around your wrist, because when you get tired, it will come out of your hand, eventually.
If you don't like the axe, you may consider a folding saw, like a Sven 21" or 15", Bahco Laplander or Silky 210 and/or a large survival knife, like an Ontario Spec Plus SP50, Ka-Bar Becker BK7 or an ESEE 6.
Honestly, I'm not in love with the Bark River knife. They say it's convex, but it feels kind of like one side is convex and the other side is straight. I'm left handed so the convex side is on the wrong side for me, the convex is good for feather sticks if you're right handed though.
The hatchet will lose it's edge much quicker but it's much easier to sharpen than that Bark River knife. CPM-3V is very hard and takes forever to sharpen, so that's something to consider.
I'd get the hatchet and save your money. Maybe look into getting small splitting ax, that's probably the next bushcraft/camping cutting tool I'm going to buy. Something like this. I haven't done much research on Mauls yet.
I don't own that yet, but my feedback on the hatchet I linked earlier would be that it's too thin and doesn't split wood as well as a more specialized too. I just recently learned about Mauls and I fuckin want one, they've got a sweet name and they're heavy and split wood much better than a camp ax. When I used the hatchet last weekend I found it difficult to chop through firewood that was bigger than approx. five inches across.
http://i.imgur.com/yFLLE.jpg http://i.imgur.com/6Y9rf.jpg .... Just thought I'd show this. There are very expensive German axes out there. I will get one. Till then this axe was purchased on amazon with the sheath for $25. Good balance, light and the axe head come to a very very thin edge. A little sharpening and this can be a great carving axe, as well as split wood. So, you don't need to spend $100 for a great axe. Cheers. http://i.imgur.com/W1Cai.jpg
http://www.amazon.com/Graintex-CA1754-Single-14-Inch-Hickory/dp/B003H9M1DA/ref=pd_cp_hi_2/177-2135312-5036648
http://www.amazon.com/Nupla-22212-Rawhide-Blade-Campers/dp/B004UMH0U2/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1331700167&amp;sr=1-1
I would have to kindly disagree. The BIFL part of a traditional axe head is that you can easily rehang(replace the handle) it yourself. What if Fiskars stops honoring their policy like so many other "BIFL" brands? Then you be stuck up shit creek without paddle. Give me a piece of wood and a rasp and I can make a handle in less than an hour.
The other gripe I have about the Fiskars (I own one myself) is that they vehemently tell you to never use the back end as a striking tool. It makes since, once you realize how the head is attached to the handle, and this to me takes away half the use of the tool. That said, it hasn't stopped me from using the back end for striking in a pinch, just not something you should be doing with it.
EDIT: If you want to downvote me, please entertain me with reasons why I am wrong. I hand make tools and use them a lot. I have used these type of axes as well as traditional ones and I feel like my arguments are sound based on first hand experience.
EDIT #2: Checked out Fiskars website on their warranty info. It appears that all axes sold now are covered for 25 years. I wouldn't consider that BIFL in my book. What happens is the plastic in the handle breaks down after time and exposure. Eventually it will break. Fiskars is betting that will be more than 25 years down the road.
EDIT#3: In spirit of what this is is all about, I would recommend a Husqvarna in any size and style with a wooden handle. They are Swedish made, and use a traditional design, allowing the purchaser to replace the handle. If you don't care to make a replacement handle yourself, they can be bought for less than $10 at any hardware store or on Amazon.
I don't think all of these points can be met with just a single knife.
Any knife strong enough to be used to baton wood over and over again isn't going to be inexpensive.
Partial serrations aren't very good, and in my experience, having a half serrated and half plain edge makes the knife okay at both but great at neither.
If you were going to rely on a knife as a survival knife, wouldn't you want it to be high quality as to not have it break on you when you need it most?
My suggestion would be a small camp axe, with a separate knife used for your serrated needs. Something like this Wetterling along with a small serrated knife like this SpyderCo.
OK.
So, there are essentially three materials the ax head could be made from: Iron, Steel and Mythril.
Iron is the most fragile at about 200MPa ultimate tensile strength, Steel will range from about 500 to 2600MPa depending on composition and Mythril is estimated to be above 90,000 MPa.
Based on this screencap it looks like a pretty standard bearded ax.
The one in the link is about 30" long with a 6.6" blade width which is pretty close to what is shown on screen.
To make things easy we will say the blade is 1.2cm thick, 16.7cm wide and 18.5 cm tall.
I used this load calculator to estimate:
For comparison a human swinging a sledgehammer would be around 1000-4000 lbs of force.
Materials science is not my specialty so I may be way off.
Husqvarna wooden stuff is the best bang for your buck. Probably not in store, but free shipping on amazon. Though it's around 90.
Husqvarna 32" Wooden Splitting Maul https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004WJ1NYW/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_VL01Bb3WD4RX8
Husky will be your cheapest. Fiskars is the step up, have heard it is a big improvement. It should be in stores.
I use the splitting maul. Its awesome. My favorite tool I own. Some of my buddies think its strange I enjoy splitting wood. But this maul makes it enjoyable.
http://www.amazon.com/Gransfors-Bruks-450-Splitting-Maul/dp/B000WIOE7A
It kinda sounds like he has a lot of stuff and that you don't necessarily know every tiny thing he has / uses / lurves, which is understandable, because people who really think on their EDC-type stuff often buy and trade a lot of crap. I'd almost suggest trying to get out of the EDC-items box and getting him The Axe Book or Back to Basics, both of which cover skills around outdoorsy things. AB will cover how to cut down all kinds of trees with an axe; BTB covers all kinds of homesteading, food growing, basic skills required for such. Both have lots of neat illustrations and seem to come from pretty competent writers. The Axe Book has made me want to get a decent axe, which obviously isn't an EDC item, but it's a nice to have one. If you get something like that, just keep in mind, axes aren't made out of stainless steel, so he'll want some mineral oil / gun-lube type oil to keep rust away.
Otherwise there's always Celox and an Israeli combat bandage for the 'super bad emergency contingency' part of one's EDC. I like to have something like that in my day bag or in my car, just in case.
this one is REALLY good! https://www.amazon.com/Husqvarna-576926201-Curved-Handle-Multipurpose/dp/B004WJGXAQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1467604448&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=husqvarna+axe
A Good hatchet! https://www.amazon.com/Husqvarna-576926401-13-Curved-Hatchet/dp/B004VLKLJE/ref=pd_bxgy_468_img_2?ie=UTF8&amp;psc=1&amp;refRID=M2MACRPSRKX1VZSM8FJ2
If you want a great axe and not pay a crap ton for a Hultafor or Gransfors Bruks I highly recommend Husqvarna axes. They are made with Swedish steel and have decent handles. I keep a 26" Multipurpose in my vehicle and it has served me well.
I friggin' love this thing. I thinned the handle significantly and re-profiled the bit to be a straight wedge, got it razor sharp and I hope to carry it forever.
Get this: Estwing Carpenter's Hatchet It's a timeless, handsome tool that you will never outgrow and weighing in at 1.9 pounds. I use an old craftsman carpenters hatchet with my camping gear that I inherited from my uncle that is perfect for my needs but if I were to buy new I would get the Estwing. (that sexy one piece forge)
There are a ton of axes out there that fit your profile straight out of the box. You're just looking for a European style forest axe.
This is your best "budget" option.
These
are
some
... pricier options.
Don't ruin a perfectly fine American axe trying to replicate a European axe. There's no reason for it.
As for whether your design is good for "camp tasks," well, that depends. You'd need to define some things.
I got my dad this maul for Christmas, He loves it, it splits like a dream, if you can lift it, it does the rest
Splitting Maul!
Buy yourself a decent hatchet. Better than a hawk for processing wood and a hatchet will have a far more substantial poll for use as a pounding implement (No striking steel on steel though!). If you are determined to have an actual hammer head, you should look into a Carpenter's Half Hatchet(aka a shingling hatchet)
In all of my time in the outdoors, I have never found any need for a pry bar. Digging sticks and wood levers? Absolutely. Pry bar? Nope.
A bearded axe looks like this
https://www.amazon.com/Viking-Age-Fully-Functional-Bearded/dp/B01M6C98EG
And the metal thing under the blade is useful for hooking an opponent’s shield so it can be pulled off and they can be attacked easier. For example, if you were charging at me with your shield up, I could hook my axe to the top of your shield and pull it (and you) forward faster, causing you to get off balance and perhaps fall over. This makes a counterattack easy for me. The handle just increases range
Edit- new words to clarify
Fair enough. Are you looking for a half hatchet in particular? That seems to fit your description the best. Flat bit, hammer poll. They are generally on a standard 12” handle, but I’m sure you could find a replacement 18” to throw on it.
EDIT: Estwing is something to look at. Very good product and on a steel handle. They have the campers hatchet and a campers axe that are both close to what you’re looking for.
Estwing Camper's Axe - 14" Hatchet with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - EO-25A https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01D8STIVM/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_062YBbD41Y5CK
Estwing Fireside Friend Axe - 14" Wood Splitting Maul with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - E3-FF4 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000HAEI1A/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_r.2YBb972F01R
Such awesome axes.
Little spendy, and if you want to get one a little cheaper with little less fit and finish you can get a Husqvarna forest axe which is currently produced by Gransfors Bruks for Husqvarna, for about half the price of the full meal deal from gransfors
I've got the crkt woods chogan hawk and I love it. It's a little heavier than the standard tomahawk, but I like that a lot. You end up getting a lot of chopping power in a little package.
Many people love the cold steel trail hawks, I prefer the CRKT hawk for a budget option.
Thanks. I have this one that hopefully will work. Doesn't seem angled though
Nicholson 06706N Axe File, 8-Inch https://www.amazon.com/dp/B006DWT7HG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_MB6QCbRT6QF3G
I got their 14" camper's axe and it's been great.
As shown here on Amazon. I've had one for nearly 30 years and it holds up great.
People seem to like this one which is only 40 bucks
Of course, if money were no object, I would want the on that op has haha
I do not have a hawk yet, and just recently got my first hatchet. (wetterlings) But my limited experience with my hatchet has me curious about the versatility of a hawk.
Here's the link to CRKT's website: http://www.crkt.com/woods-chogan-thawk-axe-2730
I bought mine off of Amazon from this listing: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00I04Q7LO/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&amp;psc=1
Edit: is there a better sub for this post?
I have the husqvarna 26" axe which is made by hults bruks. It has been a fantastic axe and keeps its edge very well. I also have a gransfors bruks axe and the quality of the husqvarna is nearly identical.
https://www.amazon.com/Husqvarna-576926201-Curved-Wooden-Multipurpose/dp/B004WJGXAQ
I normally clip off the pin, use a metal file to file it as flush as I can, and glue a rare earth magnet to the back using E6000 glue. The glue you can get at any craft store. You should be able to get the magnets there too. Depending on how many you want to make though these ones are probably a better deal.
These are great bang for the buck hand forged in sweden. A real top notch axe at a great price. Husqvarna
Gransfors Bruks aslo make BIFL axes but at a bit higher price point. You can also check out Axe junkies.com if you really want to nerd ou on axes. Rumor has it the Husky axes are forged by Granfors.
Most likely some kind of lacquer or varnish.
Get an axe file (like this one) and a Lansky puck. You can find a lot of great tutorials on how to sharpen an axe on youtube.
Vaughan carpenter hatchet
https://www.amazon.com/Vaughan-22-Ounce-Carpenters-Hatchet-Treated/dp/B0002IGHAM/ref=mp_s_a_1_3?keywords=vaughan+hatchet&amp;qid=1555884173&amp;s=gateway&amp;sr=8-3
Cold Steel Axe Gang are my personal favorite and a favorite of most people I know unfortunately on backorder for a while
Or the Prandi
https://www.amazon.com/Prandi-German-Style-Hatchet-PRA0308TH/dp/B0742LLJ3Q/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?crid=2RZBM9EQLOGMX&amp;keywords=prandi+hatchet&amp;qid=1555884296&amp;s=gateway&amp;sprefix=prandi&amp;sr=8-1
I like the one with the leather handle, available in the UK too!
Or the carpenter version.
For 100 bucks and you are after bushcrafting... I would recommend this.
Wetterlings Hatchet - 70
Mora 1 - 13
Gerber slide saw - 10
I really like this and used it exclusively to make about 10 ft³ of kindling for this season:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000HAEI1A/ref=cm_sw_r_other_apa_i_f1uHDb9WX61KP
I would highly recommend the CRKT Chogan
OP you hit the jackpot, looks like its worth....30 bucks
http://www.amazon.com/Brook-Hunter-MT-W-AXE-Premium-Mo-Tool/dp/B001PTG8F6/ref=sr_1_9?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1452906789&amp;sr=8-9&amp;keywords=hatchet+multitool
I also vote for the Husqvarna ‘multi purpose axe’. Shaped like the other swede forest axes, in a ‘boy’s axe’ size which I prefer over the larger axes for most work.
$75 on Amazon
I've been a scout camp counselor for six years and used axes of all kinds including granfors and wetterlings. The Husqvarna 26in axe is made by wetterlings and is easily the very best axe for your money. That's really all I have to say. I would also never buy a strait handled axe for actual use (apart from a double sided axe, but even they have a flared pommel). Tomahawks are a different story but they arent for doing work.
If you have any questions hit me up.
I just copied what I saw in a wranglerstar YouTube vid. I purchased these three items and they will be my dedicated axe sharpening devices.
Any examples of it? I must admit I'm intrigued.
Edit: Found the culprit. https://www.amazon.com/Husqvarna-576926201-Curved-Wooden-Multipurpose/dp/B004WJGXAQ
CRKT Chogan Tomahawk:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00I04Q7LO/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_P9pEzb857T61B
With this sheath:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00M7H0LT4/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_.-pEzb5E6JBR0
If you wanted to buy one
I have an Estwing Tomahawk I can put up tomorrow.
an axe, and
[something to sharpen the axe](http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004ASUL4I
)
This is the one I've had for a couple of years.
https://www.amazon.com/Estwing-Fireside-Friend-Axe-Construction/dp/B000HAEI1A
Over time, the part you strike has deformed. I'll probably get a couple more years out of it. I split wood to ordinary chunks with a hydraulic splitter. I use this maul to break a few pieces down even more to get the fire going. For a weekend camping trip, a beer box full of smaller pieces is nice to have.
http://www.amazon.com/Estwing-Carpenters-Hatchet-Leather-Grip/dp/B0002JT0C8/
13" Legnth Weight 20oz. Cutting edge is 3.5/8in.
Remember that the lighter the axe head, the more work you have to do and the shorter the handle, the more dangerous. Unless you are 3 feet tall, boys axe or 3/4 axe with a 2.5lb head is in no way too small. The Husqvarna should be a good bet.